Injury 2024 Injury Report/Updates

Remove this Banner Ad

The Royal Sampler said:
Match play training strikes me as oxymoronic, but I’ll take it on face value as good news.
Click to expand...
Training doing actual match play simulations does not sound oxymoronic to me… it’s a specific type of training drill.

Significant milestone once he gets to that stage. Exciting stuff if he will be doing it that soon
 
ElliottsMaggies said:
... because ACL's are generally 12 months.

Many called it in January? A month after he did his ACL?
Click to expand...

many players have returned earlier than 12 months, Tony Liberatore returned after 16 weeks. all players recovery times are different
i was suprised at the time when media were saying he was out for the whole of 2024
i would give him a full month in the VFL though to get confidence in it before a return to the seniors, just in time for finals
 
ksardog said:
many players have returned earlier than 12 months, Tony Liberatore returned after 16 weeks. all players recovery times are different
i was suprised at the time when media were saying he was out for the whole of 2024
i would give him a full month in the VFL though to get confidence in it before a return to the seniors, just in time for finals
Click to expand...
The general consensus is 12 months. Anything less is unusual, not the norm.

I'm not sure anyone could have predicted in January Dan would be back early, considering he only did his ACL in December 😆

Tony's was considered a 'miracle' recovery. Certainly not the norm.

foxsports.com.au

Tough Tales: Tony Liberatore on the greatest moment of his life

‘It was the greatest moment of my life’
foxsports.com.au foxsports.com.au
 

Log in to remove this ad.

ksardog said:
many players have returned earlier than 12 months, Tony Liberatore returned after 16 weeks. all players recovery times are different
i was suprised at the time when media were saying he was out for the whole of 2024
i would give him a full month in the VFL though to get confidence in it before a return to the seniors, just in time for finals
Click to expand...
Surely centre of gravity has a bit to do with it though.
 
Timmy from Thomastown said:
Training doing actual match play simulations does not sound oxymoronic to me… it’s a specific type of training drill.

Significant milestone once he gets to that stage. Exciting stuff if he will be doing it that soon
Click to expand...

Most people just call it match sims but ok.
 
The Royal Sampler said:
Most people just call it match sims but ok.
Click to expand...
I certainly didn’t read it as real (presumably VFL) matches being considered practice.

That would be oxymoronic. And a bit moronic to use the terminology that way😂

Also a little optimistic that he’d be plsying actual games in June
 
Fox Sports now reporting that Fly has confirmed that Pendles will miss.
Team Tips: The premiers are nowhere near peak condition right now, though they’re still not losing, which is pretty impressive. Collingwood will need to find replacements for Mason Cox (leg/concussion), Joe Richards (foot) and Brody Mihocek for their clash against the Bulldogs, plus Jordan De Goey is set to miss another month with an ab tendon tear. Additionally, coach Craig McRae confirmed on Wednesday morning that Scott Pendlebury would miss on Friday night also, leaving the Pies even more depleted. That said, it puts the likes of Reef McInnes, Nathan Kreuger and Ash Johnson in the frame for senior selection. Collingwood’s VFL side didn’t have a match last week, but the Pies will be hoping to potentially get Jeremy Howe and Jack Bytel back from injury. Jamie Elliott (vascular) and Tom Mitchell (foot) are confusingly both 2-5 weeks away, while Will Hoskin-Elliott (hamstring) should be back in a fortnight. Depending on how they’re looking on the injury front, debutants Wil Parker and Ed Allan, along with defender Charlie Dean, could end up being unlucky at selection.
Click to expand...

www.foxsports.com.au

MORE Pies injuries with veteran to miss; fringe Dog in frame; Port skipper unlikely: Team Tips

MORE Pies injuries with veteran to miss; fringe Dog in frame; Port skipper unlikely: Team Tips
www.foxsports.com.au www.foxsports.com.au
 
domus said:
Why didn't they include him in the injury report? We all knew he had hurt his arm. I hate this add ons. Tell us he's in doubt on Monday.
Click to expand...
Fly said they expected him to get through training and play.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

ElliottsMaggies said:
... because ACL's are generally 12 months.

Many called it in January? A month after he did his ACL?
Click to expand...

Yeah because the club was showing footage of him already ahead of schedule

"12 month injury" was always essentially branding because most players do knees during the season.

Plenty of players have come back in less when the timing worked out. Although I say "plenty", but the number isn't huge or anything but it's not totally abnormal


McStay would be the 4th at Collingwood in the last 20 years. That's just Collingwood though.

