Top 50 Collingwood players 21st Century

Remove this Banner Ad

DaddyMac80

DaddyMac80

Debutant
Feb 8, 2022
117
119
AFL Club
Collingwood
Hey fellow Pies fanatics, here's my top 50 Magpies of the 2st century. Judged on a combination of impact, longevity and brilliance.


1. Scott Pendlebury
2. Steele Sidebottom
3. Dane Swan
4. Jack Crisp
5. Jeremy Howe
6. Darcy Moore
7. Nathan Buckley
8. Alan Didak
9. Jamie Elliott
10. Leon Davis
11.Brody Mihocek
12. Travis Cloke
13. Ben Johnson
14. Jordan De Goey
15. Ben Reid
16. Nick Maxwell
17. Brody Grundy
18. Anthony Rocca
19. Dale Thomas
20. Nick Daicos
21. Heath Shaw
22. Brayden Maynard
23. Josh Daicos
24. Heritier Lumumba
25. Scott Burns
26. Will Hoskin-Elliott
27. Taylor Adams
28. Mason Cox
29. Simon Prestigiacomo
30. Chris Tarrant
31. Josh Fraser
32. Tyson Goldsack
33. Adam Treloar
34. Dayne Beams
35. Alan Toovey
36. Travis Varcoe
37. Isaac Quaynor
38. Bobby Hill
39. Paul Licuria
40. Nathan Murphy
41. Shane O'Bree
42. Sharrod Wellingham
43. Tarkyn Lockyer
44. Jarryd Blair
45. Chris Mayne
46. Brent Macaffer
47. James Clement
48. Josh Thomas
49. Darcy Cameron
50. Tom Langdon
 
Last edited:
James Clement at 47? Wtf
 
DaddyMac80 said:
Hey fellow Pies fanatics, here's my top 50 Magpies of the 2st century. Judged on a combination of impact, longevity and brilliance.


1. Scott Pendlebury
2. Steele Sidebottom
3. Dane Swan
4. Jack Crisp
5. Jeremy Howe
6. Darcy Moore
7. Nathan Buckley
8. Alan Didak
9. Jamie Elliott
10. Leon Davis
11.Brody Mihocek
12. Travis Cloke
13. Ben Johnson
14. Jordan De Goey
15. Ben Reid
16. Nick Maxwell
17. Brody Grundy
18. Anthony Rocca
19. Dale Thomas
20. Nick Daicos
21. Heath Shaw
22. Brayden Maynard
23. Josh Daicos
24. Heritier Lumumba
25. Scott Burns
26. Will Hoskin-Elliott
27. Taylor Adams
28. Mason Cox
29. Simon Prestigiacomo
30. Chris Tarrant
31. Josh Fraser
32. Tyson Goldsack
33. Adam Treloar
34. Dayne Beams
35. Alan Toovey
36. Travis Varcoe
37. Isaac Quaynor
39. Bobby Hill
40. Paul Licuria
41. Nathan Murphy
42. Shane O'Bree
43. Sharrod Wellingham
44. Tarkyn Lockyer
45. Jarryd Blair
45. Chris Mayne
46. Brent Macaffer
47. James Clement
48. Josh Thomas
49. Darcy Cameron
50. Tom Langdon
Click to expand...

Great effort to compile this list.

You must rate Mayne as he is ranked 2 spots above Clement. Toovey 12 spots above. :)

Ranking Crisp higher than Buckley is also interesting.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Also I can’t understand Josh Thomas over stepho, let alone Ball or Mitchell
 
jathanas said:
Great effort to compile this list.

You must rate Mayne as he is ranked 2 spots
Click to expand...

jathanas said:
Great effort to compile this list.

You must rate Mayne as he is ranked 2 spots above Clement. Toovey 12 spots above. :)

Ranking Crisp higher than Buckley is also interesting.
Click to expand...
I do have a soft spot for Mayne. I'll never forget his 18 tackles in the 2018 GF.
I'm ranking Crisp's 9.5 seasons (2015-present) over Bucks' 8 (2000-2007).
Bucks missed plenty 9f footy over those years.
Crisp has missed. .... 0!
Wow.
 
ZEV said:
You have two 45’s and neither of them should be on the list
Click to expand...
Whoops .. fixed.

Josh Thomas gets extra points from me for overcoming the situation he put himself in.
He was on the list for over a decade, and was a big part of our almost magical 2018.

Stephonson was a flash in the pan, irreparably stupid kid who was gone after 3 seasons.
 
Taylor Adams has to be higher i mean ever since he came to Collingwood he was an absolute heart and soul player just a hard at it beast who played 9 seasons for us and from 2020-2022 was considered our best player just got very unlucky with injuries , 2nd best on in a granny just looking at his 2020 season 4th and 3rd in total clearances and tackles top 10 in disposals and contested
a best and fairest an all Australian 5th in coaches MVP, that season alone is one of the best of the 21 century of ofcource not really getting close to the individual seasons of pendels, swan, bucks, beams, naicos and sidey but deserves to be around the 18-20 mark could be wrong but just served so much for this club and got royally stiffed over with injuries and missed out on a premiership
 
My top 5 would be

Pendles
Buckley (no 1 if whole career considered but its close)
Swan
Cloke
Clement

Clement at 47 is way out. 146 games, 2x B&F, 2xAA, 2nd and 3rd in B&F also.

Others who should be higher

Licuria, Rocca, Beams
 
Key qualification fact:
Impact means, impact on our 21st century.
Anything 90s is irrelevant for the purpose of this list.
Sorry Bucks.
 
Always cheer on Mason Cox as I did Twiggy Dunn in the 70s but putting him at 28 in this list is really pushing things, esp with Bobby Hill at 38. To be frank was even surprised to see His Gangliness on it
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Top 50 Collingwood players 21st Century

Similar threads

Chief Ten Beers
AI facts: ChatGPT on Collingwood
Replies
1
Views
2K
Black_White
Black_White

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top