MVP AFL Round 9 votes - Carlton v Geelong

[winty]

If you are a Geelong supporter, you are welcome to cast your votes in this thread. At season's end a vote count night will be organised, where round by round we will tally the votes to announce the Geelong Board 2011 Most Valuable Player. For four consecutive years this award has gone to the Geelong Best and Fairest.

Please structure them exactly in this fashion:

5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

 

[David the Cat]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

5 Kelly ( all the in and under work..was there every time)
4 SJ
3 Varcoe
2 Selwood ( would have got higher if he had played 4 quarters )
1 Christenson

 

[InnocentBystandr]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

5. Selwood (BOG for first 3 quarters)
4. Bartel
3. Scarlet
2. Kelly
1. Christensen (encouragement award - coming on really well)

 

[Jimpson]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

Kelly had a stinker i thought. 52% disposal eff and 9 clangers.

5. Selwood
4. Johnson
3. Varcoe
2. Chapman
1. Scarlett

 

[Hoffy95]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

5. Selwood
4. Bartel
3. Kelly
2. Christensen
1. Stokes

Stoker played a very important role in taking Yarran out of the game.

 

[pessimiser]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

5. scarlet
4. kelly
3. varcoe
2. selwood
1. johnson

 

[InnocentBystandr]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

Kelly had a stinker i thought. 52% disposal eff and 9 clangers.

ABC Grandstand gave him 3 votes for BOG!

 

[Generalissimo]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

5. The man who's benefitted most from Moneybag Jnr leaving. The God of Clearances. Jimmy Fsking Kelly.
4. Scarlo.
3. Selwood
2. Josh Hunt
1. Travis Varcoe

 

[Daitro]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

Bartel? really? went missing in the second half big time.

5 Selwood (stellar for the first three quarters)
4 Johnson (kicked the ones he needed to, got involved up the ground too)
3 Chapman (back out of his mini slump with a solid four quarter game)
2 Varcoe (showed up for three goals when he needed to)
1 Kelly (coughed it up a lot, but can excused for all the grunt work he did)

 

[cats2rise]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

Kelly had a stinker i thought. 52% disposal eff and 9 clangers.

ABC Grandstand gave him 3 votes for BOG!

He did have a fair few clearances I'd imagine. Have not looked at the stats yet.

 

[Darwin Cat]

Re: AFL Round 9 - Carlton vs Geelong

5 J Selwood
4 J Kelly
3 J Corey
2 A Christensen
1 A Mackie

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

5. Kelly
4. Selwood
3. Johnson
2. Varcoe
1. Stokes

 

[Sttew]

5. Kelly
4. Scarlett
3. Selwood
2. Johnson
1. Chapman

 

[Linx]

5. Kelly (reason his DE % was low is because he was winning basically all our in close clearances. Was a warrior.)
4. Selwood (Great for 3 quarters but think he got injured late in the 3rd and limited his out in the 4th).
3. Chapman ( Solid 4 quarters. Kicked crucial goal late in 4th - as always)
2. Christenson (Really impressed with his grunt work and poise under pressure. Clean hands and with a good head on his shoulders).
1. Stokes (Killed Yarran and bobbed up with a few goals. Solid and underrated)

 

[mac_cat]

5. Kelly
4. Selwood
3. Scarlett
2. Johnson
1. Varcoe

 

[vinum coupe]

5. Mackie (long live #4)
4. Selwood
3. Kelly
2. SJ
1. Bartel

 

[catman2006]

5.Selwood
4.Scarlett
3.Kelly
2.Chapman
1.Varcoe

 

[The_Big_Ship]

5. Selwood
4. Kelly
3. Chapman
2. Johnson
1. Scarlett

 

[True Blue Cat]

5. James Kelly - 11 Clearances and he was doing everything.
4. Joel Selwood
3. Paul Chapman
2. Matthew Stokes
1. Matthew Scarlett

 

[Frappe]

Very hard to vote on...no standouts

5. Selwood
4. Kelly - alot of clangers
3. Stokes
2. Johnson
1. Varcoe

 

[Mephistopheles929]

5 - Joel Selwood
4 - James Kelly
3 - Steve Johnson
2 - Travis Varcoe
1 - Andrew Mackie

 

[cats81]

5. Selwood
4. Scarlett
3. Johnson
2. Varcoe
1. Corey

Thought Kelly would do great by winning the clearance but then he would f*** it up by giving it away so he gets no votes...honourable mentions to Bartel and Chapman who always lift for us when we need it

 

[witsend]

5. Selwood (a warrior)
4. Kelly (a velvet warhorse)
3. SJ (frustrates and exhilarates all at the same time)
2. Scarlett (won us the game in the last 2 minutes)
1. TV (game breaking 3rd Q without which, we lose)

 

[bobbycatsfanme]

Strange game tonight, was it a case of Carlton playing better than us or did we play an off game? Tough game last week and perhaps some emotion during the week with the passing of Bobby Davis and the week's rest to Carlton seemed to have helped them as the game went on.

1. Kelly (Arguably the best utility player in the game today)
2. Boris
3. Chappy
4. Johnson
5. Mackie


really liked Duncan's game as well, won't be long before he's starting to poll votes

 

[kd35]

5. Kelly
4. Selwood
3. Johnson
2. Stokes
1. Christensen

H/M Scarlett. Pity they had 30 scoring shots.