Game Day West Coast v Richmond: aka A Get Smart rerun of CONTROL v KAOS

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sep 12, 2013
9,614
26,584
10 min from Optus
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Lakers Claremont
Round 7 sees West Coast take on the Tigers at 6.10 on Friday 29th April
also billed as
The Remake of Get Smart – Kaos v CONTROL


1650861733566.png 1650861753942.png



When the AFL commercial greedy suits set this game in the schedule, this was meant to be the 2 biggest clubs in the land (in terms of memberships at least) going for a head-to-head battle royal. A TV Ratings bonanza.

Strange as it seems, it is now being billed as the battle of the has been. This fixture features the team in position 17 with a 1-5 win loss hosting the team in position 12 with a 2-4 win loss. It only goes to show how quickly the cliff comes.

Now we can hear excuses from both teams. For the Tigers, no Dusty or Edwards but the majority of their best 22 is available. For West Coast, no NicNat, no Gaff, no Guv and the Eagles have been fairly harshly hit by Covid and a piss poor Strength and Conditioning team. That was further tested with Simpson insisting on his selection plan of credits in the bank and backing in your champions. That has meant that there are a bunch of Eagles not having played or trained together who cannot run out games, more comfortable social distancing and unable to put much pressure of the opposition.


Round 13 2021
1650861899379.png

To best understand this game, we are wise to go back to our previous encounter – round 13 on Sunday 13th June 2021. At that point, it was a battle of the heavy weights who had won the last 4 premierships. Richmond had just won an enthralling Dream Time at Optus and West Coast with a much-depleted team had just derailed the Teague Train and even broken the SCG hoodoo.

The match on the 13th was relatively low scoring but a cliff hanger. A battle of the heavyweights and an entertaining game.



But what nobody could have imagined was that since that night, Richmond have won 4 games, draw 1 and lost 10 games (finishing in 12th position at the end of 2021) and West Coast have won 3 games and lost 12 games (finishing in 9th position at the end of 2021).

It is fair to say that the teams are in transition. Neither club has publicly made statement to the supporter bases but the age profiles are rivelling Geelong.

Two of the great Clarkson proteges in Hardwick and Simpson butting heads with 2 very different styles of football. Richmond still play the chaos game, albeit Melbourne has taken their game style to a new level. West Coast still play the controlled possession game and to be fair, are probably the best at it. Reason being nobody plays it anymore as it is outdated.

So what does that provide for us on Friday. Firstly, having suffered from a bout of Covid and got the big “positive text” on Saturday morning, I will not be able to attend. Thank flock for that. Secondly, the game starts at Melbourne convenient time so anyone based in Perth will still have a decent night out after the game. That is assuming we get close to a full 75% capacity. Finally, the sooner Simpson admits that we cannot make finals, the better it will be for West Coast fans to see some of that enthusiasm in see new players, young midfielders played in the midfield, new game strategies, new ball movement, etc


My prediction:- KAOS to win by 4 shoe phones.
1650861978638.png
 

Attachments

  • 1650861768125.png
    1650861768125.png
    514.4 KB · Views: 151
Age profile

1651199276754.png

Simpson goes back to back in your champions with credits in the bank.

Not a single player under 21 and only 2 players that by Friday will be under 22.

We might be looking at a rebuild but the Match Committee has not year about that.

What feels worrying (Geelong like) is that we have 6 players over 30 or 27% of our team and that does not include NicNat.

Our three under 22 players of West, XON and Edwards are like but plugs - in and out depending on who our weekend date is. Never sustained and never in clear and consistent positions.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

A small mercy will be if Richmond decide Dusty isn't ready to go. It will slightly reduce the final margin

Can we just bring in our B team that played against North and Collingwood and tell them to play for their lives again?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Now we can hear excuses from both teams. For the Tigers, no Dusty or Edwards but the majority of their best 22 is available. For West Coast, no NicNat, no Gaff, no Guv and the Eagles have been fairly harshly hit by Covid and a piss poor Strength and Conditioning team. That was further tested with Simpson insisting on his selection plan of credits in the bank and backing in your champions. That has meant that there are a bunch of Eagles not having played or trained together who cannot run out games, more comfortable social distancing and unable to put much pressure of the opposition.

Way off the mark ATG.

Maybe plenty of excuses from Richmond, but be assured there will be no excuses from West Coast.

Have you not notices Simpson doesn't do excuses.

At West Coast its reasons ........... more reasons ........ and even more reasons.

Our game plan may be outdated, but our terminology is ever evolving.
 
Richmond coming off a 5 day break and travel. I can see us winning.
With Richmond having the short break and travel I can see them coming to a stop midway through the third quarter.
Unfortunately, as evidenced by the past two matches, we'll have come to a total standstill at some point in the first half (or even earlier).

I can see 44 players reluctant or unable to leave the 3/4 time huddles and the fourth quarter consisting of 36 guys standing around looking at each other and hoping the ball stays at the other end of the ground while the other eight sit very still on the bench, hoping the coach won't notice them and send them back out to walk around a bit more.
 
I miss the days when posters would boldly put their manhood on the line such was the confidence in our team at the time. Only feels like yesterday.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top