The U18 champs have the Larke medal but does the TAC U18 have a medal , a Brownlow so to speak and if so who has been the previous winners of the said award?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
TAC U18 Brownlow
- Thread starter Turbocat
- Start date
- Tagged users None
hawkapatto
Debutant
- Oct 4, 2002
- 129
- 0
- Other Teams
- HAWTHORN
Morrish Medal, won last year by Mungara Brown of the Northern Knights.
The Morrish Medal is voted on by the umpires in a traditional 3-2-1 format.
There is also the Coaches' Award which is voted on by the 2 coaches who give 5-4-3-2-1.
Neither is a great predictor for AFL success.
Morrish Medal
1992 - Brad Smith - Northern Knights
1993 - Dean Watson - Southern Stingrays
1994 - Gary Moorcroft - Northern Knights
1995 - Paul Hood- Geelong Falcons
1996 - Nathan Brown - Bendigo Pioneers
1997 - Derek Murray - Murray Bushrangers
1998 - Lenny Hayes - NSW/ACT RAMS
1999 - Matthew Stolarczyk - Gippsland Power
2000 - David Rodan - Calder Cannons
2001 - David Rodan - Calder Cannons
2002 - Luke Shackleton - Tassie Mariners
2003 - Mungara Brown - Northern Knights
Coaches Award
1992 - Brad Smith - Northern Knights
1993 - Angelo Lekkas - Northern Knights
1994 - Jason McFarlane - Gippsland Power
1995 - Jason Snell - Eastern Ranges
1996 - Tim Finocchiaro - Eastern Ranges
1997 - Matthew Bernes - Tassie Mariners
1998 - Steven Hazelman - Gippsland Power
1999 - Leigh Brown - Gippsland Power
2000 - Paul Carson - Western Jets
2001 - Bradley Miller - Western Jets AND Russell Grigg - Bendigo Pioneers
2002 - Blake Grima - Eastern Ranges
2003 - Colin Sylvia - Bendigo Pioneers
There is also the Coaches' Award which is voted on by the 2 coaches who give 5-4-3-2-1.
Neither is a great predictor for AFL success.
Morrish Medal
1992 - Brad Smith - Northern Knights
1993 - Dean Watson - Southern Stingrays
1994 - Gary Moorcroft - Northern Knights
1995 - Paul Hood- Geelong Falcons
1996 - Nathan Brown - Bendigo Pioneers
1997 - Derek Murray - Murray Bushrangers
1998 - Lenny Hayes - NSW/ACT RAMS
1999 - Matthew Stolarczyk - Gippsland Power
2000 - David Rodan - Calder Cannons
2001 - David Rodan - Calder Cannons
2002 - Luke Shackleton - Tassie Mariners
2003 - Mungara Brown - Northern Knights
Coaches Award
1992 - Brad Smith - Northern Knights
1993 - Angelo Lekkas - Northern Knights
1994 - Jason McFarlane - Gippsland Power
1995 - Jason Snell - Eastern Ranges
1996 - Tim Finocchiaro - Eastern Ranges
1997 - Matthew Bernes - Tassie Mariners
1998 - Steven Hazelman - Gippsland Power
1999 - Leigh Brown - Gippsland Power
2000 - Paul Carson - Western Jets
2001 - Bradley Miller - Western Jets AND Russell Grigg - Bendigo Pioneers
2002 - Blake Grima - Eastern Ranges
2003 - Colin Sylvia - Bendigo Pioneers
- Thread starter
- #4
The 2001 result is just jaw dropping. Withthe amount of talent around in 2001 not getting a gig.
bring on draft
Debutant
- Jul 7, 2004
- 111
- 0
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Morish medal
How the hell did Rodan win two morish medals? That's the eqivalent of Brian Wilson winning the brownlow!
How the hell did Rodan win two morish medals? That's the eqivalent of Brian Wilson winning the brownlow!
hbk
"here is an early tip for the morrish medal jarred moore or dale may! loved by the umpires"
i think you'll find that may isnt one of the umpires most loved players......his always trying to start players and the umpires spend half the game keeping an eye on him and his player so they dont get in a fight!
"here is an early tip for the morrish medal jarred moore or dale may! loved by the umpires"
i think you'll find that may isnt one of the umpires most loved players......his always trying to start players and the umpires spend half the game keeping an eye on him and his player so they dont get in a fight!
- Banned
- #11
Re: Morish medal
No.
Under 18 football is much diffrent to senior. I'm guessing Rodan was a midfielder for the Cannons and there is a slight chance he had a more mature body then most AND had been given more of a chance though his younger years.
No.
