-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Who is the better player? West or Mitchell.
- Thread starter Chichie
- Start date
- Tagged users None
west, only because he has maintained his form for many seasons, Mitchell has to do the same thing to be considered, right now i think mitchell just though, but i think west at his best has not been achieved by Mitchell as yet.
The_Flying_Egg
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jul 15, 2001
- 8,225
- 2,975
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Barnsley FC, Melbourne City, Bulls
West is a veteran and has shown no signs of slowing down. He is having a great year even by his standards and I think he's having a better season than Mitchell. West's last 5 weeks have been some of the best of his career and he will go close to winning the Brownlow
Mitchell is a gun and should will have a great career. Hawthorn fans should be rapt if he does what West has in his career
Mitchell is a gun and should will have a great career. Hawthorn fans should be rapt if he does what West has in his career
Contradiction?dipper86 said:
Scott West at the moment.
Sam Mitchell a tad overrated at the moment IMO
Sam Mitchell a tad overrated at the moment IMO
CrAckDoGGer
Team Captain
has micthell won 6 b&f's,been an all-australian on numerous occasions,toured with australia against ireland and been captain for a season like Scott West has? the answer is no
weagles_fan said:
what! having a bit of trouble understanding, I said west overall, because he has been so consistent over many years, I think right at this moment Mitchell is a better player, but west at his best and mitchell at his best, west has been the better. Even though west is having a great year i still think he was a better player 3 or 4 years ago.
Thank you.
celtic_pride said:
yeh i know, a player that has one the rising star award, one the most clearances in his first year, and i think winning them this year, one of the best in and under players in the league right at the moment, man you should watch abit more footy.
And disposes of it sideways or backwards almost every time.dipper86 said:
I think you should be using these school holidays to brush up on your english little boy.dipper86 said:
- Banned
- #12
Overall: Scott West
2005: Sam Mitchell
2005: Sam Mitchell
Coondog 17
Team Captain
BomberAUS said:
You obviously didn't see West giving Mitchell a football lesson a few weeks ago.
Mitchell is good but at this stage is not in the same league as West.
west
mitchell is a young gun, but shouldn't be compared with west,
west is an absolute champion and one of the most underated players going around IMO
mitchell is a young gun, but shouldn't be compared with west,
west is an absolute champion and one of the most underated players going around IMO
doesn't mean that mitchell hasn't had a good or better year than west this year, mitchell is almost all australian form.Coondog 17 said:
west by a fair margin overall though.
weagles_fan said:
still having a bit of trouble understanding? ogh well the world needs toilet cleaners, Thats one job that doesn't involve you reading, you can just go by the signs! hmm maybe not! you might have trouble recognising what the female sign is compared to the male sign, instead you could just wait outside and see which gender goes into which toilet. but in your case your better of just cleaning the disabled toilet.
There you go, enjoy your new life.
Scott West is infinitely better than Sam Mitchell.
West is having a better season than Mitchell this year as well.
West is one of the Brownlow favourites, and towelled Mitchell up in their head to head meeting in round 11.
West is having a better season than Mitchell this year as well.
West is one of the Brownlow favourites, and towelled Mitchell up in their head to head meeting in round 11.
- Banned
- #18
I can't believe this is even a poll.
After what West did the Mitchell when we played the Hawks it was clear cut that West is 10 times the player Mitchell will ever be.
After what West did the Mitchell when we played the Hawks it was clear cut that West is 10 times the player Mitchell will ever be.
- Banned
- #19
dipper86 said:
Hmmmm, so the 9 possessions a 1 clearance when playing on West meant nothing?
Scott West
Swifty_446 said:
I thought he actually got 18 possies for the game, considering our side was well beaten. it wasnt a bad effort, he did have the better of him that day, but i still think Mitchell has had a better season than west,just though, overall West is the man because he has done this consistently over many seasons.
Swifty_446 said:
so your basing this on one game this year, players arnt allowed to have bad games, earlier on in the year Bannister killed hird, does that make bannister 10 times the player Hird will ever be.
I still think Mitchell has had a better year.
Swifty_446 said:
The Hawk midfield did comfortably account for the Hound midfield late last season, which only proves that basing hypothetical judgements on isolated one-off encounters is an exercise for half-wits.
That being said, West has the edge on Mitchell both in career terms and for this season to date.
Coondog 17
Team Captain
CyberKev said:
Half-wits say's the bloke that comparing midfields when the thread has been about two individuals.
I find players going head to head in non negating roles an excellent indicator of abilities.
CyberKev said:
Which is most likely why West was clearly too good for Mitchell a few weeks ago.
so west beats mitchell once this year, one of mitchells only average games for the year, and that proves everything? Crawford beat Judd easily when he played on him... does that mean Judd isn't comparable to Crawford? Its pretty lame logic some of you dog fans are using. No one denying that West is better overall (mitchell is only 21 by the way) but Mitchell has had a awesome year, and would be up there for All Australian.Swifty_446 said:
Similar threads
