-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3
- Thread starter Wosh
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.
- Status
That makes Carlton at the very least a 4% better chance than Collingwood.
Appreciate you supporting the Carlton have been the better team argument with your factual tidbits Fadge.
We’ll done on your turnaround.
Last edited:
Maths not a strength of yours?
Of the 96 teams that have finished in positions 5th to 8th since 2000 (the first year of the new finals system) through to 2023, only one team has won the premiership.
You need to borrow my abacus?
Not really, school in general wasn’t for me. Appreciate you asking.
I’d thought you had quoted those percentages in a previous post. I must have been mistaken.
Anyway, whatever they are, and with my limited mathematical capabilities, I’m pretty certain it’s better than 0%
And drawing on your expertise with the abacus that would suggest anything above zero to be better, therefore supporting the context of my post of one being better than another and your contribution supporting that inference.
Keep it up, I’m confident you’ll get there.
Carlton are going to beat Brisbane in Brisbane for the second time this year
Then they will overcome GWS at their home ground where we have won before.
Then Geelong at the MCG where we beat them by 11 goals last time we met,
And finally Sydney in the GF where we beat them last finals series.
Pretty straight forward
- Mar 21, 2018
- 4,650
- 7,858
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Newcastle United FC
Yeah Scotland was very good for a long time at Carlton.Fantastic servant of the club. He played a decade at Carlton that it slipped my mind he also played for Collingwood first.
At least you didn’t say Alex Fasolo.
So you admit you're wrong? Some good things do come from Collingwood.
Firstly, im not saying the Blues will win the flag from 8th this season. Secondly if you understand how the finals system works any of the top 8 have a chance to win with the odds obviously varying from where you are on the ladder going into finals. Cleary teams finishing 5-8 have alot smaller chance of winning the GF.
So please tell me how this differs from your understanding of how the finals system works ?
Maybe go back to the original post I responded to, and tell me how 'any team in the 8 can win the flag, because it's so open this year'...
Maybe start with Carlton's probability of winning it, given their starting position, form leading into the finals, cohesion of playing group, etc.
Go.
- Mar 21, 2018
- 4,650
- 7,858
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Newcastle United FC
I hate to be the Grinch Wormy but;
You forgot a few other things that will need to happen.
Curnow will need to play well in finals for once. So he'll need about 43 free kicks.
The other teams that are better than you will have to really shit the bed to lose to Carlton.
Even if they do.... Carlton would have to NOT shit the bed even once across 4 high pressure games. And we all know how well Carlton handle the pressure don't we
Someone else other than Cripps would have to dominate in the midfield across all 4 games. Won't be Walsh obviously so who??
- Dec 9, 2015
- 7,940
- 13,659
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I don't think Voss has learnt his lessons yet, picked a bunch of injured players, too many, it'll be over quickly imoI hate to be the Grinch Wormy but;
You forgot a few other things that will need to happen.
Curnow will need to play well in finals for once. So he'll need about 43 free kicks.
The other teams that are better than you will have to really shit the bed to lose to Carlton.
Even if they do.... Carlton would have to NOT shit the bed even once across 4 high pressure games. And we all know how well Carlton handle the pressure don't we
Someone else other than Cripps would have to dominate in the midfield across all 4 games. Won't be Walsh obviously so who??
- Sep 3, 2019
- 20,933
- 61,651
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
First rule of a boys night out also. You’ve learnt well.
Weird shit fight.
Both teams sucked a fat one but at least Carlton made finals.
Collingwood couldn't even do that after fluking the flag last year.
Both teams sucked a fat one but at least Carlton made finals.
Collingwood couldn't even do that after fluking the flag last year.
- Sep 3, 2019
- 20,933
- 61,651
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Who’s this knob.
Who’s this knob.
Supporter of another club not playing finals, unlike Carlton.
Oh well, at least we have the first round of the most even draft, with many great prospects, to look forward to.
Oh, oh no. Oh dear.
- Dec 9, 2015
- 7,940
- 13,659
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Worst draft for 20 years they're saying, we dodged a bullet
Who? People on your own board?
Most even draft for 20 years, more like.
Next year's a mess.
Maybe, but not in mexico
You clearly didn't understand the tone of my post. I wasn't being particularly serious but gotta be in it to win itI hate to be the Grinch Wormy but;
You forgot a few other things that will need to happen.
Curnow will need to play well in finals for once. So he'll need about 43 free kicks.
The other teams that are better than you will have to really shit the bed to lose to Carlton.
Even if they do.... Carlton would have to NOT shit the bed even once across 4 high pressure games. And we all know how well Carlton handle the pressure don't we
Someone else other than Cripps would have to dominate in the midfield across all 4 games. Won't be Walsh obviously so who??
- Dec 9, 2015
- 7,940
- 13,659
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll
