- Moderator
- #1
Suprised theres not a thread here already.
References
Wilkie Speech to Parliament, Tuesday, March 26th, 2024
Mr WILKIE (Clark) (19:10): I rise to bring the House's attention to deeply troubling allegations of egregiousmisconduct within the AFL provided by former Melbourne Football Club president Glen Bartlett, former Melbourneteam doctor Zeeshan Arain and Shaun Smith, father of Melbourne player and now alleged drug trafficker Joel Smith.The allegations include: the prevalence of drug abuse and other illicit behaviour across the AFL; off-the-books drugtesting of players at Dorevitch Pathology in Heidelberg, facilitated by the former chief medical officer of the AFL,Peter Harcourt; the resting of players testing positive in these secret tests ostensibly on account of injury; wilfulinaction by AFL chairman Richard Goyder and former CEO Gillon McLachlan; and the removal of Mr Bartlett aspresident of Melbourne after he suggested to Mr Goyder and Mr McLachlan that AFL officials be regularly drugtested. The allegations are credible and detailed and provided in signed statements which have been given to meand which clearly identify the sources of the information.
The allegations are obviously deeply troubling, particularly the allegation of the systemic failure by the AFL toeffectively test for and prevent the use of prohibited drugs or to support or, where necessary, sanction players andofficials found to have used prohibited drugs. It's deeply troubling because such appalling behaviour endangers thelives, safety and future of players and officials, subverts the official drug testing conducted by Sport IntegrityAustralia on behalf of the World Anti-Doping Authority and is a fraud on the governments that provide millions ofdollars in support to the AFL, directly and indirectly, through tax breaks, grants and beneficial capital worksconditional on the AFL being a signatory to and complying with the World Anti-Doping Code. This is notconjecture, with Dr Arain describing the matter clearly in this signed statement here. He states:The off the books testing took place in Heidelberg Dorevitch. The former Chief Health Officer of the AFL, Peter Harcourt, gaveme the contact of the guy at Heidelberg who would do the testing.
Here is what happens as it has been described to me. The AFL wants a player to play at all costs, and so thecover-up begins. If there are no illegal drugs in the player's system, they are free to play. If there are drugs in theirsystem, the player is often asked to fake an injury. They are advised to lie about their condition while the results ofthe off-the-books tests are kept secret and never shared with Sport Integrity Australia or WADA. In other words,hundreds of thousands of Australians will watch the game not knowing that the game has been secretly manipulatedby the AFL. Thousands of Australians will also bet on that game not knowing that the game has been secretlymanipulated by the AFL. So the next time you hear a player has a hamstring injury you could be forgiven forwondering what's really going on.
But as Dr Arain also explains, this isn't just a Melbourne problem; it's an AFL problem, with multiple playerscoming to Melbourne from other teams with pre-existing cocaine dependencies more than suggesting that drug-testing workarounds are in fact commonplace elsewhere in the AFL. Moreover, the documents in my possessionalso indicate a shocking unwillingness by senior AFL executives to address drug abuse by players and executives,particularly in relation to cocaine usage. For instance, here are very detailed notes of a telephone meeting betweenGillon MacLachlan, Richard Goyder and Glen Bartlett.
Two things jump out at me from this record. The first is the cavalier way the AFL executives discussed MrBartlett's concerns about alleged cocaine use by Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin, which is reflected in this signedstatement by Mr Bartlett where he says he believes efforts were made by AFL executives and others to cover up MrGoodwin's alleged cocaine use, specifically hiding their concerns about the alleged drug use for up to 18 months.That seems to me to be well explained by Mr Bartlett's testimony where he states:
The second thing that jumps out at me is that Mr Bartlett made it clear to Mr Goyder and Mr McLachlan that heplanned to tackle cocaine abuse at his club at every level, including at the executive level, and, eight weeks afterthat, Mr Bartlett was unexpectedly pushed out of the AFL, despite having just recently been asked to serve aspresident for three more years. I will say that again. The highly regarded President of the Melbourne Football Club,Glen Bartlett, was dumped by the AFL just eight weeks after a meeting with AFL CEO Gillon McLachlan and AFLChair Richard Goyder where he suggested mandatory drug testing for AFL executives.
I've also obtained a signed statement from retired player Shaun Smith, the father of player Joel Smith, who is ofcourse under investigation for alleged cocaine trafficking to his teammates. In his statement, Shaun maintains thathis son had not been a cocaine user prior to joining the AFL and attributes his son's situation to the AFL's aidingand abetting of illegal drug use. To quote Shaun: "If I had known that there was a massive drug problem at the AFL when my son was 14, I would have said 'You're playingbaseball. You're playing something else.'To quote Shaun again:Something is not right when you get so many broken players."