  • Krakouer was back I think in like 6 months
  • Goldsack was back within 6 months
  • McStay will be 7 months
  • Didak I think did his knee at the end of 2006 and played ANZAC Day 2007 (partially torn ACL)
 
Cousin of Daicos said:
Yeah because the club was showing footage of him already ahead of schedule

"12 month injury" was always essentially branding because most players do knees during the season.

Plenty of players have come back in less when the timing worked out. Although I say "plenty", but the number isn't huge or anything but it's not totally abnormal


McStay would be the 4th at Collingwood in the last 20 years. That's just Collingwood though.

  • Krakouer was back I think in like 6 months
  • Goldsack was back within 6 months
  • McStay will be 7 months
  • Didak I think did his knee at the end of 2006 and played ANZAC Day 2007 (partially torn ACL)
Click to expand...
Of course we all hoped he'd be back this year. And hopefully he will be.

But it's not the norm. That's why those that have done it earlier are remembered & celebrated. Because it is so rare.

It's also worth noting what stage of their careers they were at and how soon after returning that they retired from the game.

Dan is still in his prime and we want him to be around for a few more years, not just scrape through this year to try and play in a GF/premiership before he retires.

It's great that he is ahead of schedule & hopefully he makes an early & successful return before seasons end. That's what we all want.
 
ElliottsMaggies said:
Of course we all hoped he'd be back this year. And hopefully he will be.

But it's not the norm. That's why those that have done it earlier are remembered & celebrated. Because it is so rare.

It's also worth noting what stage of their careers they were at and how soon after returning that they retired from the game.

Dan is still in his prime and we want him to be around for a few more years, not just scrape through this year to try and play in a GF/premiership before he retires.

It's great that he is ahead of schedule & hopefully he makes an early & successful return before seasons end. That's what we all want.
Click to expand...

I don't think I ever suggested it was the norm. It isn't.

As I had said, timing of when the injury occurs is the key factor imo.

If you look at all the Collingwood cases of "early" returns, all of them were done at the start/pre-season or end of the season/post season.

I doubt that's a coincidence

Goldsack - pre-season
Krakouer - pre-season
Didak - end of season
McStay - very very early pre-season
 
Cousin of Daicos said:
I'm surprised so many in the media are surprised McStay is coming back this year?

Many of us here called it back in January. Even the Club was basically telling everyone he would be back this year when they didn't put him on the long term injury list.

Round 20 is a little later than I predicted though.

I honestly thought he'd be back playing AFL early to mid-July but I won't complain about Round 20. Still gives him a month lead in to finals
Click to expand...
I’m totally shocked that the media didn’t run with it when you predicted it.
 
domus said:
Why didn't they include him in the injury report? We all knew he had hurt his arm. I hate this add ons. Tell us he's in doubt on Monday.
Click to expand...
. What difference would it have made to your life if he was mentioned in an injury report on Monday or not? Everybody knew he had some sort of injury. They thought he’d get through and he didn’t.
 
I think we should name and shame all posters who bemoaned the young players not getting opportunities at the start of the season. Contrarily we had posters saying we had no depth with VFL looking a horrible team. 🤣🤣 curse you all!!

I've never seen a season like this. Where does our VFL team get top up players from this week?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
larrikan said:
I think we should name and shame all posters who bemoaned the young players not getting opportunities at the start of the season. Contrarily we had posters saying we had no depth with VFL looking a horrible team. 🤣🤣 curse you all!!

I've never seen a season like this. Where does our VFL team get top up players from this week?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Click to expand...
Have you visited the VFL game day thread? 😆

It's a nightmare on there.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Injury 2024 Injury Report/Updates

Similar threads

Jen2310
Training Pre-season updates 2024-2025.
2 3 4 5
Replies
123
Views
6K
ElliottsMaggies
ElliottsMaggies
Jen2310
  • Locked
Training 2024 training updates.
250 251 252 253 254
Replies
6K
Views
335K
Anzacday
Anzacday
Jen2310
VFL VFL pre-season 2025 (list changes, updates)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
142
Views
5K
Jen2310
Jen2310
BigVic
2024 review
Replies
8
Views
565
whiskeytown
whiskeytown
Stronzatello
Copeland tickets 2024
Replies
13
Views
2K
Jen2310
Jen2310
R
2024 Highs and Lows
Replies
1
Views
242
Kes1984
Kes1984
Jen2310
Prediction Copeland Trophy 2024 - Friday October 4th.
8 9 10 11 12
Replies
286
Views
9K
Anzacday
Anzacday

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top