Opinion Since 2000, when have you felt most invested with the Melbourne Football Club?

[Headless]

Just interested. Feels like I'm just cruising at the moment and am struggling to genuinely care about results.

I really enjoyed 2000-2006 but probably felt most invested around 2008-2011 or so, I reckon, so have voted 2009-2011 on this occasion.

 

[schmuttt]

2018-2020 purely because of how invested I was in 2018, went to 14 games from memory.

Was very invested in 2022, 2023 honestly I went to one game and was super frustrated with the team. Think that'll continue this year.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Whenever we have played entertaining football. No specific time period. Though 2019 is probably when I was least invested, didnt watch a single game for the rest of the season after ~ round 12. Ive never done that before.

 

[Headless]

Though 2019 is probably when I was least invested

Could be a thread in that.

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

I quite enjoyed the Paul Roos come up when we were crap though. Much more enjoyable than the past two years.

 

[Dory_77]

Went 2018-20. That finals droughtbreaker and even the shit follow up was a wild roller-coaster. Last couple of years have felt like a chore, but also had higher expectations so feel like there's less of those underdog kinda wins we had in previous periods

 

[schmuttt]

Went 2018-20. That finals droughtbreaker and even the s**t follow up was a wild roller-coaster. Last couple of years have felt like a chore, but also had higher expectations so feel like there's less of those underdog kinda wins we had in previous periods

Yep. In terms of picking a 3 year period where I was super invested each week I'd say 16/17/18 though, we had some great wins and played some really good footy.

 

[Daemon]

Great question. I actually can't answer myself as my memory is so bad, particularly the 2000s. Will be interesting to see the poll results.

 

[Bluelegs]

I picked 15-17 but would like to say 14-18.

Watching us from the start of the Rooms era, working our way out of the muck and into the finals was huge. But I switched off big time in 2019 when we immediately fell to pieces.

 

[Bluelegs]

I picked 15-17 but would like to say 14-18.

Watching us from the start of the Rooms era, working our way out of the muck and into the finals was huge. But I switched off big time in 2019 when we immediately fell to pieces.

Tommy Wiseau's The Melbourne Football Club

 

[Topkent]

2014-18 for sure.
The wins against Essendon with Roos punching the desk, beating Adelaide over there. Win in Geelong when Gawn showed up, beating Hawks at the G. All those wins ment something
Then the rise into 2018 and beating WC, celebration game at the G etc.

Prem year was great but by about 3 weeks into 22 I was bored AF of the style and I've really been numb ever since.

Even the players. Loved watching Garlett, Vanders, Jones, Jetta, Pedo, Cross etc

Hate half this current team

 

[Topkent]

Although for nostalgia I'd rather watch the 00-06 team.

Neitz Farmer Robbo Brown Walsh Ward Yze Vardy Etc so many watchable players.

 

[The Dr]

Tommy Wiseau's The Melbourne Football Club

'You're tearing me apart, Lisaaaaaa'

Kind of how I feel about Goody tbf


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Proper Gander]

2014-18 for sure.
The wins against Essendon with Roos punching the desk, beating Adelaide over there. Win in Geelong when Gawn showed up, beating Hawks at the G. All those wins ment something
Then the rise into 2018 and beating WC, celebration game at the G etc.

Prem year was great but by about 3 weeks into 22 I was bored AF of the style and I've really been numb ever since.

Even the players. Loved watching Garlett, Vanders, Jones, Jetta, Pedo, Cross etc

Hate half this current team

This is definitely my invested era. Also it was good as we slowly started to win more games each year. And since we weren’t yet winning lots they were special. I watched every win back half a dozen times.

 

[Jamurp]

15-18 for me. Roos coming to the club felt a bit unbelievable at the time, we were such a basket-case, glad he saw something in us. The improvement over those 3 years was great to see and we had some good wins amongst some tough losses.

Breaking the finals drought in 2018 was amazing and those two finals wins at the G against two clubs who had bullied us was epic, 90k crowds, mostly dees supporters too, felt unreal.

19 was garbage and 20 was a tease, 21 was amazing of course, last two seasons have been a grind and I'm really not keen on how we play anymore.

Feels like we're on the downward slope unfortunately.

 

[mrmonkey]

Although for nostalgia I'd rather watch the 00-06 team.

Neitz Farmer Robbo Brown Walsh Ward Yze Vardy Etc so many watchable players.

Yeah in terms of personel that period was really enjoyable but that period from 14-18 that was when I felt we have a core of a really good list.

 

[Proper Gander]

I think the whole premiership thing was a mistake.

From 2014 to 2018 you saw a team improve and grow, if going year to year it was very much linear growth. And with this there were fewer expectations but more anticipation.

Do you think we can give the flag back?

 

[Headless]

I think the whole premiership thing was a mistake.

Classic Dees.

 

[Scythe94]

Yeah, I do remember saying that if we just jagged a flag, I wouldn't care what happened for the next decade or two at least.

But then the flag was in Perth during COVID, we've since regressed to pure mid-table mediocrity, and even our wins have started feeling like a chore to watch. Careful what you wish for, I guess.

 

[Proper Gander]

Classic Dees.

It’s amazing to find a way to cast the veil of negativity over a premiership

 

[Headless]

Yeah, I do remember saying that if we just jagged a flag, I wouldn't care what happened for the next decade or two at least.

But then the flag was in Perth during COVID, we've since regressed to pure mid-table mediocrity, and even our wins have started feeling like a chore to watch. Careful what you wish for, I guess.

It’s amazing to find a way to cast the veil of negativity over a premiership

At least we have each other on this peaceful, calm board.

 

[Headless]

I've noticed nobody else has voted 2009-2011. It's almost like people here didn't secretly enjoy 186 etc.?

 

[Proper Gander]

Yeah, I do remember saying that if we just jagged a flag, I wouldn't care what happened for the next decade or two at least.

But then the flag was in Perth during COVID, we've since regressed to pure mid-table mediocrity, and even our wins have started feeling like a chore to watch. Careful what you wish for, I guess.

It’s all my fault.

As we approached the GF I quickly found God and said if he just let us win, that would do me for life and I’d never ask for anything again.

Post flag I quickly un-found God, but I think he is around somewhere reminding me of the terms and conditions of that little contract

 

[Headless]

It’s all my fault.

As we approached the GF I quickly found God and said if he just let us win, that would do me for life and I’d never ask for anything again.

Post flag I quickly un-found God, but I think he is around somewhere reminding me of the terms and conditions of that little contract

The 2021 finals series was about the only time I haven't been around the Melbourne board in nearing 20 years, so I guess it's my fault for returning.

 

[Proper Gander]

I've noticed nobody else has voted 2009-2011. It's almost like people here didn't secretly enjoy 186 etc.?

I loved them. The Dee’s really did become something