Player Watch #33: Kamdyn McIntosh

[Grrr]

maybe, but would still offer more than Kmac next year.

Also more lacking for midfield depth than wing given our mids injury history. Mac was used forward this year as much as which he ain't.

 

[Groupie_]

clean out the decks

 

[A Tiger 4 lyf]

I assume he has hit some form of trigger for extension quietly


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[tigers12]

how is he not delisted i would rather punt on a delisted free agent that is younger and more hungrier kmac knows he is going to get a game every week next season and if he does we have a problem

 

[captain cotch 9]

how is he not delisted i would rather punt on a delisted free agent that is younger and more hungrier kmac knows he is going to get a game every week next season and if he does we have a problem

He probably wont play every game but his off field leadership and his personality and experience will be vital next year.

If we do a Norf we will end up like Norf

 

[Punt Road Feral]

Was hoping Pickett was retained and Kmac hung them up but it’s panned out the other way round.

Will be very important having a wise old head for our new draftees. Kmac can teach them a thing or two about getting the most out of their careers and he has certainly done that.

 

[Tonythetiger]

Was hoping Pickett was retained and Kmac hung them up but it’s panned out the other way round.

Will be very important having a wise old head for our new draftees. Kmac can teach them a thing or two about getting the most out of their careers and he has certainly done that.

He also had to go back to the two's multiple times to earn back his spot which is good as an example for a lot of the younger players. He never sooked it up. Good chance he cracks 200 games. Pick 31 in 2012, not the most talented but hell of a return.

 

[Boston tiger]

Same votes this year in the B&F as a bloke who just got a 7 year deal. Last year finished 10th. This bloke needs to be cheered every time he steps on to the field. What a warrior.
Make the young guns earn a spot and see if they can get past the old boy

 

[Hank Heavenly]

He also had to go back to the two's multiple times to earn back his spot which is good as an example for a lot of the younger players. He never sooked it up. Good chance he cracks 200 games. Pick 31 in 2012, not the most talented but hell of a return.

Same votes this year in the B&F as a bloke who just got a 7 year deal. Last year finished 10th. This bloke needs to be cheered every time he steps on to the field. What a warrior.
Make the young guns earn a spot and see if they can get past the old boy

His slecetion has been a farc for the last two years...

It has done the exact opposite of teaching kids to earn games.
The y would have beeter form in the VFL than he does in the AFL, yet Kmac is an auto selection (up until the back half of this season) on the back of terrible performnces.

Every game he plays from here is a game of experince and learning a kid doesn't get.

Really bad decision IMO

 

[voorhees]

how is he not delisted i would rather punt on a delisted free agent that is younger and more hungrier kmac knows he is going to get a game every week next season and if he does we have a problem

you don't think Mac is hungry for success or playing his heart out for the club?
Man might have his faults, but being hungry to play his heart out is not one of them.

 

[voorhees]

Same votes this year in the B&F as a bloke who just got a 7 year deal. Last year finished 10th. This bloke needs to be cheered every time he steps on to the field. What a warrior.
Make the young guns earn a spot and see if they can get past the old boy

good call..
if Banks wants his spot on field..prove it!
work that bloody hard that you force the club to cement you into the position.

 

[Tonythetiger]

good call..
if Banks wants his spot on field..prove it!
work that bloody hard that you force the club to cement you into the position.

A bit like how Ralphsmith has really come on and found that spot on the wing to make his own. If we just played him every week and he stunk it up his confidence would be zapped.

 

[tora tora tora]

His slecetion has been a farc for the last two years...

It has done the exact opposite of teaching kids to earn games.
The y would have beeter form in the VFL than he does in the AFL, yet Kmac is an auto selection (up until the back half of this season) on the back of terrible performnces.

Every game he plays from here is a game of experince and learning a kid doesn't get.

Really bad decision IMO

2024 Kmac was fit in an injury crisis but RFC is incapable of having senior players in the VFL.

Thank **** Graham got traded and Pickett retired. I hope a couple of new assistant coaches bring a new selection policy.

 

[tiger_tough]

I thought we should only keep one of Pickett and McIntosh. Would have preferred Pickett but he's gone. Happy to keep McIntosh around given the mass exodus of experience we've had. I just hope he's not a lock each week...

 

[Hank Heavenly]

you don't think Mac is hungry for success or playing his heart out for the club?
Man might have his faults, but being hungry to play his heart out is not one of them.

sh!t you and I would be hungry to play our hearts out for this club, that can't be the selection criteria.

You havge to be able to play at the level, and Kmacs last 2 years have shown that he can't do that anymore