Travis Cloke Vs Colin Sylvia

[Zeke]

No contest in my most humble opinion. Travis has it all over Sylvia.

Colin Sylvia:  8 games / 58 disposals @  7.25 / 18 marks @ 2.25 / 2 goals @ 0.25
Travis Cloke:  2 games / 29 disposals @ 14.50 /  7 marks @ 3.50 / 2 goals @ 1.00

I know it's early days, but I have a feeling that Trav will continue to make Sylvia look like a mere VFL wonder for years to come.

 

[Yze_Magic]

You always bring up meaningless stats

Why dont you show us their stats at VFL level where they play full games?

And how about the Time on Ground for both players in their AFL games?


Sylvia has it over Cloke in every facet of the game

 

[macca_2111]

Cloke has played two games, if he's anything like his brothers he will be another dud. Dont get your hopes up yet Collingwood supporters

 

[Zeke]

You always bring up meaningless stats

Is the fact the the kid you have dubbed 'the next Gary Ablett Snr' has kicked 2 goals in 8 matches a meaningless stat?

Sylvia has it over Cloke in every facet of the game

Ok, that's your opinion, now provide some evidence.

 

[Longy413]

And how about the Time on Ground for both players in their AFL games?

Does that mean he isn't doing enough with his time on the ground to command more game time?

 

[Yze_Magic]

Sylvia is stronger, quicker, more polished, more skilled, will kill the opponent in a tackle, a vastly superior leap, a better mark...


And that is why stats of 2 players that have played less than 10 games are meaningless

 

[dascman03]

Zeke FFS get ur hand off it

 

[Zeke]

Sylvia is stronger, quicker, more polished, more skilled, will kill the opponent in a tackle, a vastly superior leap, a better mark...

Sylvia has shown nothing at senior level to suggest he will be anything but an honest toiler. Travis, on the other hand has show a lot in just 2 games. It's not gospel, but it's a pretty damning indication at this stage.

 

[m.diddy]

No contest in my most humble opinion. Travis has it all over Sylvia.

Colin Sylvia:  8 games / 58 disposals @  7.25 / 18 marks @ 2.25 / 2 goals @ 0.25
Travis Cloke:  2 games / 29 disposals @ 14.50 /  7 marks @ 3.50 / 2 goals @ 1.00

I know it's early days, but I have a feeling that Trav will continue to make Sylvia look like a mere VFL wonder for years to come.

He is suppose to be the best tackler in the game where are the stats there?

 

[dees 4 life]

Sylvia is stronger, quicker, more polished, more skilled, will kill the opponent in a tackle, a vastly superior leap, a better mark...

And his last name is CLOKE!!

Sylvia will be a better player.

 

[Zeke]

And his last name is CLOKE!!

Sylvia will be a better player.

His name is Cloke, so he must be a hack?

Spose that means Wayne Carey was a rubbish footballer cause his brother wasn't up to AFL standard.

 

[dees 4 life]

His name is Cloke, so he must be a hack?

You hit the nail right on the head there big fella...

 

[guess_who]

Why dont you show us their stats at VFL level where they play full games?

Cloke has played what 3 VFL Games maybe 4? been in the best for at least two of them.

 

[m.diddy]

Would take a good young KPP player over a good young midfielder any day of the week.

 

[dees 4 life]

Cloke has played what 3 VFL Games maybe 4? been in the best for at least two of them.

That seems to be enough to compare two players these days

 

[cs61]

Cloke hasn't done jack.

 

[Pieyed]

Cloke has played two games, if he's anything like his brothers he will be another dud. Dont get your hopes up yet Collingwood supporters

Well we cant all pass up Judd for Hodge like you genius's

 

[Silvagnis]

I'd rather have Cloke due to his potential as a key forward, rather than a guy who exceeds at lower levels due to his bulk but as always can't cope at the higher grade. Having said that I'd still rather Franklin or Roughead than a Cloke!

 

[parrot]

Tough call, both would be useful for the Bullants.

 

[Nightwolf]

1 handball boy certainly looks the goods. I enjoy watching his 1 handball each week....quality stuff

 

[Sylvia Saint]

1 handball boy certainly looks the goods. I enjoy watching his 1 handball each week....quality stuff

Considering that has only happened once in his career and everything...

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Cloke but Zeke, if Cloke is so much better than Sylvia why start this thread to make certain that you'll win.

 

[m.diddy]

1 handball boy certainly looks the goods. I enjoy watching his 1 handball each week....quality stuff

Not as good as the golden Boy Cam Hunter who had 1 kick and that was smothered.

 

[Zeke]

Cloke but Zeke, if Cloke is so much better than Sylvia why start this thread to make certain that you'll win.

Huh?

 

[oooze]

COMPARISONS
KICKING DISTANCE: EQUAL
VERTICAL JUMP: SYLVIA BY A BLOODY MILE(Look at the draft camp stats)
TACKLING: SYLVIA BY A ********ING MILE
PACE: EASILY SYLVIA (Look at the dreamteam stats)
OVERHEAD MARKING: SYLVIA FOR HIS SIZE IS MUCH GREATER
ARROGANCE: sYLVIA HAS THAT TOUCH OF ARROGANCE THAT MANY GOOD PLAYERS HAVE I.E AKERMANIS, VOSS, CAREY ETC

GAME SET MATCH