2015 Brownlow

[Substance]

FWIW I have fyfe on 29 votes with priddis needing 2 BOGs to overtake him. No one else in contention.

 

[happy_eagle]

Only game I am not totally confident with in terms of Fyfe is ironically Round 1 against Port
Have that game as

3 votes - D.Mundy (14 disposals in last quarter, 29 total with 10 clearances)
2 votes - O.Wines (Was Ports best player in a close loss. 27D with 2 Goals)
1 vote - D.Pearce (Provided outside run on with 28D and 2 Goals. Used the ball incredibly well)

Most places I have seen have actually given Fyfe the BOG for this match, but I haven't even had him in the votes. Difference between that would be either 26 votes (which is what I have him on now) and 29 (which would put him a game clear of Priddis)

 

[Duritz]

Only game I am not totally confident with in terms of Fyfe is ironically Round 1 against Port
Have that game as

3 votes - D.Mundy (14 disposals in last quarter, 29 total with 10 clearances)
2 votes - O.Wines (Was Ports best player in a close loss. 27D with 2 Goals)
1 vote - D.Pearce (Provided outside run on with 28D and 2 Goals. Used the ball incredibly well)

Most places I have seen have actually given Fyfe the BOG for this match, but I haven't even had him in the votes. Difference between that would be either 26 votes (which is what I have him on now) and 29 (which would put him a game clear of Priddis)

Not being a smartarse, but why is that ironic?

 

[happy_eagle]

Not being a smartarse, but why is that ironic?

I guess ironic wasnt the right word
More so unusual. Usually Round 1 votes are read out pretty quickly on Brownlow night as if they hold no real consequence
There are flashpoints at every medal count, and it just seems a little strange that one of these moments might be the first votes read out for the count.

 

[Duritz]

I guess ironic wasnt the right word
More so unusual. Usually Round 1 votes are read out pretty quickly on Brownlow night as if they hold no real consequence
There are flashpoints at every medal count, and it just seems a little strange that one of these moments might be the first votes read out for the count.

oh OK. Then yes you're right, ironic def the wrong word. Right one here would be "interesting", because it is interesting that your vote might come down to such an early round.

 

[Armesy]

Only game I am not totally confident with in terms of Fyfe is ironically Round 1 against Port
Have that game as

3 votes - D.Mundy (14 disposals in last quarter, 29 total with 10 clearances)
2 votes - O.Wines (Was Ports best player in a close loss. 27D with 2 Goals)
1 vote - D.Pearce (Provided outside run on with 28D and 2 Goals. Used the ball incredibly well)

Most places I have seen have actually given Fyfe the BOG for this match, but I haven't even had him in the votes. Difference between that would be either 26 votes (which is what I have him on now) and 29 (which would put him a game clear of Priddis)

Without going back to review and just looking at my votes, I have that game as
3 Fyfe
2 Pearce
1 Gray

Mundy, Pavlich and Wines next best. Fyfe got the 10 coaches votes.

 

[happy_eagle]

Without going back to review and just looking at my votes, I have that game as
3 Fyfe
2 Pearce
1 Gray

Mundy, Pavlich and Wines next best. Fyfe got the 10 coaches votes.

Willing to accept that I read this game wrong. Alot of good performances from both sides

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

Sorry haven't had a chance to post updated tallies for a while, finally got a few minutes. my leaderboard until today

31 Fyfe
30 Priddis
29 Hannebery
24 Swan, Gaff
23 S Mitchell, Dangerfield, Goldstein, Mundy

will post complete game by game tallies when get more of a chance. happy to look at individual matches if requested

rnd 1, freo v port, I had
3 fyfe
2 mundy
1 wines

 

[Armesy]

Sorry haven't had a chance to post updated tallies for a while, finally got a few minutes. my leaderboard until today

31 Fyfe
30 Priddis
29 Hannebery
24 Swan, Gaff
23 S Mitchell, Dangerfield, Goldstein, Mundy

I was worried my count had the favourites with overestimate counts as i feel like i favour them, but yours has even higher totals. My leaderboard is

Fyfe 33
Danger 26
Priddis 25
Hanners 23
Mundy 21
Pendles 20
Mitch 20
Cotchin 20

 

[Gosha]

Anyone think Jordan Lewis to be leading after five rounds @ $7 is good value?

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

Anyone think Jordan Lewis to be leading after five rounds @ $7 is good value?

