AFL Dream Team 2007

[kingyubbo]

Dont rate the second trade? May i ask why

Yeah, Campbell for Hughes trade is a little silly. Gaining 10-20 points for a guy on the bench? Seems a little drastic at such early stages.

With the Pettard thing, Rodan is far more experienced. You never know, Pettard might have a rookie week and get 30 points. I don't think you can say Pettard is a long term option over Rodan.

If FFGenie says Lucas will keep going down (funny as he's averaging 90), then i'll wait.

 

[theone5]

Dont rate the second trade? May i ask why

Campbell has basically secured his place in Kangaroos's starting 22, whereas, Hughes has not secured his place in Richmond's starting 22.
With Bowden, Hall and Thursfield all to potentially come back, i do not think he will get a game week-in, week-out.
Like someone just said, Wallace would definitely be swinging the axe this week after that embarrassing performance Richmond put on today so you should have at least waited to see the team line-ups.
Nevertheless, i am nearly certain that he will play this week.
He was not too bad today and with Schulz injured, he should hold his spot for a few more weeks but i just do not see the point in the trade, especially because Campbell has not peaked in value yet.

 

[dash stars]

Yeah, Campbell for Hughes trade is a little silly. Gaining 10-20 points for a guy on the bench? Seems a little drastic at such early stages.

With the Pettard thing, Rodan is far more experienced. You never know, Pettard might have a rookie week and get 30 points. I don't think you can say Pettard is a long term option over Rodan.

If FFGenie says Lucas will keep going down (funny as he's averaging 90), then i'll wait.

ill have the choice or hadley or pettard for my final spot in the 22... there going to score more than brennan and bock.. ill upgrade them and ill be in front

 

[makingmemark]

any gos as to when Andrew Browne and Lindsay Thomas could be back???

very interested in that too mate as they're both my current emg's for center.

thanks POTP. with that breakeven i can imagine alot of peeps will follow what's already been done and get on Petterd

 

[Mattlowry]

Now i have some questions to ask

I have Gibbs and Selwood on my Bench.

Sellwood's price is pretty high, but will it rise next week? I plan to trade for Petterd this week, but wont be interested in getting him next week so i need to trade one of Gibbs or Selwood (Joel that is) this week.

Then once i do this i will free up some serious cash. My next question would be after this trade who do i get in Goodwin or Grant?

 

[Juddy88]

Thinking of doing one trade this week
In Whitnall/Gram, Out Raines

Hmm

 

[Audacious]

Would you make that trade though? Buddy is looking very good at the moment!

Buddy Franklin has played brilliantly over the last month, but he is still not of the calibre of Lucas.

 

[Juddy88]

Now i have some questions to ask

I have Gibbs and Selwood on my Bench.

Sellwood's price is pretty high, but will it rise next week? I plan to trade for Petterd this week, but wont be interested in getting him next week so i need to trade one of Gibbs or Selwood (Joel that is) this week.

Then once i do this i will free up some serious cash. My next question would be after this trade who do i get in Goodwin or Grant?

Selwoods B/E is -30 lol

 

[bones25]

Now i have some questions to ask

I have Gibbs and Selwood on my Bench.

Sellwood's price is pretty high, but will it rise next week? I plan to trade for Petterd this week, but wont be interested in getting him next week so i need to trade one of Gibbs or Selwood (Joel that is) this week.

Then once i do this i will free up some serious cash. My next question would be after this trade who do i get in Goodwin or Grant?

Get rid of Gibbs, check who caaaaaaarlton are playing next week, he is no where near the player that Murphy was at this time last year.

 

[the egg]

Campbell has basically secured his place in Kangaroos's starting 22, whereas, Hughes has not secured his place in Richmond's starting 22.
With Bowden, Hall and Thursfield all to potentially come back, i do not think he will get a game week-in, week-out.
Like someone just said, Wallace would definitely be swinging the axe this week after that embarrassing performance Richmond put on today so you should have at least waited to see the team line-ups.
Nevertheless, i am nearly certain that he will play this week.
He was not too bad today and with Schulz injured, he should hold his spot for a few more weeks but i just do not see the point in the trade, especially because Campbell has not peaked in value yet.

Hmm yeah Campbell i cant see him scoring higher than 60 where as Hughes has potential to score 100's being a key forward. I was just looking for cash this week which was why i made these trades, i only had 10 grand in the bank and will look to upgrade Bock next week and maybe Foley depending how they play this week. Bowden is in terrible form and Hall is suspended so they wont be back for a while which should give Hughes a chance to cement his spot (IMO i think he already has)

 

[PowerOfThePussy]

Now i have some questions to ask

I have Gibbs and Selwood on my Bench.

Sellwood's price is pretty high, but will it rise next week? I plan to trade for Petterd this week, but wont be interested in getting him next week so i need to trade one of Gibbs or Selwood (Joel that is) this week.

Then once i do this i will free up some serious cash. My next question would be after this trade who do i get in Goodwin or Grant?

Selwood will rise for sure - b/e of -30 - should go up a fair bit i imagine.

Cheers
POTP

 

[thereignisover07]

thinking...
IN: h. shaw and hughes
OUT: bock and mooney

mooney is good but i dont think he'll get much higher. he only managed 89 and 2 goals in a game where he should of had 120 and 6 goals.
use the cash later on to trade a rischitelli, priddis or a foley.. to a k cornes or a cross

thoughts?

