
Beerfish
Unscripted Hot Takes








- Jan 20, 2008
- 62,954
- 106,390
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Nic Martin
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 1
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Hey he prevented a quad injuryGlad to see that world class soft tissue specialist is paying off![]()
Too soon man.Mercuri Gumby Winderlich
It’s important to grieve.Too soon man.
Joe Daniher at CHF given his final years with us were cruelled through his groin injury (and subsequently him not giving a shit).Essendon prime movers having injury-hit careers in their prime... It’s been happening since Neale Daniher in ‘81. Hopefully this recurring shit for Ridley won’t deny him of another clear run at it this year.
How many peak years has injury robbed us of over the years? -
N Daniher - a ten year career lost
P Salmon - 1.5 seasons lost at his peak
T. Watson - 2 seasons when close to best player in the comp.
P. Vander Haar - could barely get on the park for 3 or 4 seasons at his peak
M. Harvey - 5 years blighted by bulimia and a leg broken 3 times
M. Long - 4 years out of 5 ruined after winning a N/S
J. Hird - 3 years ruined after a Brownlow win.
D. Bewick - ACL during his peak years
D. Rioli - multiple years injury affected
M. Mercuri - groin and knee hampered him after the age of 28 - many years lost at his peak.
D. Solomon - ACL after 2 GF appearances.
A. Ramanauskas - looked a star in the making before his neck tumor ruined his career.
J. Winderlich - at least 5 years of interruption with his back issues after breaking out.
M. Lloyd - lost a full season at his peak with big hammy which also cost us a few years of his best in his twilight.
D. Hille - ACL just as he begins to really announce himself.
I know other teams suffer their injuries but looking at that list it feels like we’ve suffered more than others for losing key players at their peak
We need Riddler to avoid missing chunks of seasons because he is such an important prime mover.
Here’s my Tribute XVIII to the lost years;
Solomon Reid (Ridley)
Harvey Vander Haar N Daniher
Long Rioli Ramanauskas
Mercuri Gumby Winderlich
Salmon Lloyd Bewick
Hille Watson Hird
Ive probably missed someone.
Essendon prime movers having injury-hit careers in their prime... It’s been happening since Neale Daniher in ‘81. Hopefully this recurring shit for Ridley won’t deny him of another clear run at it this year.
How many peak years has injury robbed us of over the years? -
N Daniher - a ten year career lost
P Salmon - 1.5 seasons lost at his peak
T. Watson - 2 seasons when close to best player in the comp.
P. Vander Haar - could barely get on the park for 3 or 4 seasons at his peak
M. Harvey - 5 years blighted by bulimia and a leg broken 3 times
M. Long - 4 years out of 5 ruined after winning a N/S
J. Hird - 3 years ruined after a Brownlow win.
D. Bewick - ACL during his peak years
D. Rioli - multiple years injury affected
M. Mercuri - groin and knee hampered him after the age of 28 - many years lost at his peak.
D. Solomon - ACL after 2 GF appearances.
A. Ramanauskas - looked a star in the making before his neck tumor ruined his career.
J. Winderlich - at least 5 years of interruption with his back issues after breaking out.
M. Lloyd - lost a full season at his peak with big hammy which also cost us a few years of his best in his twilight.
D. Hille - ACL just as he begins to really announce himself.
I know other teams suffer their injuries but looking at that list it feels like we’ve suffered more than others for losing key players at their peak
We need Riddler to avoid missing chunks of seasons because he is such an important prime mover.
Here’s my Tribute XVIII to the lost years;
Solomon Reid (Ridley)
Harvey Vander Haar N Daniher
Long Rioli Ramanauskas
Mercuri Gumby Winderlich
Salmon Lloyd Bewick
Hille Watson Hird
Ive probably missed someone.
[/QUOTERoger Merrett. We couldn’t get him on the park with his elbow and I think ankle injuries. He went to Brisbane and played 160 odd games. More than he played with us. Just shows our medical and conditioning has never been much chop. Apart from the early Quinn years we’ve been ordinary in this part of the game.
Joe Daniher at CHF given his final years with us were cruelled through his groin injury (and subsequently him not giving a shit).
ProbablyDoes he have a lower back problem they aren't picking up
Despite some of the reports the club has only ever said he had some discomfort and after scans he was going to miss the Bulldogs scratch match in a couple of weeks. No report of actual hamstring strain. Think it is just being very precautious for this tie of year. Round 1 is still very much in the window.He's running laps so he can't be that bad!
I seem to recall his quad injury last year was reportedly only minor too.Despite some of the reports the club has only ever said he had some discomfort and after scans he was going to miss the Bulldogs scratch match in a couple of weeks. No report of actual hamstring strain. Think it is just being very precautious for this tie of year. Round 1 is still very much in the window.
It was but he injured further during the recovery if I remember right. Low grade strain in March and reaggravation in April.I seem to recall his quad injury last year was reportedly only minor too.
Despite some of the reports the club has only ever said he had some discomfort and after scans he was going to miss the Bulldogs scratch match in a couple of weeks. No report of actual hamstring strain. Think it is just being very precautious for this tie of year. Round 1 is still very much in the window.
Probably
He's running laps so he can't be that bad!
It's what you do for these injuries. As long as it's not painful you run - well jog and build up to running.Or our medical staff are about to make a monumental error..
That's a hard read.Essendon prime movers having injury-hit careers in their prime... It’s been happening since Neale Daniher in ‘81. Hopefully this recurring shit for Ridley won’t deny him of another clear run at it this year.
How many peak years has injury robbed us of over the years? -
N Daniher - a ten year career lost
P Salmon - 1.5 seasons lost at his peak
T. Watson - 2 seasons when close to best player in the comp.
P. Vander Haar - could barely get on the park for 3 or 4 seasons at his peak
M. Harvey - 5 years blighted by bulimia and a leg broken 3 times
M. Long - 4 years out of 5 ruined after winning a N/S
J. Hird - 3 years ruined after a Brownlow win.
D. Bewick - ACL during his peak years
D. Rioli - multiple years injury affected
M. Mercuri - groin and knee hampered him after the age of 28 - many years lost at his peak.
D. Solomon - ACL after 2 GF appearances.
A. Ramanauskas - looked a star in the making before his neck tumor ruined his career.
J. Winderlich - at least 5 years of interruption with his back issues after breaking out.
M. Lloyd - lost a full season at his peak with big hammy which also cost us a few years of his best in his twilight.
D. Hille - ACL just as he begins to really announce himself.
I know other teams suffer their injuries but looking at that list it feels like we’ve suffered more than others for losing key players at their peak
We need Riddler to avoid missing chunks of seasons because he is such an important prime mover.
Here’s my Tribute XVIII to the lost years;
Solomon Reid (Ridley)
Harvey Vander Haar N Daniher
Long Rioli Ramanauskas
Mercuri Gumby Winderlich
Salmon Lloyd Bewick
Hille Watson Hird
Ive probably missed someone.