Trades 2022 Round 19 Trades - the everyone except Mills, Laird and Sinclair sucks edition

[WaynesWorld19]

Yep, this is what I’m working with so could bring in a forward as well

View attachment 1451533

Other option I considered is Bont or could go LDU / Guthrie / Trac / Etc

Guthrie for mine, given the home games the Cats will play, on the run home

 

[Harry12031]

Guthrie for mine, given the home games the Cats will play, on the run home

Liking it, esp with eagles R23, cheers for the help

 

[Penski]

I see Grundy expected to miss another week due to the VFL bye, which might put him at two weeks away at least.

 

[11kgm]

I see Grundy expected to miss another week due to the VFL bye, which might put him at two weeks away at least.

thank god two more weeks of DC

 

[Exambolor]

Same ....plus English McStuffin

An actual English Muffin would be better than English right now

 

[TedDougChris]

An actual English Muffin would be better than English right now

Although if it had lettuce in it, the Muffin would be more expensive that English's 800K price tag right now.....

 

[mrpig]

Also Carmichael didn't train according to Collingwood track watches

as a dawson owner.. i actually want this

would make my trades this week easy

Otherwise i'll just screw up my luxury trades anyway

 

[11kgm]

as a dawson owner.. i actually want this

would make my trades this week easy

Otherwise i'll just screw up my luxury trades anyway

Dawson to Sinclair
Kelly to Merett

sadly no Laird till next week

 

[mrpig]

Dawson to Sinclair
Kelly to Merett

sadly no Laird till next week

that would be good for u

at least you dont have to feel the pain of the player you trade out scoring big, whilst the player you trade in spuds it

There's nothing luxurious about luxury trades anymore

 

[11kgm]

that would be good for u

at least you dont have to feel the pain of the player you trade out scoring big, whilst the player you trade in spuds it

There's nothing luxurious about luxury trades anymore

everyone has gone shit for me
English in then out straight away
Wines and Titch
Anderson
Doc over Sinclair

plus others hahaha

 

[WaynesWorld19]

everyone has gone s**t for me
English in then out straight away
Wines and Titch
Anderson
Doc over Sinclair

plus others hahaha

Same here ....4 weeks ago, felt my team was taking shape ....but for 4 weeks either all my trade-ins have been injured .....or I've had 2 premo injuries or H&S Protocols every week

For Coach's that had their teams completed early ....not an issue

But for us dufess's that didn't get their starting side correct & are 2-3 trading weeks behind everyone else .....the injury carnage has been bad news

I really thought Mid-Pricers Crouch, Rowell and Danger would start the season with a bang .....and then fade ....they were simply **** selections

 

[Milo Cyrus]

Same here ....4 weeks ago, felt my team was taking shape ....but for 4 weeks either all my trade-ins have been injured .....or I've had 2 premo injuries or H&S Protocols every week

For Coach's that had their teams completed early ....not an issue

But for us dufess's that didn't get their starting side correct & are 2-3 trading weeks behind everyone else .....the injury carnage has been bad news

I really thought Mid-Pricers Crouch, Rowell and Danger would start the season with a bang .....and then fade ....they were simply **** selections

Tis a stupid game, only 5 rounds to go.

 

[Milo Cyrus]

So, is Whitspud going to get named?

if Dawson & Whitspud don't get up my preferred trades will be compromised again.

 

[TedDougChris]

So, is Whitspud going to get named?

if Dawson & Whitspud don't get up my preferred trades will be compromised again.

Same here… I have coverage for one out (it’s not great but it exists), but two out means I’d have to hold Jelly instead of trading him

 

[Cotchy9]

Witts to Marshall
Or
Titch to Brayshaw?

Likely do the other one next week, but what’s more important this week?

 

[Pure Grunt]

Hold Jelly?
Trade Cripps>Mills
&
1. Hough>Culley (loop Culley/Hollands/Carmichael) - then next DC>Marshall, Keays>Oliver/Guthrie (Brodie F6, Jelly M8)

or

2. Jelly>Marshall - then next Brodie>Oliver/Guthrie, Hough>190k (Marshall/DC F6, Keays M8)

 

[mrpig]

Witts to Marshall
Or
Titch to Brayshaw?

Likely do the other one next week, but what’s more important this week?

I'm getting brayshaw this week

His run home i think is great.... almost all teams he is playing against dont have taggers, and play an open game style

I'm giving up playing "which ruck will show up this week"

my rucks are English and Gawn, and i'm setting and forgetting for the ROS unless injury

 

[Pure Grunt]

Witts to Marshall
Or
Titch to Brayshaw?

Likely do the other one next week, but what’s more important this week?

Witts to Marshall for the cash change over - points about same - Think Marshall will beat Brayshaw margin slightly
Brayshaw is the enigma v Tigers (130). Titch v Roos (110)
Marshall V WCE (120). Witts v Lions (90) - Big O back

 

[Cotchy9]

Witts to Marshall for the cash change over - points about same - Think Marshall will beat Brayshaw margin slightly
Brayshaw is the enigma v Tigers (130). Titch v Roos (110)
Marshall V WCE (120). Witts v Lions (90) - Big O back

That’s the way I’m leaning atm. Marshall probably outscore Witts by more than Titch does Bray. But that said, Titch only had 89 v Roos in round 1. Witts 97 v Big O earlier this year

 

[mrpig]

Witts to Marshall for the cash change over - points about same - Think Marshall will beat Brayshaw margin slightly
Brayshaw is the enigma v Tigers (130). Titch v Roos (110)
Marshall V WCE (120). Witts v Lions (90) - Big O back

Titch has only played 1 good game in the past 5 weeks

and that was the game in a swimming pool against GWS

The upside of brayshaw i think is better than marshall and also is the floor of brayshaw

I'd much rather be running with Witts and Brayshaw than Marshall and titch

 

[Cotchy9]

Titch has only played 1 good game in the past 5 weeks

and that was the game in a swimming pool against GWS

The upside of brayshaw i think is better than marshall and also is the floor of brayshaw

I'd much rather be running with Witts and Brayshaw than Marshall and titch

This is also a good point. As it stands Witts is probably as good as Titch, and yeah, Brayshaw is better than Marshall. I’m playing for league, and Witts might have a West Coast team without Nic Nat next week. Could be 50+ hit outs and a nice 100+ score

 

[Pure Grunt]

This is also a good point. As it stands Witts is probably as good as Titch, and yeah, Brayshaw is better than Marshall. I’m playing for league, and Witts might have a West Coast team without Nic Nat next week. Could be 50+ hit outs and a nice 100+ score

You did say you were likely to do the other next week which would void that opportunity
You are therefore holding Witts until round 21 when he has the Hawks or 22 vs Cats?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Also Carmichael didn't train according to Collingwood track watches

I traded him in last week so this is guaranteed to happen.

 

[Pure Grunt]

That’s the way I’m leaning atm. Marshall probably outscore Witts by more than Titch does Bray. But that said, Titch only had 89 v Roos in round 1. Witts 97 v Big O earlier this year

Your call - Titch with no Ward - Tag?

 

[Cotchy9]

Your call - Titch with no Ward - Tag?
View attachment 1451966View attachment 1451967

Hmm. That is an interesting graph. Cheers. It’s more the lack of CBA’s atm that’s killing Titch