And Shaun is absolutely right. The men and women of the AFL and the AFLW deserve so much better than the waythey are currently being treated by AFL executives. Remember, when players enter the AFL, they are often barelyout of their teens, and the culture they go into matters. But too many players are coming out broken, with addictionissues that had not been addressed and in fact had been enabled, because the players are currently being treated ascorporate cannon fodder, being expected to play at all costs, regardless of their health. In other words, for someplayers Aussie Rules turns out to be a game that destroys their lives forever. That must stop, because those of us inthe know are sick of hearing AFL executives talk about player welfare, when we now know they are actuallysabotaging player welfare.
Australian Rules football plays an incredibly important role in this nation's culture. To many footy fans, AussieRules is one of the most important things in their life. Indeed, many of us watch the games almost religiously. Wetake our children to Auskick clinics week after week. And, to be absolutely clear, I'm stoked that Tasmania is set tofinally have an AFL team. But it's exactly because of all that that we expect the AFL to act with integrity and notfor us to be left standing and sitting here tonight wondering just how many young lives have been ruined by illegaldrug use known to but not acted on by the AFL.
To be clear, the AFL is not a private company, and these matters are no ordinary drug scandal. No. The AFL isan entity regulated by the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission and receives hundreds of millionsof dollars in direct and indirect tax breaks, government grants and beneficial capital works. But the AFL is also bigbusiness, sustained in part by helping players secretly break the World Anti-Doping Agency code. As a result, it isnot an exaggeration to say that the off-the-books testing scheme I've described sees the AFL effectively involved ina multi-hundred-million-dollar fraud on governments and taxpayers.
Aussie Rules football is far too important to our nation for it to be damaged by the actions of some in the AFL,which is why tonight I call for intervention at the highest level and ask the Prime Minister to personally intervenein this matter, to study the documents in my possession and to do everything he can to restore and protect thereputation of our beloved game, because right now the term 'white line fever' has taken on a different and sinistermeaning at the AFL. To assist the House and the Prime Minister, I seek leave to table documents I've referred totonight.
The DEPUTY SPEAKER (Ms Claydon): Leave not granted.
Mr WILKIE: Deputy Speaker, could I just seek leave again?
The DEPUTY SPEAKER (Ms Claydon):Leave not granted.
Mr WILKIE: You want to hide these documents? That reflects shockingly on the government.
The DEPUTY SPEAKER (Ms Claydon): You don't have an opportunity to debate that, sorry. Thank you,Member for Clark.
References
- The AFL Illicit Drug Code (2021)
- The Australian Football Anti Doping Code (2021)
- The AFL Player Collective Bargaining Agreement 2023-2027
- Andrew Wilkies Speech to Parliament in Hansard (page 101)
- AFL Statement on the Illicit Drug Policy
- AFL Doctors Association Statement on the Illicit Drug Policy
- AFL Players Association Statement on the Illicit Drug Policy
Wilkie Speech to Parliament, Tuesday, March 26th, 2024
Mr WILKIE (Clark) (19:10): I rise to bring the House's attention to deeply troubling allegations of egregiousmisconduct within the AFL provided by former Melbourne Football Club president Glen Bartlett, former Melbourneteam doctor Zeeshan Arain and Shaun Smith, father of Melbourne player and now alleged drug trafficker Joel Smith.The allegations include: the prevalence of drug abuse and other illicit behaviour across the AFL; off-the-books drugtesting of players at Dorevitch Pathology in Heidelberg, facilitated by the former chief medical officer of the AFL,Peter Harcourt; the resting of players testing positive in these secret tests ostensibly on account of injury; wilfulinaction by AFL chairman Richard Goyder and former CEO Gillon McLachlan; and the removal of Mr Bartlett aspresident of Melbourne after he suggested to Mr Goyder and Mr McLachlan that AFL officials be regularly drugtested. The allegations are credible and detailed and provided in signed statements which have been given to meand which clearly identify the sources of the information.
The allegations are obviously deeply troubling, particularly the allegation of the systemic failure by the AFL toeffectively test for and prevent the use of prohibited drugs or to support or, where necessary, sanction players andofficials found to have used prohibited drugs. It's deeply troubling because such appalling behaviour endangers thelives, safety and future of players and officials, subverts the official drug testing conducted by Sport IntegrityAustralia on behalf of the World Anti-Doping Authority and is a fraud on the governments that provide millions ofdollars in support to the AFL, directly and indirectly, through tax breaks, grants and beneficial capital worksconditional on the AFL being a signatory to and complying with the World Anti-Doping Code. This is notconjecture, with Dr Arain describing the matter clearly in this signed statement here. He states:The off the books testing took place in Heidelberg Dorevitch. The former Chief Health Officer of the AFL, Peter Harcourt, gaveme the contact of the guy at Heidelberg who would do the testing.
