Teams 2015 Rate My Team

[go you pups]

Nice team. Love the risks but there is better value then Ziebell.. Trade him to Adams or Kelly but apart from that love it. Love the Nic Nat inclusion.

Thanks mate. Yeah, with you on that one. I've had my eye on Adams, and that'd also free up some cash to upgrade one of my rookies.

Disagree Fitzey, Adams has a poor bye round and I wouldn't say he's a best 22 type yet, best 25 yes though.

Ziebell has history of averaging in the 90s with Greenwood gone he may spend more time in the guts than across half forward this year, will be a nice POD but his only downfalls is the tendency to rank up a 60 or two and has suspension history.

If you want other left field options look at Walters and Hrovat.

 

[Fitzey]

Disagree Fitzey, Adams has a poor bye round and I wouldn't say he's a best 22 type yet, best 25 yes though.

Ziebell has history of averaging in the 90s with Greenwood gone he may spend more time in the guts than across half forward this year, will be a nice POD but his only downfalls is the tendency to rank up a 60 or two and has suspension history.

If you want other left field options look at Walters and Hrovat.

That is what they say every year about Ziebell. Never happens

 

[go you pups]

That is what they say every year about Ziebell. Never happens

So you wouldn't take a 90-95 average from a forward though?

 

[Fitzey]

So you wouldn't take a 90-95 average from a forward though?

Not when he is awkwardly priced and Adams and Kelly cheaper and will average around the same

 

[go you pups]

Not when he is awkwardly priced and Adams and Kelly cheaper and will average around the same

Caddy MK2 with Adams, Kelly and Martin.

Can't see Kelly cracking any more than 80 with Ward, Judas, WHE, Treloar, Greene, Shiel, Whitfield etc taking away midfield minutes from him, then Scully and Palmer will tag/negate also probably.

 

[In Judd we trust]

Take 2 . rookies/bench TBD

 

[Clint Beastwood]

Wouldn't bank on Sinclair getting games early In Judd we trust , he's behind Lycett and Naitanui.

 

[Byron Beers]

Starting to shape nicely. The structure in the forward line is a bit off but I feel that between my 4 rookies, there should be at least 2 playing each week.

DEFENCE: M. Hibberd, B. Smith, J. Newnes, H. Lumumba, B. Whitecross, D. Viojo Rainbow (Z. Jones, T. Clurey)

MID: G. Ablett, S. Pendlebury, J. Selwood, B. Crouch, R. Griffen, B. Newton, N. Freeman, B. Arces (P. Cripps, T. Dumont)

RUCK: N. Naitanui, M. Kreuzer (J. Griffen, M. King)

FORWARD: D. Martin, R. Gray, D. Swan, T. Mitchell, J. Hogan, C. Daniel (T. Membrey, M. Clark)

Anyway, let us know what you think guys. I'm pretty stoked with this side at the current moment but would love to hear your opinions and they are much appreciated!

 

[Membling]

Twitch and Bontempelli can be selected as forwards In Judd we trust

 

[Lyukle]

Starting to shape nicely. The structure in the forward line is a bit off but I feel that between my 4 rookies, there should be at least 2 playing each week.

DEFENCE: M. Hibberd, B. Smith, J. Newnes, H. Lumumba, B. Whitecross, D. Viojo Rainbow (Z. Jones, T. Clurey)

MID: G. Ablett, S. Pendlebury, J. Selwood, B. Crouch, R. Griffen, B. Newton, N. Freeman, B. Arces (P. Cripps, T. Dumont)

RUCK: N. Naitanui, M. Kreuzer (J. Griffen, M. King)

FORWARD: D. Martin, R. Gray, D. Swan, T. Mitchell, J. Hogan, C. Daniel (T. Membrey, M. Clark)

Anyway, let us know what you think guys. I'm pretty stoked with this side at the current moment but would love to hear your opinions and they are much appreciated!

Looks good, might want to rethink Kreuzer

 

[Raise The Flag]

Thoughts on a revised side??
Thanks

 

[Byron Beers]

Looks good, might want to rethink Kreuzer

Haha, I actually had Leumberger but for some reason wrote Kreuzer!

 

[Jackizm]

So heres what i've got right now. Beau Waters getting injured and retiring & Kruezer not being ready for rd1 have thrown a spanner in the works but im liking the look of what I got so far.



46k in the bank.

Thoughts?

 

[Keystone agony]

Yep and Jack Martin also.

eh?

Martins priced at 50 and is not a bullocking type midfielder

???

