List Mgmt. Trade & Free Agency talk Pt 4

[Yappie dribbles]

Am I only one thinking cj is over rated and won't make it

 

[Mr Magic]

Probably because he f’ed up in Queensland and helped cost the club $100k.

I am not a politician, I only deal with what I can control

 

[Hoos]

Am I only one thinking cj is over rated and won't make it

Nope.

 

[Phar Ace]

Probably because he f’ed up in Queensland and helped cost the club $100k.

Yeah it happened and he is probably sick of the consequences and reminders, overt or otherwise - fresh start at another Club is probably the best thing for him really.

 

[Hoos]

I am not a politician, I only deal with what I can control

 

[Barunga Bullet]

Am I only one thinking cj is over rated and won't make it

Vickery mk2

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Am I only one thinking cj is over rated and won't make it

We have as a Club invested quite a bit of time, wages, coaching, fines in CCJ...whether he makes it or not is a moot point...we just need some adequate compo for our investment in him...

 

[Bojangles17]

GWS are very keen on Mac Andrew, who is likely to be available at Richmond’s pick-7, but won’t still be there at GWS’s pick-13. So their pick-2 is up for grabs, as GWS don’t need or want more midfielders.

So I can definitely see us packaging up 28, 38 & 42 (or a similar combo) to get Dogs pick-17. Then offer GWS 7 & 17 for pick-2 so we get Hobbs or Callaghan. GWS still get Mac Andrew at pick-7 and collect an extra first round pick in the process.

So we go to the draft with 2, 15, 26, 40 & 47.

If GWS are confident Mac Andrew gets to 7 they’ll do that deal and so should we, as nothing changes except we get Hobbs or Callaghan instead of Ward, and we get the same player as we would have at pick-15. We just don’t have the pick-17 but we may well get who we would have chosen at pick-26 anyway.

Get it done Tigers !


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

I tipped this,

 

[THE THIN MAN]

At least with CCJ, Richmond did not part with Pick 6, one of Silvagni recruitment decisions!

No Cookies | Herald Sun

No Cookies

www.heraldsun.com.au

 

[PremiershipTigers]

You know we don’t have to trade for Tarrant right? Bringing him in as a UFA won’t effect 38 if we’ve already traded it to the Dogs in a deal for 17.

Ie.

Step 1. Trade 38+whatever else for 17
Step 2. Bring in Tarrant as a unrestricted free agent
Step 3. Laugh because they can’t tax a pick we don’t have

Pretty sure we are not actually awarded the pick until the end of trade period, once all the FA moves have happened

 

[Hoos]

View attachment 1253007

No Cookies | Herald Sun

No Cookies

www.heraldsun.com.au

I don't know what's funnier; Carlton only getting a third round return for a #6 pick or the article describing him as a "playmaker".

 

[This Is Anfield]

I must be one of the other 10%.

Why would anyone give up a first rounder for Peter Wright?

I reckon 90% of us are in that 10%

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

At least with CCJ, Richmond did not part with Pick 6, one of Silvagni recruitment decisions!

View attachment 1253007

No Cookies | Herald Sun

No Cookies

www.heraldsun.com.au

Fecking hell SOS...the gift that keeps on giving! legend!

 

[Hoos]

I reckon 90% of us are in that 10%

Lol.

What did Essendon give up for him...second or third round pick? And what's he done since going there apart from kick 7 when the Dogs took a 3 week break before the finals?

 

[Rocco sifreddi]

Lol.

What did Essendon give up for him...second or third round pick? And what's he done since going there apart from kick 7 when the Dogs took a 3 week break before the finals?

think it was a 4th round pick.

 

[Hoos]

think it was a 4th round pick.

Even better, lol.

 

[Frustrated Tiger]

10 extra pages since last night... must be some news....brb after I check....

 

[Hoos]

10 extra pages since last night... must be some news....brb after I check....

I can save you some trouble.

 

[acr2751]

I am not a politician, I only deal with what I can control

then why are you dealing with this as you have no say in it

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

With respect I am going to take that as posturing.

So how can we negotiate to a better place.

Pies have lost their 2nd and third round futures so they have lost that advantage

I will take pick 22 for 38, 42 which is similar points.

I assume you want more and gravy so what do you want?

Agree the points are similar (pick 22 is worth 50 or so less if I remember correctly but the Pies don't really need more points and can lose a few points although they would lose some lower draft picks) but pick 22 is worth a lot more because of the player it gets you(and I think a lot of clubs would be interested). The tigers future 3rd a pick about 50 would not quite be enough. I think a future second a pick about 30 would be a little to high. So I think it might take a future 3rd going back the way of the tigers. Maybe a pick about 45. Feel free to change it up some more what do you think?

 

[David C]

You know we don’t have to trade for Tarrant right? Bringing him in as a UFA won’t effect 38 if we’ve already traded it to the Dogs in a deal for 17.

Ie.

Step 1. Trade 38+whatever else for 17
Step 2. Bring in Tarrant as a unrestricted free agent
Step 3. Laugh because they can’t tax a pick we don’t have

Suspect 38 cannot be traded until the free agent window closes.

 

[Frustrated Tiger]

then why are you dealing with this as you have no say in it

Should have checked your post first....absolute dribble..... ahh well, Day 2, let's do it again.

 

[M0557]

Am I only one thinking cj is over rated and won't make it

I am with you.

I'd be pushing for 40 + Tarrant for CCJ and move on. We ain't getting 20.

 

[LuKe2428]

Why do we have to pick up Tarrant as a free agent though?
He doesn’t have a contract so we can sign him after the trade/draft period.
We have done that with Mansell, Stack ect.

 

[Hoos]

Should have checked your post first....absolute dribble..... ahh well, Day 2, let's do it again.

So they gave me a choice; read every post in this thread as it happens on Day 2 of the trade borefest...or have a spot of heart surgery before lunch.