-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Welcome Welcome To Freo Shai Bolton!!!
- Thread starter Tonga Bob
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,252
- 87,322
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I'd argue Jeff was more mercurial, Sonny the better Freo player
- Mar 25, 2020
- 2,244
- 5,860
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
freo84
Norm Smith Medallist
Shaiken not shaitirred
He would love for us to do that because he is a known Freo hater.
Last edited:
But it wasn't to say where Walters was in relation to Farmer, just in relation to the rating of "not exciting".
Although, while we're here, I'm not to sure many of our players have kicked 6 goals and had 32 disposals in a game like Sonny did.
Taylor
Community Leader
- Moderator
- #332
But it wasn't to say where Walters was in relation to Farmer, just in relation to the rating of "not exciting".
Although, while we're here, I'm not to sure many of our players have kicked 6 goals and had 32 disposals in a game like Sonny did.
Far out, give Bolton a minute
- Dec 26, 2010
- 5,901
- 7,827
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Matildas
I think Parceleet's post might be correct that Perth wasn't one of the clubs originally aligned with Fremantle, but when I went with what I remembered and what is written in some draft histories, I just got more confused.
One of Fremantle's concessions for a list build when we entered the AFL was that we could pick players from half of the sides in the WAFL competition for the first two years of drafting and EF was one of those. I think that is why Ben Cousins was eligible for Fremantle because he played colts and league for EF, even though his father Bryan Cousins played for Perth. His father/son eligibility was for Geelong/WC.
I got a feeling Claremont was originally one of the 4 Freo aligned clubs to help build an AFL list, and then they changed it for F/S purposes to make it WAFL teams north of the river for WC, WAFL south of the river for Fremantle Dockers. It might have happened when Peel came into the competition in 1997 or might have been changed more than once.
It's hard to work out because when you look at what's called the Zone selections that Fremantle had at the end of 1995 (the draft that WC took Cousins) - the players Fremantle selected are from 5 WAFL clubs. They are: Michael Brown, Michael Clark (Swans) Trent Carroll, Gavin Mitchell, Greg Harding (Claremont), Steven Koops, Martin Whitelaw (WP) Brendon Feddema (EF) James Clement, Phil Matera (SF) ( Matera was picked and traded to WC for David Hynes and Pick 3)
Zone Selection players in 1994 were:
Travis Edmonds, Todd Menegola (SD) Clinton Wolf, John Hutton (Clar). Except for Wolf, they're also players recycled from previously being on other AFL lists.
When they first tried the AFL/WAFL alignments (as we have now with Peel and Fremantle) in 1999 Claremont was with West Coast for a year, but Claremont ditched them and EP became their aligned club. Fremantle was with South Fremantle.
Darren Bolton was a Peel Thunder player who only played one season at South Fremantle because of that alignment, although Shai played colts for South Fremantle.
Last edited:
Yep as I recall it Cousins was eligible to be listed by us by virtue of playing for EF; by the slime because his Dad played for Perth; and by Geelong because Brian played for them too (back when it was minimum 50 VFL games, not 100 like it is now.)
There was a required number of WAFLgames that had to be played as well. It was that silly, it was almost impossible for Fremantle, and maybe the Eagles, to actually select FS to be part of the team.
The rules were entirely different and still are for the VFL clubs.
I remember that Fremantle had five clubs, but wasn't sure that WP were one. I thought it may have been EF, SF, Claremont, Swans and Perth. But obviously I was wrong.
What? Nothing to do with Bolton really.
- Nov 9, 2001
- 2,265
- 8,701
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- are listed below us on the ladder
I often wonder what happened to that kid in the huge beanie you can see from 2:20 on, after Farmer buries the Dees.
I seem to remember the same as you that SF, EF, Swans, Perth and Claremont were aligned to Freo in the very early days?
Shaidreams
Its the power Optus, combined with the power of Katanning. Its something that no one really understands.
Remember the dreamtime at the G that was played at Optus. Bloke absolutely went off.
james haish
All Australian
- Apr 6, 2024
- 850
- 1,777
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I know Damian Barrett is a muppet, but if 34 goals in the bottom side to be their leading goal kicker is “checked out” then we don’t even need him to check in
- Nov 9, 2001
- 2,265
- 8,701
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- are listed below us on the ladder
Dusty mustn't be a great then.
I don’t think you should pay this much for a player unless they are Brownlow/Coleman medallist level but it’s done now and was extremely predictable by Freo so I’ve moved on.
I don’t actually think he will turn us into a scoring juggernaut purely as a fwd as his averages over the past 4yrs (including his AA) suggest he only kicks about 5 more goals a year than Schultz. I do feel he will add more to our midfield mix and that combined with his scoring is exciting.
Charlie Cameron produced most of his best footy older than Shai so his age doesn’t worry me but please god keep him fit.
I don’t actually think he will turn us into a scoring juggernaut purely as a fwd as his averages over the past 4yrs (including his AA) suggest he only kicks about 5 more goals a year than Schultz. I do feel he will add more to our midfield mix and that combined with his scoring is exciting.
Charlie Cameron produced most of his best footy older than Shai so his age doesn’t worry me but please god keep him fit.
We were actually a high scoring team for the last half of the season anyway
This was without the small forwards really doing much, it was our midfielders turning into goal scorers
He is just going to add to that progress
- Nov 7, 2018
- 2,125
- 6,923
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
My main sense of excitement about him is not just how many goals he kicks but the way he kicks them.
He is a beast one on one and can be a true target/option if Tracy and Amiss have worked up the ground to help our transition into the forward line.
He is a defenders nightmare.
He is a beast one on one and can be a true target/option if Tracy and Amiss have worked up the ground to help our transition into the forward line.
He is a defenders nightmare.
- Apr 26, 2011
- 10,981
- 13,505
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Wimbledon AFC
Walters was pretty bad this year.
Is he a replacement for Walters ?
Walters traditionally has played roaming into the
midfield during games.
Still missing a genuine small.
Is he a replacement for Walters ?
Walters traditionally has played roaming into the
midfield during games.
Still missing a genuine small.
It's a general comment about the replies I'm seeing here. People posting their opinions and getting swarmed by others because it's not "Bolton=Flag". This isn't something personal to me.
Forums are places for debates for sure. But the responses that some opinions are inviting are personal attacks and borderline bullying.
Personally, couldn't give a shit what people thought of my opinions. If I don't do it in real life I'm not doing it here:
I don't rate Bolton highly
I think we overpaid and should have gone to the draft
I still believe we need a mature KPD because of stocks are thin
JOM earned his contract last year.
Don't give a **** if people don't agree.
Snuffaluphagus
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 10, 2015
- 25,252
- 87,322
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
KPD stocks are thin - I just dont understand how that's a discussion. How many do we need...
Last edited:
Pearce injury prone, Cox not a true KPD, Draper and Davies not there on development yet and McDonald both average and injury prone.
