He's a band-aid on an amputation. Hopefully for you, you're right, can't see you guys making finals in 2025-2031. Just too many noses in the rebuild trough.
Except we are 16th choice! Even Tarp City is ahead of us.
We can throw all the gold in Saudi Arabia at them, still doesn't work, unless you've been alive for only 14 or so years (which wouldn't surprise me). The free agents we get are cooked/washed up/retired/thinking about their super. We need...
He (not alone obviously) cost us the WCE game, that was honestly enough. You might think it's tough, I think it's fair, like more than fair. His opponent kicked 5 in a half and he was playing for a side who previously battled to score, not some free wheeling masters.
Chom has to play forward IMO. He was half decent at CHB but we desperately need a 2nd Tall Forward with W Dawson developing in defence.. I may have it all wrong but Chom is a CHF! Especially if we don't want to draft (which it seems) a KF.
Darling should play as a 3rd Tall Forward and push up...
Clear and obvious (if they are indeed the offers), I'm yet to hear of likely acceptable one yet, sure we overate 2, just as Richmond overate 18,20 & want to keep 6 for themselves - it's expected. The final offer will IMO, be F2 and 4 from crows or at a pinch F1 + 4 for F2 + 2 if they are adamant...
If we walk away with Tauru, Hotton and Gerreyn, it'll be worth it. You can have whoever it is you need/want. You're one of the few (from both sides) with your feet firmly on the ground.
10, 11, 25(ish) should do it, we'll give you a future 2nd if you want it. Thanks. Keep 6, have 2 - get the...
I answered your question, provided some historical evidence too. Do you need more? CCJ trade, Polec, Hay are all much worse than Daniel. Yes we overpaid, but it doesn't run a drum in our 'worst ever' masterclass.
Well good luck, I would have thought we would be ones to say no, but there you go.
Whilst I agree, he was contracted; I would have walked away but Clarko wanted him and our kicking from defence is easily the worst in the league. He is clean and one grab, albeit minute.
LOL CCJ, Hay, Polec...
The only way I could see that working is if we were to swap our 62 with your 32 in addition to the above.
Effectively 2,62 for 7,20,32.
That's a bit closer to what we'd be after, I feel.
There's also the possibility of putting 3R1's on the table in terms of our asking price, this time. We should at least select him and see what Adelaide offer to have him, if it happens to be 4,2025R1 for access to Draper + 2025 R2 then accept it and pick The Viking. We're still in control and...
7(8),8(10),32(45),2025R1 for 2,62(52), 2025 R2(20) + 2025 R3(40) could work for me.
Leaves us with 7,8,32.
and 2025 R1(NMFC) + 2025 R1(StK) = Sharp/Ludowycke.
They basically get their choice of midfielder, we get Tauru/Smilie + Armstrong and perhaps GUnit should he slide.
For the points...
We don't really know yet in this stage-managed fiasco, but at face value you're correct. All the goodwill we thought we had has amounted to zero (good learnings have been our only wins so far). But, we continue to overpay in $, picks and contract length so, probably nothing!
Led by Richmond nuffies in the media. It's as if they are front-running stories...
Only the very naive would believe that shit!
We're being worked against by multiple angles, it's our reality until we change the narrative a bit on field. We kinda did in the 2nd half of the year until the...
Excellent summary. I'll hold fire and judge at the end of the eon (as we all should), but you summed up how I'm thinking succinctly (at half time), without having access to all the information.
I'd say we'll trade #2 to St.Kilda for 7 + 2025 R1 if that's your offer - Then try to on trade St.Fiddlers 2025 R1 alongside our 2025 R2 to you for 10 & 18 valuing St.Fiddlers 2025 R1 rightfully (to you, not us) at about 5.
It's about even, but you get your second R1 next year which will help...
Well put. I'm sick of people not understanding value, it makes reading this critically important thread, tiresome.
St. Kilda crettins as well, we only get draft picks for presents anymore, fancy coming on here and telling us our Xmas gift is worth a $5 voucher at Big W. **** off, you're wrong...
Yeah we'll console ourselves with the best young midfield in the game (and Duursma to come), an AA FF and a 25 y/o pick 700, AA ruckman. For the record, what will you use to console yourself? Bradley Hill, GWS discards & Roscoe Lyons?
We don't have to trade shit, if it isn't in our favour we...
I'm not interest in fair. Fair can FRO.
6 and 11 from TigreFC (The Fighting Fury) or 7+F1 (from the Seaford Saints) will do.
I can't see Saint(as) finishing above 11th with that faschtinkener midfield.
come come a....(again)?
They come and go...
...Life will never be the same!
Geez, you missed a few gimme's there, sweet and sour!
I'm prepared to give Luke the benefit of the doubt as it was against TullaFC. Ordinarily you'd be right, but he did the right thing (only cos it was) against the...
I hope not but if it's true, we should just take the Saints deal of 8 + F1, hold on to our own F1 and see what we have. It's not as if we're going to be finals bound or anything like that, so having 2 picks in the first 25-30, irrespective of Academy/FS selections would be a masterpiece to just...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.