Search results for query: *

Yep, Brayshaw sits in their top 5, if not top 3. You match bids for that type of talent. You’re not getting fairly compensated by the league if say, that scenario involves a Cripps, Curnow or Walsh.

Don’t disagree, wouldn’t have been outlandish to make the same call re; Brisbane earlier in the year. Each team has strengths & weaknesses, it’s how the balance of the team can support to cover that is the key. Injuries & game plan play a huge part in that. Carlton seemed to have cleared out...

Rock solid citizen- Will be missed. God bless you Chugga.

2 in his first 6 in his second Kicked 1 goal in his first two years…..

Billy Frampton disappointed???

2009 - Murphy, Gibbs, Judd, Kreuzer, Walker, Yarran……. Judd was 25, same age as LDU, the others 22 and under You look at Norths forwards & backs…… I’d be surprised.

Yep, shone as brightly as any Ive seen for a couple of years before injury. As you’ve said, he was an athletic freak who could do things that others simply couldn’t once he “learned” the game. Was a bit of a slow burn at first as his footy brain wasn’t at the level his athletic abilities were...

“Contended for four of the next ten premierships”…….. Contended…….. hmmmmmm…… Where have I heard some debate, statements, made about what it takes to be considered a contender, Um, I just don’t recall……

They seriously don’t have any idea of what they are doing It’s almost unbelievable in it’s incompetence It’s so bad you can’t work out what to blame first

Not really, school in general wasn’t for me. Appreciate you asking. I’d thought you had quoted those percentages in a previous post. I must have been mistaken. Anyway, whatever they are, and with my limited mathematical capabilities, I’m pretty certain it’s better than 0% And drawing on your...

That makes Carlton at the very least a 4% better chance than Collingwood. Appreciate you supporting the Carlton have been the better team argument with your factual tidbits Fadge. We’ll done on your turnaround.

Don’t Hollands & Ross’s career stats stack up very similarly? Despite Ross having four more seasons to improve upon them from that of a second year player?

Shoo……..this is a thread relating to teams playing in finals. Get back to your abacus and mock ladder for 2025. I’ll give you a freebie, Pies won’t make the 8. Again.

I don’t believe I argued that he wasn’t. You must have missed the “inside mid” part.

You’d suggest our ability to be in a great space for FA space next year (2026) is because out current band of FA being paid significantly overs for output, but more importantly, games played. A couple of exceptions of course. A massive lesson on just how easily these type of deals can make or...

It shouldn’t. Grey was always a forward / mid then mid / forward throughout his career. I’d suggest the balance of the football world never saw Grey as a top 1-2 inside mid. Take what would be considered his best season in 2014, his contemporaries in that AA squad are being picked and...

All jokes aside, should seriously look at Matt Owies. Has kicked more goals this year than any of: Bobby Hill Lachie Schultz Dan McStay Brody Mihocek Jamie Elliott Mason Cox Jordon De Goey Nick Daicos Well, anyone on their list actually. I think something that would work for the Blues to...

They’d need to buy him a bigger jumper 😂

At least the Pies get a better draft pick……

Cowardly

Pretty much sums it up.

Please tell me Carroll is injured and they haven’t subbed him instead of Durdin or Motlop Please

*******ed by the umpiring

It’s a bad comedy Weitering & Young are the defensive version of Abbott & Costello

Boring……

Here you are again with your woulda, coulda, shouda nonsense The facts are Nick Daicos didn’t win all the individual awards, that’s just simply facts. That’s like saying Sam Docherty would have won the best & fairest this year but he’s been out all year with an ACL, once again, simple facts...

Here he is, the undercover Pie Fadge’s undercover brother 😂

They also sat by average 10th from an age perspective after winning their first. With all of their top 10 players 30 and under, most in that prime 26/27 age bracket. Where do you think Collingwood rank from an age perspective after last year? I’d reckon you’d know…. I’ve seen you compare top 10...

Um, Dusty, um, Richmond, um……….. Um, The Pies.

I didn’t want to be nasty…..