Training Training Thread 2023

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Indeed, and when Gaff said no, we traded out for whoever most looked the part, and Jared Polec was his name. It didn't end well
Some revisionism there me thinks.

Gaff was a RFA, we already had a useless pick 11 and Preuss was already going. Our intention was to get both Gaff and Polec on opposite wings for a team playing under a dome. Polec had already committed to North when the Gaff deal fell through.

So, in off season for a team desperate in need of outside run and age bracket gap in the list, was to acquire in one off season:

Gaff
Polec
Hall
Pittard
Tyson

Thomas
Taylor
Scott

And this for a bags of coin and due to how Thomas was rated in the draft, a useless pick. We were already a basket case and this was the "fix".
 
Some revisionism there me thinks.

Gaff was a RFA, we already had a useless pick 11 and Preuss was already going. Our intention was to get both Gaff and Polec on opposite wings for a team playing under a dome. Polec had already committed to North when the Gaff deal fell through.

So, in off season for a team desperate in need of outside run and age bracket gap in the list, was to acquire in one off season:

Gaff
Polec
Hall
Pittard
Tyson

Thomas
Taylor
Scott

And this for a bags of coin and due to how Thomas was rated in the draft, a useless pick. We were already a basket case and this was the "fix".

Exactly, Polec was always intended to complement Gaff and then Gaff whacked Brayshaw and missed a flag. It was the Wish version of when we tried to get Dusty and Kelly in one go.
 
[/QUOTE]
tracey-morgan-no.gif


Don't know why this gets trotted out.

Drew Petrie
Jarrad Waite
Scott Thompson
Todd Goldstein
Nick Dal Santo
Ben Cunnington
Ben Brown
Brent Harvey
Daniel Wells
David Hale (he chose to trade him)
Hamish McIntosh
Andrew Swallow
Lindsay Thomas
Lachie Hansen
Nathan Grima
Levi Greenwood
Robbie Tarrant
Leigh Adams
Jack Ziebell
Sam Wright
Michael Firrito

I'm sick of this perception that Brad Scott achieved preliminary finals in spite of his list.

Plenty of talent in that 2010-15 group for mine. Laidley left Scott a very decent handover list.

Nothing like the dog turd Noble copped via Scott and Shaw.
With a few worthy exceptions, it was never a premiership list to be fair but he must take full responsibility for us never seriously threatening.

He overrated the list for years and through misguided loyalty kept playing a swag of solid, competitive soldiers.

He never quite grasped the value of top end talent. He preferred to roll with it rather than shake it up. It got him and the Club in the end.

Strange considering how talented his teammates at the Lions were. That should not have been lost on him.
 
Next year will be the 40th anniversary of our last win which must be the longest drought in the AFL.

I doubt it’s changing any time soon.
I know Ross would love to hand the mantle to another North player. How nice would that be if it was to happen in 2023 given as you said it is 40 years since he won it. Unlikely yes. Would I love it to happen, absolutely.
 
It's a lazy media narrative that gets regurgitated each time Brad Scott's name is mentioned and it's flat out incorrect. Our best was easily good enough, we were just horrific at arresting momentum in games.
Look on the bright side, imagine what he'll do with the mega talented list at Essendons..

On SM-S901E using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Remove this Banner Ad

Training Training Thread 2023

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top