Simpson and Scotland or Bateman and Young

[hazz33]

Who would you prefer as your 2 wings if you could choose 1 of the pairs 2 be your wings for the next 5 years

 

[Puddy]

Hard one.

Simpson is a brilliant player, Scotland very average while Bateman and Young are both very good players. Bateman and Young just get the nod for me

 

[Notorious_29]

Going by 2010, it would have to be Scotland and Simpson without a doubt. You didn't specify whether you meant currently or over their careers so I'll assume you meant who would you prefer on your wings atm.

 

[CrimsonRaven]

Scotland and Simpson by a mile on current form.

 

[blues4flag]

Hard one.

Simpson is a brilliant player, Scotland very average while Bateman and Young are both very good players. Bateman and Young just get the nod for me

Scotland has been one of our best players this season. 5th best at worst, with Judd, Simpson, Murphy and Russell making up the other 5.

 

[Turly]

depends is this on current form??? or overall, overall I would say young and bateman both have been awesome for us, and a big part in winning the flag in 08. On current form it would be scotland and simpson.

 

[Cynic]

Back in 2008 the Hawk Duo would be all over the Blues but this year it's not even close.

Next five years?

Scotland 29
Simpson 26
Bateman 28
Young 24

...uh...maybe Carlton simply as Simpson is much less of a risk than Young