Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[Fadge]

Has Squibby ever had a finals game as good as this?

View attachment 2194802

Was that am Elimination Final or Semi Final?

LOL.

We keep Daicos for Preliminary Finals and Grand Finals.

 

[Fadge]

If Nick doesn't get 7 BOGs in 2025, can we all concede that he has peaked in 2024 ?

Yeah, because that's how it works...

 

[Fadge]

Cox and McStay finals specialist apparently. Problem was, only 1 side in the history of the game was good enough to play finals from 9th and it wasnt Collingwood

Such a sick burn.

Keep them coming.

'Carlton played finals from 9th, so cop that!'

 

[Fadge]

No prize this century mate, haven't you been paying attention? I haven't heard one Blues supporter say we are the perfect side, we are a work in progress and if you take offence at anything in here i can't help you

'Work in progress'.

FMD.

 

[Fadge]

finishing higher than Collingwood by percentage was sweet- I'm in laugh at you land carrying a big grin -

but thanks for asking!

A highlight of Carlton's 21st Century...

Finishing higher than Collingwood (by percentage) in 2024.

'A Year For The Ages...'

 

[Arr0w]

A highlight of Carlton's 21st Century...

Finishing higher than Collingwood (by percentage) in 2024.

'A Year For The Ages...'

Actually happened in 2021, too

 

[Fadge]

Actually happened in 2021, too

Oh wow.

Twice in the last 23 years!

 

[Arr0w]

Oh wow.

Twice in the last 23 years!

And taken you 40 odd years to draw level on the flag count

Powderpuffs

 

[YeoShuey]

Cerra LoL.

We just prefer the bloke who has stood up in big finals.

I'm sure his 7-10 disposals, and 1 goal or less per final made a HUGE difference.

 

[Fadge]

I'm sure his 7-10 disposals, and 1 goal or less per final made a HUGE difference.

Put your argument forward for Cerra having a greater career output to date than Mason Cox.

Go.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

So that was an Elimination Final and Semi Final?

What are they?

Ahhh it includes a prelim...

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Was that am Elimination Final or Semi Final?

LOL.

We keep Daicos for Preliminary Finals and Grand Finals.

Answer the question though Fudger... U seem to have such an issue with that...

Has Squibby ever played a finals game as good as Walsh?

 

[YeoShuey]

Put your argument forward for Cerra having a greater career output to date than Mason Cox.

Go.

I'm happy to answer after you answer this one which you have avoided a numerous few times.

On what basis is Cox currently better than Walsh

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Put your argument forward for Cerra having a greater career output to date than Mason Cox.

Go.

Well for one, Cerra got more coaches votes in 2023 alone than Cox has for his entire career... He's also had far better individual games if ur using that ridiculous beat 10 games nonsense.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I'm happy to answer after you answer this one which you have avoided a numerous few times.

He won't answer it. He knows it's indefensible.

 

[Fadge]

Ahhh it includes a prelim...

What? The 34 possession, 2 goal game you highlighted in the post I commented on?

 

[Fadge]

Well for one, Cerra got more coaches votes in 2023 alone than Cox has for his entire career... He's also had far better individual games if ur using that ridiculous beat 10 games nonsense.

Ok, list the top 10 games from Cerra and Cox's career, if it's that compelling.

Or put a general case forward for Cerra having greater career output than Cox.

Go.

 

[Arr0w]

Ok, list the top 10 games from Cerra and Cox's career, if it's that compelling.

Or put a general case forward for Cerra having greater career output than Cox.

Go.

You list them, you made the claim that Cox is better than Cerra, prove it

Go

 

[Fadge]

Has Daicos ever played a finals game as good as Walsh?

Daicos' 2023 Grand Final, against the best opposition in the biggest game, is better than any final Walsh has played against inferior opposition in inferior games.

And Daicos did it in his second season, as a 20 year old, coming off a leg injury that would have ended most players' seasons.

 

[YeoShuey]

He won't answer it. He knows it's indefensible.

You list them, you made the claim that Cox is better than Cerra, prove it

Go

How did I know he'd completely dodge the Walsh question once again?

 

[doppleganger]

I'm sure his 7-10 disposals, and 1 goal or less per final made a HUGE difference.

Yeah his averages look as good as Charlie.

Everyone knows big Mason's big finals game, what are Cerra's big finals contributions?

 

[Fadge]

Well for one, Cerra got more coaches votes in 2023 alone than Cox has for his entire career... He's also had far better individual games if ur using that ridiculous beat 10 games nonsense.

Oh no.

We don't need to fact check again, do we?

Are you including Coaches votes in Finals? You know, the biggest and most important games of the season?

 

[Arr0w]

Can't believe pie supporters are still salty about finishing in mexico

Wowee

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

What? The 34 possession, 2 goal game you highlighted in the post I commented on?

You commented on a video of all Walsh's finals games in 2023...???? Lmao

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Oh no.

We don't need to fact check again, do we?

Are you including Coaches votes in Finals? You know, the biggest and most important games of the season?

Tell me Fudger... Where do those votes in finals go towards? The AFLCA? Or that other award Walsh who's apparently behind Cox won...?