I have it
fyfe 12 (most markets without him)
hannebery 10
priddis 7

lewis on 5 in my lists

 

[Duritz]

I have it
fyfe 12 (most markets without him)
hannebery 10
priddis 7

lewis on 5 in my lists

How come you have more than one list?

 

[TheJanuaryMan]

How come you have more than one list?

im like the Chinese restaurant on Seinfeld when Elaine tries to order takeout....."you on LIST"

I just keep multiple versions

 

[happy_eagle]

best value for the Round 5 lead are the shortest options in Hanneberry and Shiel
Mundy a chance if you reckon he can steal votes off Fyfe early on

 

[cisco]

I was worried my count had the favourites with overestimate counts as i feel like i favour them, but yours has even higher totals. My leaderboard is

Fyfe 33
Danger 26
Priddis 25
Hanners 23
Mundy 21
Pendles 20
Mitch 20
Cotchin 20

33 for Fyfe seems very high - do you have a break down of his votes per game please?

 

[Armesy]

33 for Fyfe seems very high - do you have a break down of his votes per game please?

Fyfe
Round
1 - 3
2 - 3
3 - 1
4 - 3
5 - 3
6 - 1
7 - 3
8 - 3
9 - 3
10 - 1
11 - 3
13 - 2
14 - 1
17 - 1
20 - 2

I admit is seems very high but that's just how it turned out in my votes.

 

[cisco]

Fyfe
Round
1 - 3
2 - 3
3 - 1
4 - 3
5 - 3
6 - 1
7 - 3
8 - 3
9 - 3
10 - 1
11 - 3
13 - 2
14 - 1
17 - 1
20 - 2

I admit is seems very high but that's just how it turned out in my votes.

Thanks buddy.

 

[Duritz]

Fyfe
Round

20 - 2

I admit is seems very high but that's just how it turned out in my votes.

Really? What were your 3-2-1's here? I ask because not only did they lose this match by 24 points, using stats or SC scores many players had more impact than he did. Wondering how you thought he'd get 2 votes in a losing side with minimal impact?

 

[happy_eagle]

Josh Hill (BOG medal) and Shuey I thought were the Eagles best in the derby
Hill, Mundy and Sandilands were the Dockers most consistent, but i'd expect only one of them to be in the votes given the loss

 

[mitchell2buddy]

I agree, think Priddis is the main contender with Dangerfield a tiny chance if he polls out of his skin.

I am thinking to just cross my fingers that Fyfe doesn't get suspended for the next two weeks. Cash out after Cripps takes the Rising star. Little bit risky but I am pretty sure he has it.

Great bet!

Personally, i think you should cash out take the $1500 then place $500 on cripps & fyfe @3.50 - you've guarenteed yourself $1000 profit with a chance to win a further $1750, and if it falls through and fyfe or cripps do not win, well you have $1000 and no need for what ifs! Win-Win situation, thoughts?
Read more at http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2015-brownlow.1093040/page-8#LH4f1lduRS7TOv09.99

 

[Armesy]

Josh Hill (BOG medal) and Shuey I thought were the Eagles best in the derby
Hill, Mundy and Sandilands were the Dockers most consistent, but i'd expect only one of them to be in the votes given the loss

I have

3 Hill
2 Fyfe
1 Mundy

I know that WC won but Freo dominated the game for large parts and just couldnt put it on the scoreboard. Fyfe had 12 clearances, 3 contested marks and 21 contested possessions. They are huge numbers. After the first quarter he led the freo fightback.

Hill obviously eagles best but thought they were a very even team performance whereas Fyfe and Mundy had cracker games.

 

[ronpingwins]

I have

3 Hill
2 Fyfe
1 Mundy

I know that WC won but Freo dominated the game for large parts and just couldnt put it on the scoreboard. Fyfe had 12 clearances, 3 contested marks and 21 contested possessions. They are huge numbers. After the first quarter he led the freo fightback.

Hill obviously eagles best but thought they were a very even team performance whereas Fyfe and Mundy had cracker games.

Fyfe had a cracker third quarter. Apart from that he had no influence. Won't poll.

 

[happy_eagle]

Might well be the first ever game that a team wins and has no polling players
Can't see it happening
Hillx2 and Shuey for the votes I reckon

 

[freo_leo29]

Might well be the first ever game that a team wins and has no polling players
Can't see it happening
Hillx2 and Shuey for the votes I reckon

His first Hill is the Eagle one anyway but i agree with your votes so who knows

 

[the_big_sav]

Is it time to start talking team votes yet?