They'll be in the top 8 come the end of the year.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
News Shane McAdam traded to Melbourne for F2
- Thread starter Mostyn
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I had forgotten Melbourne held theirs and Sydney's 2nd round picks.
We got Melbourne's 2nd.
We got Melbourne's 2nd.
- Aug 5, 2013
- 2,573
- 2,312
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Melbourne may not have got anything out of him, but Adelaide didn't replace him with anything either.
The pick is this year.
Even if we replaced him last year or still had him, wouldn’t have solved our issues.
- Mar 20, 2013
- 5,178
- 5,314
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Will be pick 25-23 now (wins by either of GC or Saints will leapfrog them as now already better %)
While we didn’t replace McAdam with an upgrade (you could prob say it ended yo being mostly cook getting the chance) this season I’ll take that pick every time
While we didn’t replace McAdam with an upgrade (you could prob say it ended yo being mostly cook getting the chance) this season I’ll take that pick every time
We've been stuck with Murphy all year and will grab Neal-Bullen as a replacement for next year.
Haven't we done well
Do we really think McAdam would have finally have put it all together this year if he stayed with us?
If we're being real, this sort of year from him was always on the cards.
BTW, I think the pick order page on Bigfooty is wrong.
Pretty sure the McAdam pick is 27 right now, will be 25 if Suns and Saints win.
- Jul 6, 2017
- 31,706
- 45,559
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Who would have thought when we did that trade possibility getting a low 20's pick for him in a strong draft. If it ends at 23 there is a very outside possibility dodson may be on the board.
- Mar 20, 2013
- 5,178
- 5,314
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I just went by the ladder
18 teams and they’re 7th bottom
But is thee a priority pick or 2 in there afl gave north as future end 1st rounders to trade away ?
Indicative 2024 AFL Draft Order - Draftguru
www.draftguru.com.au
Edit: Actually, that page isn't up to date either
- Mar 20, 2013
- 5,178
- 5,314
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
There are 2 “special assistance” picks wedged in there at end of 1st so your right it is 27-25.Indicative 2024 AFL Draft Order - Draftguru
Edit: Actually, that page isn't up to date either
Neil-Bullen is a better player than both. Will be a substantial upgrade.We've been stuck with Murphy all year and will grab Neal-Bullen as a replacement for next year.
Haven't we done well
Would hope we're not giving pick 25-27 for him though.
Agreed. Why gift them back the “win” we had with the Melbourne second rounder because of their dismal season?
We finished in front there but there’s no reason we need to square the ledger.
Given that we traded away our 2024 second round pick last year in the upgrade to get Curtin, it's nice that the Melbourne second round pick will be almost as good as ours would have been. Currently sitting 12th, and likely to drop to 13th with Gold Coast set to play Richmond. Could even drop to 14th if Saint Kilda win as well.
It means our draft hand this year is pretty much intact.
It means our draft hand this year is pretty much intact.
Last edited:
Basically no different to had he been on our list this season anyways.We've been stuck with Murphy all year and will grab Neal-Bullen as a replacement for next year.
Haven't we done well
Great skill set but horrible durability and then there's our selection committee to go with it.
- Sep 3, 2018
- 5,307
- 7,005
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Has this turned out to be arguably the best trading out of a player we have done?
Didn’t like it at the time - but with the benefit of hindsight, him not playing essentially the whole year for Melbourne and us getting a good pick in a strong draft. Got lucky for once
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Didn’t like it at the time - but with the benefit of hindsight, him not playing essentially the whole year for Melbourne and us getting a good pick in a strong draft. Got lucky for once
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Still need to do something with the pick.
Bit early to tell. You'd be needing a good news story if you're hanging your hat on this already. That said, Melbourne's crap year has certainly impacted the outcome positively.
- Sep 3, 2018
- 5,307
- 7,005
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
On its own this worked out well for us - not through good planning but it has turned in to a fair pick for him- and we’ll overs compared to his output. Provided Cook a run at it as well.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Did I miss a retirement announcement?
If he had managed to stay injury free (but what are the odds of that?) we would unquestionably have been a better side in 2024 with McAdam still in it. But it's not like he was the difference between us pushing for a flag or not. He'll turn 30 next year, so still has a few years to prove his worth to Melbourne.
The task now is to do something worthwhile with the second-round pick. Most likely we will trade it to avoid having it just swallowed up by the Welsh bid.
The task now is to do something worthwhile with the second-round pick. Most likely we will trade it to avoid having it just swallowed up by the Welsh bid.
Similar threads