 

[Yellow Feathers]

I have Martin locked in at F6 in both formats.

Had a great pre-season setting PBs and he's added a fair bit of bulk. Finished the year with a rising star nom for his 19 poss. 4 goals against West Coast. Monster game.

Reckon' he'll improve a lot this season.

 

[go you pups]

eh?

Martins priced at 50 and is not a bullocking type midfielder

???

Will disappoint

 

[go you pups]

I have Martin locked in at F6 in both formats.

Had a great pre-season setting PBs and he's added a fair bit of bulk. Finished the year with a rising star nom for his 19 poss. 4 goals against West Coast. Monster game.

Reckon' he'll improve a lot this season.

Will be lucky to avg 75, can't see him breaking into GCS midfield yet.

 

[Keystone agony]

Will be lucky to avg 75, can't see him breaking into GCS midfield yet.

Id happily take 75 from him though.

Was a standout in an intraclub for them. He has improved his engine along with his size. Will play a high HFF/wing with stints onball IMO.

GC midfield over rated for me IMO and doesnt run that deep.

Ablett, Prestia, Swallow, Bennell - i know im forgetting a few but Martin will be a welcomed addition involved in the midfield rotations.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Jack Martin is a stud.
Selected as an underager so he's had 2 pre seasons under his belt

"wont break into their midfield" - Jack Martin will BE their midfield (Swallow, Ablett & Prestia as backup )
.

 

[go you pups]

Jack Martin is a stud.
Selected as an underager so he's had 2 pre seasons under his belt

"wont break into their midfield" - Jack Martin will BE their midfield (Swallow, Ablett & Prestia as backup )
.

O'Meara, Lonergan, Hallahan, Bennell (when fit), talks of KK pushing up field also.

Not convinced with Jack.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

O'Meara, Lonergan, Hallahan, Bennell (when fit), talks of KK pushing up field also.

Not convinced with Jack.

Forgot about O'Meara - obviously he is a gun.

Trust me though, Jack Martin is something else. There is a reason he was selected first in the Mini draft.

 

[go you pups]

Forgot about O'Meara - obviously he is a gun.

Trust me though, Jack Martin is something else. There is a reason he was selected first in the Mini draft.

For sure he is but I can't see him spending large amount of minutes in midfield, I'd be disappointed if he didn't impact the scoreboard but I reckon right now he is more SC relevant than DT/AF relevant. Expect scores similar to say a Hoskin-Elliot/Ballantyne type.

 

[Pawel]

Final result, no changes until late March!

 

[Keystone agony]

O'Meara, Lonergan, Hallahan, Bennell (when fit), talks of KK pushing up field also.

Not convinced with Jack.

I think he would be ahead of Hallahan and Lonergan albeit they are very inside mids whereas he will outside and spending time across half forward.

Hes certainly one im not 100% sold on, i dont think hes really been in my team yet however i havnt touched it for a while.

 

[TJ Hendricks]

Hi guys. I've only been following this sport since January so I'm still completely new.

Any feedback appreciated. Thanks.

DEFENDERS
Nick Malecski
Josh Gibson
Brian Lake
Phil Davis
Brendon Whitecross
Zak Jones

Nathan J Brown
Matthew Dick


MIDFIELD
Dion Prestia
Boomer Harvey
Robbie Gray
Jaeger O'Meara
Josh Caddy
Marcus Bontempelli
Nathan van Berlo
Daniel Rich

Blake Acres
Patrick Cripps


RUCKS
Nic Naitanui
Matthew Leuenberger

Matthew Kruezer
Rory Lobb


FORWARDS
Buddy Franklin
Jarryd Roughead
Chad Wingard
Zac Clarke
Brandon Matera
Tom Boyd

Mitch Clark
Jesse Hogan


Not bad for a American newbie?

Here's my second version. Hopefully it's better than the first. Sure isn't as easy as it looks.

DEFENDERS
J. Newnes
J. Gibson
H. Lumumba
A. Rance
K. Kolodjashnij
Z. Jones

NJ Brown
M. Dick

MIDFIELDS
N. Fyfe
D. Prestia
J. O'Meara
J. Caddy
N. Van Berlo
D. Rich
N. Freeman
B. Acres

P. Cripps
N. Krakouer

RUCKS
N. Naitanui
M. Leuenberger

R. Lobb
M. King

FORWARDS
B. Franklin
D. Swan
N. Riewoldt
H. Bennell
JJ Kennedy
M. Bontempelli

J. Hogan
M. Clark


Any help would be appreciated.