Under 18 football is much diffrent to senior. I'm guessing Rodan was a midfielder for the Cannons and there is a slight chance he had a more mature body then most AND had been given more of a chance though his younger years.
i don't think a calder player will win as there are to many good players getting in the best iregulary. A good bet would be Meeson from Geelong. as for "hawks2008" favaleki, bendigo haven't won enough games! Or a rough chance on late surge from pattison on the cards?
In junior footy it is very very rare to see dominant big-men. They take longer to develop and the rovers and centremen tend to play the better footy. Even the best big men tend to have good games and bad games and get shunted around from ruck, to forward to defence.
Often the best players don't play much footy as well. Deledio for example missed 3 games playing for Australia and another 3 as a result of the championships. In an 18 game season playing 6 less games counts. With school footy etc the number of guys who actually play midfield in all 18 weeks is pretty small, and one of them will normally win.
Another factor is that often the very best players are recruited after their first junior season and don't come back for a 2nd. Many of the medalists are 2nd year players (or 3rd year) who have established a reputation and can start the season well.
Finally, and opening a can of worms, at this level the umps don't see the players on TV etc and don't recognise them in many cases. Lots of good performances get missed. Guys who stand-out physically often get votes that they might not deserve. There weren't too many Fijians with a 'fro in the under-18s when Rodan won his two. Similar story with Mungara Brown when he won, wouldn't be suprised if Luan Marsh got close this year.
Often the best players don't play much footy as well. Deledio for example missed 3 games playing for Australia and another 3 as a result of the championships. In an 18 game season playing 6 less games counts. With school footy etc the number of guys who actually play midfield in all 18 weeks is pretty small, and one of them will normally win.
Another factor is that often the very best players are recruited after their first junior season and don't come back for a 2nd. Many of the medalists are 2nd year players (or 3rd year) who have established a reputation and can start the season well.
Finally, and opening a can of worms, at this level the umps don't see the players on TV etc and don't recognise them in many cases. Lots of good performances get missed. Guys who stand-out physically often get votes that they might not deserve. There weren't too many Fijians with a 'fro in the under-18s when Rodan won his two. Similar story with Mungara Brown when he won, wouldn't be suprised if Luan Marsh got close this year.
hothead said:
The Coaches Award locks away all the 4,3,2,1 votes and publishes the 5s each week in the record. The Morrish Medal is a normal count. The TAC team of the year is announced on the same night.
Murray are the only team who publish their coaches award voting. So you could work out how many Deledio has received this year.
http://murraybushrangers.footballvic.com.au
Does anyone know the format of the night?
http://murraybushrangers.footballvic.com.au
Does anyone know the format of the night?
The new site is www.murraybushrangers.com.au
inside info man
Debutant
does anyone have a list of who has been invited?
been trying to get my hands on the list but haven't been able to!
here is each clubs list of best chances
bendigo- faveleki, hill, carroll
calder- may, both smiths, jolly, iobaucci, becker
dandenong- moore, nayna, ongarello, stanley
eastern- knights, hocking, hill
geelong- sherringham, foss, lewis
gippsland- collins, polo, roughhead,
murray- deledio, egan. prior, wood
north ballart- rosa, driscoll, bateson
northern knights- pattison, gilbert, carnell
oakleigh- sharp, bain, hasset
sandringham- mohammed, beaumont, murphy
western- primsall, rose
what do you all think about my best chances for each club!
been trying to get my hands on the list but haven't been able to!
here is each clubs list of best chances
bendigo- faveleki, hill, carroll
calder- may, both smiths, jolly, iobaucci, becker
dandenong- moore, nayna, ongarello, stanley
eastern- knights, hocking, hill
geelong- sherringham, foss, lewis
gippsland- collins, polo, roughhead,
murray- deledio, egan. prior, wood
north ballart- rosa, driscoll, bateson
northern knights- pattison, gilbert, carnell
oakleigh- sharp, bain, hasset
sandringham- mohammed, beaumont, murphy
western- primsall, rose
what do you all think about my best chances for each club!
you are pretty spot on for gippsland
taylor collins was stiff to miss out on Vic Country selection, good midfielder
dean polo got all australian, he has some talent, roughhead is the same
steve foster has had a good year in the ruck
and shaun mooney in the backline has also been good but never got picked for vic country etc etc
he could be a roughie
i wouldnt really know about the other teams as i dont really follow the TAC cup to greatly
taylor collins was stiff to miss out on Vic Country selection, good midfielder
dean polo got all australian, he has some talent, roughhead is the same
steve foster has had a good year in the ruck
and shaun mooney in the backline has also been good but never got picked for vic country etc etc
he could be a roughie
i wouldnt really know about the other teams as i dont really follow the TAC cup to greatly
