Yep thats correct there will be quite a few more delistings at the blues and probably 2 rookie upgrades in possibly sheehan and kerbatieh so our lowest live pick wont be that late id expect .
-
LIVE: Sydney v Brisbane Lions - 2:30PM AEST Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 61% chance -- What's your tip? -- Ticketing Buy, Sell -- Teams on Thurs »
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Grand Final
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round PF Winner: Still Me
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Trades that left you speechless
- Thread starter ljamest36
- Start date
-
- Tags
- afl trade trade period
- Tagged users None
who?
Is he worth those picks though? I wouldn't have thought
Kerbatieh? I thought he's just at Northern Blues and not Carlton-listed? Could be wrong
Depends where he is bid. 54 or higher we get him for free anyway. Isn't touted to go much earlier than that.
- Aug 27, 2007
- 13,487
- 11,803
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Everton_East Freo_Atalanta_Tranmere
Mitchell genuinely shocked me - even though it makes a lot of sense to both parties
But just the general nature of how it happened, plus there being next to no rumours circulating - or if there were, they certainly weren't getting much notable mention (not that I saw)
Just a wow trade all round. 10/10 would watch the reactions of posters to that trade again - particularly hawks and eagles posters.
But just the general nature of how it happened, plus there being next to no rumours circulating - or if there were, they certainly weren't getting much notable mention (not that I saw)
Just a wow trade all round. 10/10 would watch the reactions of posters to that trade again - particularly hawks and eagles posters.
The_Reaper
Hall of Famer
lewd
When you look at Carlton's trading overall it makes sense.
As part of the Gws deal we traded out a pick in the late 40s, and a pick in the 50s this year, and got back the giants future second (that was a side bar to marchbank etc).
The Hawthorn trade essentially reverses this - we gave up the giants future second, and got back a pick in the 40s and a late pick.
Remember, the giants future second is likely to be late 30s. Given that this is considered a deeper draft, we basically prefer pick 48 and 60 this year to 38 next year. No shenanigans there
It's hard for me to get past the Ryder trade. It's not so much that we lost a difficult-to-replace star, or that his reasons for leaving were dubious, or that we got minimal return for his quality/market value as per Ports contract offer. That all sucked.
No, the killer was that his teammates, and supporters, who had been denied a finals series the year before and then busted a gut/supported hard all year to see us make a final, were to find out on the eve of that final that he was leaving the club. What a complete dampener to throw upon us as we were getting excited to play North at the G...
So it's not so much the trade itself but the circumstances in which it became a fair accompli.
No, the killer was that his teammates, and supporters, who had been denied a finals series the year before and then busted a gut/supported hard all year to see us make a final, were to find out on the eve of that final that he was leaving the club. What a complete dampener to throw upon us as we were getting excited to play North at the G...
So it's not so much the trade itself but the circumstances in which it became a fair accompli.
This is massively underestimated. Richmond's record without Deledio in the last 4 years is 4-16. I can't help but think that his influence in the side in massively under-rated.
Stratts4Norm
Team Captain
- Sep 19, 2015
- 386
- 320
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
So they got hill for mayne in a way, freo killed this trade period
ExTasDeeMan
Cancelled
At the time Ben Holland for pick 21, actually still boggles the mind.
Calm down chuckles I was onboard for the 4peat until your team just failed no jealousy at all...love to think your reviled now you aren't winning flags huh?
Mitchell to West Coast is easily the most crazy trade I can recall. The game is only just entering a phase where player movement is more common and bizarre, but this just didn't make any sense.
In the AFL teams aren't going to give you good draft picks for older players, so trading them on is hard to justify unless you're looking to dump salary, and even still I reckon that would be really rare. Mitchell I'm pretty sure took less money halfway through this year and then he gets traded for absolutely **** all.
Mitchell has been the heart and soul of the Hawks along with Hodge, brought back them to relevance and I daresay he was continuing to have a huge influence on the club. Letting him end his career at the Hawks seemed inevitable. I can understand them getting rid of Lewis who clearly had some issues with the club at the end, but Mitchell nope.
In the AFL teams aren't going to give you good draft picks for older players, so trading them on is hard to justify unless you're looking to dump salary, and even still I reckon that would be really rare. Mitchell I'm pretty sure took less money halfway through this year and then he gets traded for absolutely **** all.
Mitchell has been the heart and soul of the Hawks along with Hodge, brought back them to relevance and I daresay he was continuing to have a huge influence on the club. Letting him end his career at the Hawks seemed inevitable. I can understand them getting rid of Lewis who clearly had some issues with the club at the end, but Mitchell nope.
- Aug 20, 2010
- 16,721
- 22,090
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Yeah this is the way I like to think about it. Hawks got 23 for Hill, Freo got Hill for Mayne. Makes sense in it's own way and means everyone is a winner.
Stratts4Norm
Team Captain
- Sep 19, 2015
- 386
- 320
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
I don't rate mayne anymore so i can't say Collingwood came out on top
- Aug 20, 2010
- 16,721
- 22,090
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Mitchell/Lewis.
- Whatever Port Adelaide were smoking when they got involved with the Hanley trade.
- Ryan Griffen
- Lance Franklin, going to a top team so soon after landing Kurt Tippett.
- Fevola, whilst trying to push out Bradshaw/Rischitelli etc. to get it done
- Whatever Port Adelaide were smoking when they got involved with the Hanley trade.
- Ryan Griffen
- Lance Franklin, going to a top team so soon after landing Kurt Tippett.
- Fevola, whilst trying to push out Bradshaw/Rischitelli etc. to get it done
Fremantle giving up pick 2 to get Chris Bond. Gee, I can remember him at Carlton. He was a goer with spirit but not very skilled. We traded him to Tigers. He was a good clubman everywhere he went but to think someone gave up a pick 2 in draft foh him still has me scratching head.
Port Adelaide giving up pick 8, pick 43, Hamish Simpson and Roberts for Shayne Breur of Geelong
Port Adelaide giving up pick 8, pick 43, Hamish Simpson and Roberts for Shayne Breur of Geelong
Who remembers Fremantle trading pick 4 for Tony Delaney ?
FMD
FMD
- Sep 14, 2005
- 18,419
- 18,675
How do you use BF if you don't watch enough of it to know who players are....
Thats Wright
Premiership Player
- Banned
- #149
Lids and Wells both crucial to their sides chances. Both pushed out the door.
Both teams would've been better off flicking their coaches than their most important players.
What happens when 2 sides finish 9th after drawing and exactly the same percentage?
Ease up. North are 28-21 without Wells in the same period. He's a good player and I'm sad to see him go but he doesn't have the same impact on North that Deledio has on Richmond...
Similar threads