 

[thereignisover07]

going to keep gibbs also. he'll come good and pagan will run him on the ball in time. no rush

 

[AdamG03]

OK so Gibbs just went down 6,700 afta the last round. His breakeven for next round is 73 (which he wont get based on his past performances)

Im debating over the whole Murphy, Gibbs, Brennan, Lappin situation also.

I currently have Brennan doin wat he does best down back (not scoring well)
I know... worst pickup ever.

Murphy not playing that great in the Centre. Same goes for Gibbs.

I want to get Lappin into my team and i would like to trade out Brennan for Waters ASAP (Rather have an eagles player than any other team, because i know what is going on with players from WCE than any other).

Petterd looks good as a cash cow. But i like having reserves who are going to play.

Hence my team currently looks like this.

McPhee, C Cornes, Gilbee, Birchall, Adcock, Brennan, Kozi
Ellis, Riggio (Will be watching closely to how Jesse Smith is going, also want to get rid of Brennan ASAP!!!)

Kerr, Judd, Black, Murphy, Priddis, J Selwood
Gibbs, Hadley (Petterd a possible in? Lappin would be good if i wasnt so worried about his fitness)

Cox, Sandilands
Hudson, Ryder (Happy with my rucks)

Johnson, Pavlich, Gablett Jnr., Franklin, Dale Thomas, Lovett, Embley
Alwyn Davey, Aaron Edwards (Happy with my Fwds for now)

Currently ranked 50 out of 192338. But still would like anyones thoughts or advice?

Thanks
AdamG03

 

[Mattlowry]

Well got rid of Gibbs, brought in Peterd.

Brought in Goodwin to. Have a fair bit of room to move in my cap too. Going to trade Selwood next week probably, then trade for some stars over the next two weeks with my spare cash (assuming i dont have any major injuries!)

 

[Juddy88]

Wtf the FFgenie update says Brennan rose by 77K this week LOL and says he is at 309K atm

 

[theone5]

OK so Gibbs just went down 6,700 afta the last round. His breakeven for next round is 73 (which he wont get based on his past performances)

Im debating over the whole Murphy, Gibbs, Brennan, Lappin situation also.

I currently have Brennan doin wat he does best down back (not scoring well)
I know... worst pickup ever.

Murphy not playing that great in the Centre. Same goes for Gibbs.

I want to get Lappin into my team and i would like to trade out Brennan for Waters ASAP (Rather have an eagles player than any other team, because i know what is going on with players from WCE than any other).

Petterd looks good as a cash cow. But i like having reserves who are going to play.

Hence my team currently looks like this.

McPhee, C Cornes, Gilbee, Birchall, Adcock, Brennan, Kozi
Ellis, Riggio (Will be watching closely to how Jesse Smith is going, also want to get rid of Brennan ASAP!!!)

Kerr, Judd, Black, Murphy, Priddis, J Selwood
Gibbs, Hadley (Petterd a possible in? Lappin would be good if i wasnt so worried about his fitness)

Cox, Sandilands
Hudson, Ryder (Happy with my rucks)

Johnson, Pavlich, Gablett Jnr., Franklin, Dale Thomas, Lovett, Embley
Alwyn Davey, Aaron Edwards (Happy with my Fwds for now)

Currently ranked 50 out of 192338. But still would like anyones thoughts or advice?

Thanks
AdamG03

Waters...
Not much of an upgrade?

 

[AdamG03]

When/Where do i get the updated Round 6 CSV file for FFGenie?
I just looked at the site i downloaded off and couldnt find it?
Link?

 

[Cruiser23]

Is it time to trade pendlebury considering he is 295k and he has a b/e of 87 the week? has he reached his peak?

 

[AdamG03]

Waters...
Not much of an upgrade?

Waters > Brennan
Or i could use $35k in the bank and get Carazzo or Guerra.
Yeh?

Thoughts on the Murphy/Lappin situation?

 

[kingyubbo]

Currently ranked 50 out of 192338. But still would like anyones thoughts or advice?

If you're ranked 50, you don't need to take advice from us

 

[PowerOfThePussy]

Wtf the FFgenie update says Brennan rose by 77K this week LOL and says he is at 309K atm

not on mine it doesn't

it has him as -16.2 for the round and price 215.1

POTP

 

[theone5]

Waters > Brennan
Or i could use $35k in the bank and get Carazzo or Guerra.
Yeh?

Thoughts on the Murphy/Lappin situation?

OUT: Murphy, Brennan
IN: Lappin, Shaw

Perfect...

I am too nice.
I should be more quiet in the future.

 

[AdamG03]

If you're ranked 50, you don't need to take advice from us

Any criticism is good. I still worry about my decisions throughout the week like anyone else

Shizen that i only scored 1979 considering...
Kerr 35
Mcphee 70
Gilbee 71
Brennan 37
Murphy 53
Thomas 54
Lovett 58
Sandilands 63
Embley 0 Replaced with Davey 73 (Edwards on the pine with 95... wouldve got me 2001 instead of 1979)

;P

 

[Juddy88]

not on mine it doesn't

it has him as -16.2 for the round and price 215.1

POTP

Did u just click update last?

Mine has everything else right from what i see

I bet the people who have Brennan wish he was at that price