MVP AFL Round 5 votes - Hawthorn v Geelong

[SJ]

If you are a Geelong supporter, you are welcome to cast your votes in this thread. At season's end a vote count night will be organised, where round by round we will tally the votes to announce the Geelong Board 2011 Most Valuable Player. For four consecutive years this award has gone to the Geelong Best and Fairest.

Please structure them exactly in this fashion:

5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

 

[winty]

Tough one today.

5. Chapman
4. Bartel
3. Taylor
2. Lonergan
0.5 each - Menzel and Duncan

Apologies to Scarlett, Selwood, Ottens and Varcoe.

 

[thejester]

5. Chapman
4. Lonergan
3. Taylor
2. Ottens
1. Menzel

 

[YIIIABLETTT]

Tough one today so many worthy contendors. Was a super performance.

5- Chapman
4- Lonergan
3- Bartel
2- Scarlett
1- The Q9

 

[Jimmy Yamazaki]

5. Chapman
4. Selwood
3. Lonergan
2. Scarlett.
4. Duncan

just missed Ottens, Menzel...

 

[cats2rise]

5- Chapman
4 - Lonergon
3 - Ottens (wheres the love for otto today?)
2 - Taylor
1 - Bartel

 

[cynical]

5. Chapman
4. Scarlett
3. Kelly
2. Taylor
1. Lonergan

 

[Spermbird]

1) Chapman
2) Kelly
3) Lonergan
4) Scarlett
5) Ottens

Aplogises to Taylor

 

[rapido]

1. Taylor - great recovery after a slow start.
2. Lonergan - excellent game on Franklin.
3. Bartel - consistent across 4 quarters
4. Chapman - a touch of class. Loving the pact.

5. Scarlett - because I can. I love that man.

 

[Jimpson]

5. Taylor
4. Chappy
3. Scarlett
2. Ottens
1. Lonergan

 

[Turbocat]

5, Ottens
4,Chappy
3,Selwood
2,Lonergan
1,Duncan ( or Menzel )

 

[Roadie]

5. Chapman
4. Selwood
3. Ottens
2. Lonergan
1. Taylor

HMs: Scarlett, Bartel, Duncan, Menzel

 

[Generalissimo]

5. Chappy
4. Lonners
3. Scarlo
2. Selwood
0.5 Dasher
0.5 Harry T

 

[Micksy]

5.Kelly
4.Chapman
3.Duncan
2.Selwood
1. Menzel

 

[True Blue Cat]

5. Chapman
4. Kelly
3. Lonergan
2. Harry Taylor (while he started slowly those contested marks in the 2nd kept us in it)
1. Menzel

 

[Craigyboy]

5. Taylor
4. Chapman
3. Scarlett
2. Bartel
1. Ottens

Unlucky: Selwood, Corey & Menzel

 

[Belisarius]

5. Taylor
4. Chappy
3. Ottens
2. Lonergan
1. Selwood.

 

[STC]

5. Jimmy Bartel
4. Joel Corey
3. Paul Chapman
2. Harry Taylor
1. Joel Selwood
Dasher, Otto, Scarlo so close.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

5.Bartel
4.Lonergan
3.Taylor
2.Chapman
1.Selwood

 

[alfy!]

5. Chapman
4. Bartel
3. Taylor
2. Scarlett
1. Lonergan

 

[Big Nasty]

5) Paul Chapman
4) Joel Selwood
3) Jimmy Bartel
2) Brad Ottens
1) Tom Lonergan

 

[Sttew]

5. Scarlett
4. Selwood
3. Chapman
2. Taylor
1. Lonergan

 

[Sttew]

What is apparent is that 15+ players could have received votes. It was a classy team effort

 

[year of the cat]

5. Chapman
4. Lonergan
3. Taylor
2. Ottens
1. Selwood

 

[Burgers45]

From an independent supporter...

5. Bartel (Put his body on the line and brilliant over the 4 quarters)
4. Chappie (Aleays plays well in pressure games)
3. Taylor (started badly on Buddy, but Scott's switch, Harry on Roughhead and Lonegen on Buddy was a match winner)
2. Lonergan (Held Buddy after being switched onto him)
1. Kelly (Was in everything)

Honourable mentions to Scarlett, Varcoe, Selwood.


****I hope you guys can beat those arrogant Magpies..