![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/adelaide.png)
WaynesWorld19
Moderator
- Moderator
- #1
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 0
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
I'd be very weary of Ladhams making a bigger impact this yearWhat do we make of Tom Hickey's value proposition for R2. How does it compare to other sub 500k rucks, like OMac and Cameron.
TH is $465k and he has a decent recent history of scoring tonnes prior to his injury last year.
no love for solo ruck cameron?
with dpp he becomes a bit more valuable imo. if youre gonna start with a pox fwd line. having him to swing forward once the ruck carnage settles is good option i thinkWaiting for Pies fans to sell me on this.
If it's just him and McStay named round 1 it looks good.
If Cox is anywhere near the 22 it could be a disaster.
with dpp he becomes a bit more valuable imo. if youre gonna start with a pox fwd line. having him to swing forward once the ruck carnage settles is good option i think
His DPP might not be so valuable come round 6 when one (or both) of Gawn/Grundy and possibly Marshall get it. Likely all of them out-score Cameron.Swinging him forward is one thing but then you need to replace him with a premo Ruck anyway. If there is No Cox I would start him in a heartbeat but he is no lock as a 2nd ruck.
His DPP might not be so valuable come round 6 when one (or both) of Gawn/Grundy and possibly Marshall get it. Likely all of them out-score Cameron.
Match sim today from a poster on our board.
“Tim English was best afield and controlled the air, land and sea. His upper body is now massive and he also finished 7th in the time trials a few weeks back, so he is in the very top of the class for fitness too. It showed in a dominant and clean display.”
The concussion issue is the big worry. Could easily have the highest average of the rucks, but how many games does he play?Ruck only next year and 3rd most expensive with his history it makes it hard to even consider him.
I think the worry with Marshall is with King injured long term he gets parked forward and they play that spud Campbell.English is my R1 but I'm surprised there isn't more love to Marshall, he should have most of the rucking duties now Ryder is gone and in the season he was the main ruck he averaged 112 and he was still a young player back then.
How often do clubs cover their No.1 KPF going out with their No.1 ruckman?I think the worry with Marshall is with King injured long term he gets parked forward and they play that spud Campbell.
Could be the play to get him in when he gets DPP and King is back.
Not often.How often do clubs cover their No.1 KPF going out with their No.1 ruckman?
Jack Hayes actuallyNot often.
But it's Roma or Mason Wood essentially.
Not a bad call if forgotten about him.Jack Hayes actually
Jack Hayes actually
What's the word on Max Heath ....any chance of games in 2023, if Marshall goes down ?Roma & Meek atm for me
Wouldn’t think so mate - Campbell in reserve if we need before MooseWhat's the word on Max Heath ....any chance of games in 2023, if Marshall goes down ?