Here is what happens as it has been described to me. The AFL wants a player to play at all costs, and so thecover-up begins. If there are no illegal drugs in the player's system, they are free to play. If there are drugs in theirsystem, the player is often asked to fake an injury. They are advised to lie about their condition while the results ofthe off-the-books tests are kept secret and never shared with Sport Integrity Australia or WADA. In other words,hundreds of thousands of Australians will watch the game not knowing that the game has been secretly manipulatedby the AFL. Thousands of Australians will also bet on that game not knowing that the game has been secretlymanipulated by the AFL. So the next time you hear a player has a hamstring injury you could be forgiven forwondering what's really going on.
But as Dr Arain also explains, this isn't just a Melbourne problem; it's an AFL problem, with multiple playerscoming to Melbourne from other teams with pre-existing cocaine dependencies more than suggesting that drug-testing workarounds are in fact commonplace elsewhere in the AFL. Moreover, the documents in my possessionalso indicate a shocking unwillingness by senior AFL executives to address drug abuse by players and executives,particularly in relation to cocaine usage. For instance, here are very detailed notes of a telephone meeting betweenGillon MacLachlan, Richard Goyder and Glen Bartlett.
Two things jump out at me from this record. The first is the cavalier way the AFL executives discussed MrBartlett's concerns about alleged cocaine use by Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin, which is reflected in this signedstatement by Mr Bartlett where he says he believes efforts were made by AFL executives and others to cover up MrGoodwin's alleged cocaine use, specifically hiding their concerns about the alleged drug use for up to 18 months.That seems to me to be well explained by Mr Bartlett's testimony where he states:
The second thing that jumps out at me is that Mr Bartlett made it clear to Mr Goyder and Mr McLachlan that heplanned to tackle cocaine abuse at his club at every level, including at the executive level, and, eight weeks afterthat, Mr Bartlett was unexpectedly pushed out of the AFL, despite having just recently been asked to serve aspresident for three more years. I will say that again. The highly regarded President of the Melbourne Football Club,Glen Bartlett, was dumped by the AFL just eight weeks after a meeting with AFL CEO Gillon McLachlan and AFLChair Richard Goyder where he suggested mandatory drug testing for AFL executives.
I've also obtained a signed statement from retired player Shaun Smith, the father of player Joel Smith, who is ofcourse under investigation for alleged cocaine trafficking to his teammates. In his statement, Shaun maintains thathis son had not been a cocaine user prior to joining the AFL and attributes his son's situation to the AFL's aidingand abetting of illegal drug use. To quote Shaun: "If I had known that there was a massive drug problem at the AFL when my son was 14, I would have said 'You're playingbaseball. You're playing something else.'To quote Shaun again:Something is not right when you get so many broken players."
And Shaun is absolutely right. The men and women of the AFL and the AFLW deserve so much better than the waythey are currently being treated by AFL executives. Remember, when players enter the AFL, they are often barelyout of their teens, and the culture they go into matters. But too many players are coming out broken, with addictionissues that had not been addressed and in fact had been enabled, because the players are currently being treated ascorporate cannon fodder, being expected to play at all costs, regardless of their health. In other words, for someplayers Aussie Rules turns out to be a game that destroys their lives forever. That must stop, because those of us inthe know are sick of hearing AFL executives talk about player welfare, when we now know they are actuallysabotaging player welfare.
Australian Rules football plays an incredibly important role in this nation's culture. To many footy fans, AussieRules is one of the most important things in their life. Indeed, many of us watch the games almost religiously. Wetake our children to Auskick clinics week after week. And, to be absolutely clear, I'm stoked that Tasmania is set tofinally have an AFL team. But it's exactly because of all that that we expect the AFL to act with integrity and notfor us to be left standing and sitting here tonight wondering just how many young lives have been ruined by illegaldrug use known to but not acted on by the AFL.
To be clear, the AFL is not a private company, and these matters are no ordinary drug scandal. No. The AFL isan entity regulated by the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission and receives hundreds of millionsof dollars in direct and indirect tax breaks, government grants and beneficial capital works. But the AFL is also bigbusiness, sustained in part by helping players secretly break the World Anti-Doping Agency code. As a result, it isnot an exaggeration to say that the off-the-books testing scheme I've described sees the AFL effectively involved ina multi-hundred-million-dollar fraud on governments and taxpayers.
Aussie Rules football is far too important to our nation for it to be damaged by the actions of some in the AFL,which is why tonight I call for intervention at the highest level and ask the Prime Minister to personally intervenein this matter, to study the documents in my possession and to do everything he can to restore and protect thereputation of our beloved game, because right now the term 'white line fever' has taken on a different and sinistermeaning at the AFL. To assist the House and the Prime Minister, I seek leave to table documents I've referred totonight.
The DEPUTY SPEAKER (Ms Claydon): Leave not granted.
Mr WILKIE: Deputy Speaker, could I just seek leave again?
The DEPUTY SPEAKER (Ms Claydon):Leave not granted.
Mr WILKIE: You want to hide these documents? That reflects shockingly on the government.
The DEPUTY SPEAKER (Ms Claydon): You don't have an opportunity to debate that, sorry. Thank you,Member for Clark.
