Recommitted Alex Witherden

[BeornJ]

Very underrated player.

Hope he plays on at WC. Only 23, has a lot of strong assets, couple of things to work on.

 

[Jack Richards]

Yep. Yes he is prone to some poor running or kicking but still only 23.

I hope he gets an opportunity elsewhere.

 

[FFB1]

Very underrated player.

Hope he plays on at WC. Only 23, has a lot of strong assets, couple of things to work on.

Underrated yet Brisbane were happy to let him go and pay $ of his contract to do so, and couldn’t hold down a spot in the Eagles 22 this year?

Many Brisbane supporters were saying what most Eagles supporters are now saying - weak defensive game and is slow, and kicking overrated.

 

[Warwick]

He’s many things but underrated he is not.

 

[Nathan Barley]

Body needs to be 100% right all the time to not be a liability with his lack of athleticism. Otherwise even when in form his kicking doesn't make up for this

 

[sutts]

Witherden is best suited to the rebounding half back role. He has been played as a faux lockdown defender for parts of the year in the worst WCE team in history. Of course his output has been average. Barrass aside, the entire WCE squad has been a steaming pile of sh!t. If you think Witherden is bad, have a look further up the field at the midfield.

 

[Tugga27]

Witherden is best suited to the rebounding half back role. He has been played as a faux lockdown defender for parts of the year in the worst WCE team in history. Of course his output has been average. Barrass aside, the entire WCE squad has been a steaming pile of sh!t. If you think Witherden is bad, have a look further up the field at the midfield.

Regardless of the rest of the team being shit, he's been putrid.
Is soft as butter and slow.

I can still picture Darcy Fogerty turning him inside out and then running away from him and having a bounce.

That he couldn't hold down a spot in a terrible side tells you all you need to know.

He's a list clogger.

 

[WCE_phil]

Can't defend, slow a treacle, kicking whilst it can be elite doesn't have the penetration of a younger hurn or Rich or Jetta. Also prone to ****ing 2-3 kicks a game resulting directly in goals. If his kicking gives up 3 goals a game and his defending gives up 3 goals a game nothing more needs to be said.

 

[Jack Richards]

Ok WCE fans aside who hate him. Is there anyone who thinks he could get to a 3rd club?

 

[McIvor]

Will forever be haunted by him not being able to catch that GWS lad late in the semi-final or preliminary final years ago that saw the Giants get that late goal and make the GF

 

[Scotland]

He's not a dud, he's just a guy with a limited skill set. Defensively limited and needs to be the attacking focal point of the defence to really shine.

If you are like Brisbane (Rich) or WC (Barrass vs the world, everything else a shambles) he is borderline. Could see him slotting into our team next year and playing every game or playing a handful of games and being de-listed. Ditto if he moves this off season.

 

[BeornJ]

Can't defend, slow a treacle, kicking whilst it can be elite doesn't have the penetration of a younger hurn or Rich or Jetta. Also prone to ******* 2-3 kicks a game resulting directly in goals. If his kicking gives up 3 goals a game and his defending gives up 3 goals a game nothing more needs to be said.

Mate, I like you, and respect your insights into footy, drafting and all things WCE but this is silly...

You've just decided that he is prone to directly leading to 2-3 opp goals a game. The most clangers he has kicked in a game this year is 5. That happened twice. He avgs 2.2 clangers a game, for comparisons sake Duggan averages 2.7. Also witherden averages more disposals a game so that's a lower clanger rate.

I still think he has had an off season, but not as bad as all that!

 

[Jack Richards]

Mate, I like you, and respect your insights into footy, drafting and all things WCE but this is silly...

You've just decided that he is prone to directly leading to 2-3 opp goals a game. The most clangers he has kicked in a game this year is 5. That happened twice. He avgs 2.2 clangers a game, for comparisons sake Duggan averages 2.7. Also witherden averages more disposals a game so that's a lower clanger rate.

I still think he has had an off season, but not as bad as all that!

I agree. In fact, stat wise he has had his best season in disposals.

If we want to talk poor performances, Ridley this year has been poor in an Essendon side.

It's natural that blokes in a poor performing side would be that. Poor.

The amount of people want Jake Kelly gone just because he was played as a lockdown key defender instead of manning small forwards.

If Witherden is delisted, I'll be shocked.

 

[Obeanie1]

I agree. In fact, stat wise he has had his best season in disposals.

If we want to talk poor performances, Ridley this year has been poor in an Essendon side.

It's natural that blokes in a poor performing side would be that. Poor.

The amount of people want Jake Kelly gone just because he was played as a lockdown key defender instead of manning small forwards.

If Witherden is delisted, I'll be shocked.

Not much fun playing defense at the Eagles this year.

Barrass had a ripper year as the intercept tall defender. Not surprising with the tsunami of ball being pumped into our defensive 50.

And when our defenders looked up field to rebound.................

 

[Tugga27]

I agree. In fact, stat wise he has had his best season in disposals.

If we want to talk poor performances, Ridley this year has been poor in an Essendon side.

It's natural that blokes in a poor performing side would be that. Poor.

The amount of people want Jake Kelly gone just because he was played as a lockdown key defender instead of manning small forwards.

If Witherden is delisted, I'll be shocked.

Be prepared to be shocked I reckon.

 

[iBeng]

Holy shit Witho is only 23? Feels like a decade ago we traded him after he was pegged to be Richs replacement in the backline...

 

[Lore]

Out of contract still?

 

[bzparkes]

Out of contract still?

Supposedly signed a 1 year extension early on, as posted by an ITK on our board.

 

[bzparkes]

Supposedly signed a 1 year extension early on, as posted by an ITK on our board.

And when I say early on, I mean a couple of years ago.

 

[Vindicater]

Will year up the seconds league somewhere you think

 

[Altum Volantes]

Contracted and still in the frame for a regular game at the Eagles, along with about 30 blokes at least this year.

 

[DollaDollaBeal]

So he is contracted? I cannot find anything about it, anywhere. Perhaps I'm not looking hard enough....

 

[3rd Grade Maggy]

Holy s**t Witho is only 23? Feels like a decade ago we traded him after he was pegged

Probably should have asked first.

 

[iBeng]

Probably should have asked first.

Consent is important kids!

 

[Ticky009]

Well, since final list submissions were completed on 1st December and he's still down as a listed player on the Eagles page - we can assume he's put pen to paper sometime and will be playing next year.