Search results for query: *

big difference between a first rounder and 2nd rounder. Also, regarding Houston, he is worth a first rounder, just not to us. Which is why I don't want us to waste a pick on him. Regarding ANB, he is worth a pick around pick 30, if you don't want him, don't get him. You can't be like 'we want...

no pick inside 35 surely.

what are you banging on about. lol, you actually thought a club would offer pick 5 and a F1 for pick 4. Good Lord. A couple of seasons ago the dees offered 3 first rounders for essendons early first rounders (with some stuff coming back) but still, no list manager isn't going to listen to offers.

only you wouldn't be able to comprehend a clear hypothetical that was never supposed to be taken seriously. Any pick is trade-able.

well you're wrong. Wce have already said that they're willing to trade pick 3...

Like list managers don't listen to all trade offers. That would be foolish. If Dees offered you pick 5and a F1, you wouldn't keep pick 4 so saying 'we'll keep pick 4' means nothing.

The AFL will change the rules again before we get anyone decent. Then change them back again.

lol as if you know the inside thinkings of the AFC. So you've spoken to the list manager have you? I agree that it'd be surprising if pick 4 was used in any of the trades even if splitting the pick but don't pretend you have any idea what the club is thinking.

that's ridiculous. he's definitely pick 42 in value. he's pick 25 value. and that's what we'll get with maybe a 3rd coming back.

ANB isn't slow. Probably the same pace as a Soligo.

player welfare is extreme language. He's contracted and would be on decent money. It's not welfare, it's just a preference to return to SA.

'helping facilitate a player welfare situation' lol. Youre a team that came 15th. Sure Dees had a bad year but he'll come about 3rd in our BnF. Who will come 3rd in your Bnf? Whoever it is, I'm sure pick 42 won't cut it.

dude, even the dees beat port.

Ollie hollands would have to be one of the worst players in the afl

did you really make the 8? losing to stkilda, then embarrassing yourselves in the first final is a massive asterisk in 'making the 8'.

it could be, yeah.

I'm enjoying this. Carl fans very smug after melbourne went out in straight sets twice. Top 4 finish is better than finishing 8th after losing to Stkilda and then losing by what's looking like 100.

nah. he's worth pick 30. That's 5 off 25. 12 off 42. He'll come top 5 in our Bnf this year. He's done a lot more in his career than McAdam. Twice the player.

yep. same age as McAdam who your supporters wanted a 2nd rounder for. (some even wanted a late first). it's contradictory to drop the age card now.

lol F3. Stop flattering your own team. You came 15th. ANB will be a top 10 player in your team. Sure Melbourne had a down season but he's been a solid contributor for a long time. Pick 25 with a F3 coming back.

Pick 25 is marginally overs. Pick 30 is about right. But considering you only have pick 25, then that's what will be traded. Pick 40 odd won't cut it.

what a silly umpire. 'I believe it was touched can you check to see if it was touched'. That's the dumbest logic ever. If you're not sure, then the soft call has to be 'I think it was a goal'. Then the reply shows it wasn't even touched so the goal umpire is clearly making up noises in his own...

if crows fans rate McAdam then Neal-Bullen is 10 times better. Damn, we got sold a lemon.

With all due respect, as a Sydney fan, you're not in a position to to say 'move on'. If the AFL took Heeney off you out of nowhere you wouldn't be half the team. I will continue to make noise about this issue until we either get compensated or the AFL acknowledge their completely inept running...

McVee is better than half of these blokes.

'he gets on base'- Tim Lamb on Billings

bowey and sparrow haven't improved since 2021. Viney is slowing. As is May. You think Trac would want to leave a potential top 4 team? We're closer to bottom 4. Still have no genuine key fwd to help Van rooyen. If Berry was a young Viney, he'd be in Adelaides team well before matt crouch. we...

full rebuild, mini rebuild. whatever you like to call it. we came 14th this year and got spanked by wce and freo by 90 with all of them playing. no Luke Jackson, brayshaw retiring, Mac Andrew stripped from us, Neal-bullen leaving, Petracca causing unrest. it's over.

of course he will improve the side..you're missing the point. Do you have any concept of list management? Do you think it's wise for a team like North Melbourne or WCE to spend a first rounder on a 28 year old? Of course not. Melbourne is rebuilding and is no different. It's not the time to be...

Tell me something I don't know. Fullarton too. McAdam.