tigs2010
Pick 1...
Doesn't say a whole lot. If he's going to make it he will need to be the best KPF we've drafted in 11 years
Player Watch #40: Callum Coleman-Jones
- Thread starter Grockadoc
- Start date
- Tagged users None
No he will be...Doesn't say a whole lot. If he's going to make it he will need to be the best KPF we've drafted in 11 years
tigs2010
Pick 1...
Has a notable deficiency...unable to take one handed mark attempts...clunks his marks two handed!Probably already is
Dr Tigris
Brownlow Medallist
I reckon CCJ is a very smart pick. What I really liked last year was that he was the best contested mark in the draft (that alone is worth gold and jewels to me) and was a mobile tall RR more than a pure ruck. Also has was the state team captain and considered a genuine leader.
So my thinking was that maybe he didn't stand out like a beacon. But we knew for certain he was tall enough and had enough mobility to work at the AFL level, and that he would be a top quality mark. Plus his leadership etc seemed to lead to a good attitude. So the starting point to me was a low risk of failure. If at worst we got a monster KPF that could take a good grab that is worth the pick.
That he can ruck and showed he could rack up the touches around the ground, and had decent skills, is a massive upside to me.
He looked like a draft pick that was low risk, high upside. And he would fill in a KPF/ruck role.
Conversely Balta was all talent, but high risk. I'd prefer to take the low risk/high return, than the high risk/brilliant return option.
And we got both.
Also, I suspect Miller will take a bit longer. But that country football, dedicated, type often is a jewel in the dirt player.
Still like what CCj brings to the table. Good pick up.
So my thinking was that maybe he didn't stand out like a beacon. But we knew for certain he was tall enough and had enough mobility to work at the AFL level, and that he would be a top quality mark. Plus his leadership etc seemed to lead to a good attitude. So the starting point to me was a low risk of failure. If at worst we got a monster KPF that could take a good grab that is worth the pick.
That he can ruck and showed he could rack up the touches around the ground, and had decent skills, is a massive upside to me.
He looked like a draft pick that was low risk, high upside. And he would fill in a KPF/ruck role.
Conversely Balta was all talent, but high risk. I'd prefer to take the low risk/high return, than the high risk/brilliant return option.
And we got both.
Also, I suspect Miller will take a bit longer. But that country football, dedicated, type often is a jewel in the dirt player.
Still like what CCj brings to the table. Good pick up.
The best part about all this is that Brett Deledio trade paid for
Callum Coleman - Jones
Noah Balta
Patrick Naish
How exactly did this work again.
Geelong pick received - swapped for 2 picks in 20s?
But wasnt the other pick a 3rd rounder?
I reckon CCJ is a very smart pick. What I really liked last year was that he was the best contested mark in the draft (that alone is worth gold and jewels to me) and was a mobile tall RR more than a pure ruck. Also has was the state team captain and considered a genuine leader.
So my thinking was that maybe he didn't stand out like a beacon. But we knew for certain he was tall enough and had enough mobility to work at the AFL level, and that he would be a top quality mark. Plus his leadership etc seemed to lead to a good attitude. So the starting point to me was a low risk of failure. If at worst we got a monster KPF that could take a good grab that is worth the pick.
That he can ruck and showed he could rack up the touches around the ground, and had decent skills, is a massive upside to me.
He looked like a draft pick that was low risk, high upside. And he would fill in a KPF/ruck role.
Conversely Balta was all talent, but high risk. I'd prefer to take the low risk/high return, than the high risk/brilliant return option.
And we got both.
Also, I suspect Miller will take a bit longer. But that country football, dedicated, type often is a jewel in the dirt player.
Still like what CCj brings to the table. Good pick up.
Great post summed it up nicely I seen a bit of him at sturt last year and very much in the Toby Nankervis role but alot more capable as a forward. I think Toby will be hanging till this kid is ready to give him a chop out.
He lacks a bit of a leap but has grown a few centimeters so should end up around the 202/204 cm hopefully and already weighing mid 90s knows how to use his body to advantage.
Hopefully he can continue his progress in the vfl over the next month or so and wouldn't be at all surprised to see him given a crack for a few weeks at the second tall spot could really surprise I think.
Wait, so if Coleman Jones comes into the side as a second ruck then Moore will no longer be required? But given that reiwoldt is almost 30 and moore is only 21 there will still be time for him to etch his place in the team as the key position forward while Coleman Jones is the main ruck.
Hardwick said they are treating KPPs a little differently now in their development. They will play a few weeks then have a week or two off. They will train them in those weeks off so they become accustomed to the weight they are gaining. CCJ has already put on 7kg since arriving. Pretty smart if you ask me.
For the people that may not be aware Callum Coleman Jones just turned 19 3 days ago, So i am expecting a significant amount of development in him as well as some physical growth. If he does actually end up 202-204 that would be great for his rucking as mentioned doesnt have a massive leap
Yeah come on mate...explain the intricacies of that one again please...The best part about all this is that Brett Deledio trade paid for
Callum Coleman - Jones
Noah Balta
Patrick Naish
Yeah come on mate...explain the intricacies of that one again please...
"Deledio became a Giant just minutes before the deadline of this year's NAB AFL trade period, in exchange for a first- and third-round selection at next year's draft."
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-10-20/giants-grab-star-tiger-brett-deledio-in-final-hour
Richmond on traded the #15 recieved for Deledio to brisbane for picks #20 & #25 which was used to secure Coleman-Jones & Balta and the 3rd rounder was used to match the bid for Naish
Out: Brett Deledio
In: Coleman-Jones , Balta , Naish
- Oct 11, 2003
- 9,987
- 12,354
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- tigers
gee thats a great result for us. CCjones will be no 1 ruc in 2 years. he is a genuine ruchman. balta will be flying of the half back line. naish may be on the wing.
But Naish went at 34, 2nd round. If I remember, we didnt have a normal 2nd round pick, so where did we get enough points? Did we use the extra 3rd round and our normal 3rd round to get the matching points?
DrMike
No one likes Wang
- May 13, 2012
- 25,033
- 56,910
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Discount
Yeah...I know about the discount. But one 3rd round pick got us enough points?
TJTIGER
Brownlow Medallist
- Jul 10, 2009
- 12,022
- 16,813
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- RFC AFLW/VFL, Furies-2015 Premiers
Sensational!! It shows as premiers we are prepared to be inovative in gaining a competitive advantage and continuing to grow as a club.....Love It !!!
- Nov 18, 2014
- 9,313
- 23,587
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Red Sox, Bruins, Celtics, Niners
Just wait for Milller. He'll join CCJ, Balta and Garthy as part of the next tall generation. They can all play.
Have said it before: our list is loaded at the moment, for now and into the future. Best I've seen it in 30 years.
Have said it before: our list is loaded at the moment, for now and into the future. Best I've seen it in 30 years.
Why do we need to trade Moore after investing 3 years of development into him ?? thats just crazy unless we think he wont make it and if thats the case nobody els would take him any way.
We will have 4 selections in the draft so can look to get a Inside mid with these picks what difference would a #55 we get for Moore make to our current selections
