MVP AFL Round 10 votes - Geelong v GWS Giants

[Pure_Ownage]

I'll kick things off. Remember 5 4 3 2 1 format.

5. SJ
4. Harry
3. Kelly
2. Chappy
1. Bartel

 

[Senatorguesty]

Re: Votes Round 10 vs GWS

5: The H
4: Stevie
3: Jimmy B
2: Kelly
1: Chappers

HM: Buddy

 

[tomthabuddah]

Re: Votes Round 10 vs GWS

1. Jimmy
2. Stevie J
3. Harry
4. Chap
5. Kel

 

[InnocentBystandr]

Re: Votes Round 10 vs GWS

5. Stevie J (lifted when it was needed)
4. Harry 'Half Dozen' Taylor
3. Jimmy 'Every woman wants him - every man wants to be him' Bartel
2. Mitch Duncan
1. James 'MRP*' Kelly

HM: Chappy, T Hunt, Stringer

* According to Malthouse et al he'll be gone for weeks

 

[Boxhead_31]

Re: Votes Round 10 vs GWS

5. SJ
4. H Taylor
3. Bartel
2. Kelly
1. Stringer

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

Re: Votes Round 10 vs GWS

Pretty clear top five for mine, though you could just about have them in any order.

5. Steve Johnson
4. Paul Chapman
3. Harry Taylor
2. James Kelly
1. Jimmy Bartel

 

[True Blue Cat]

Re: Votes Round 10 vs GWS

5. Steve Johnson
4. Harry Taylor
3. James Kelly
2. Mitch Duncan
1. Jimmy Bartel

 

[Nibbler_]

5. Johnson
4. Taylor
3. Bartel
2. Kelly
1. Duncan

Unlucky: Chapman, T Hunt and I was personally very impressed with J Hunt.

Smedts did some good things too.

 

[Frappe]

5. Kelly
4. Johnson
3. Taylor
2. Scarlett
1. Chapman

 

[RobDog18]

5. Steve Johnson
4. Harry Taylor
3. Jimmy Bartel
2. Paul Chapman
1. James Kelly

 

[alfy!]

5. SJ
4. Bartel
3. Harry
2. Selwood
1. Kelly

 

[Sttew]

5. Stevie J
4. Harry T
3. Jimmy B
2. Kelly
1. Chappie

 

[TheWoodenSlug]

5 - Johnson
4 - Chapman
3 - Taylor
2 - Mackie
0.5 - Bartel
0.5 - Kelly

 

[Vdubs]

5. Harry 100
4. SJ
3. Bartel
2. Scarlett
1. Kelly

 

[Ninty]

9 - The Q.
3 - Stevie J
2 - Jimmy
1 - Selwood
$122 - Geelong council. 17k turn up to the game and they fine people that can't find a park anywhere else!? People park all over the place every week. Go and get ****ed.

[don't take my votes seriously]

 

[catman2006]

5. Stevie J
4. Harry T
3. Jimmy B
2. James K
1. Mitch D

 

[David the Cat]

5 Bartel
4 Taylor
3 SJ
2 Chapman
1 Selwood

 

[Big Nasty]

5) Steve Johnson
4) Paul Chapman
3) Harry Taylor
2) James Kelly
1) Jimmy Bartel

 

[Turkey Tom]

5 - Bartel
4 - Johnson
3 - Chapman
2 - Selwood
1 - Harry

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

5. Johnson
4. Scarlett
3. Chapman
2. Kelly
1. Taylor




Apologies if i'm about to offend anybody, but i cannot fathom for 1 second how Bartel can be in peoples votes, particulary over Chapman.

He got the ball and just threw it on the boot for the majority, unless i watched a different game.

 

[OldStyle2007]

5. Taylor
4. Scarlett
3. SJ
2. Kelly
1. Chapman

 

[Nankervis brothers]

5. S. Johnson
4. P. Chapman
3. J. Kelly
2. H. Taylor
1. J. Bartel

A. Mackie a close 6th.

 

[David the Cat]

5. Johnson
4. Scarlett
3. Chapman
2. Kelly
1. Taylor




Apologies if i'm about to offend anybody, but i cannot fathom for 1 second how Bartel can be in peoples votes, particulary over Chapman.

He got the ball and just threw it on the boot for the majority, unless i watched a different game.

For me it was because in the first half he was the only player committing to the hard ball get, and winning contested ball. He threw himself into the fray when Selwood went off for a while. And not many were around to help him.

I thought he was great most of the day. Bartel is a warrior.

Many have him top 3, and most top 5.

 

[Vdubs]

5. Johnson
4. Scarlett
3. Chapman
2. Kelly
1. Taylor




Apologies if i'm about to offend anybody, but i cannot fathom for 1 second how Bartel can be in peoples votes, particulary over Chapman.

He got the ball and just threw it on the boot for the majority, unless i watched a different game.

"Opinions are like arse-holes, everybody has one", any you are fully entitled to your arse-hole. And nobody at all is offended.

 

[GeeCats07]

5. Johnson
4. Kelly
3. Taylor
2. T. Hunt
1. Chapman