Restricted Free Agent Andrew Brayshaw

[s_wd6]

Serong banging on about 'Immortals', meanwhile Andy after being offered $1.5m per year by the Saints...

View attachment 2206564

Yeah but then he'd have to play for the Saints

 

[bzparkes]

Yeah but then he'd have to play for the Saints

Hmm, true.

 

[THE_GUN]

Yeah but then he'd have to play for the Saints

What's the difference between St Kilda & Fremantle apart from being in different states

 

[WilloTree]

What's the difference between St Kilda & Fremantle apart from being in different states

Liam Henry

 

[s_wd6]

What's the difference between St Kilda & Fremantle apart from being in different states

Purple is more flattering

 

[THE_GUN]

Purple is more flattering

Yes to Alvin Purple i suppose

 

[DragoDelph]

 

[Joao]

I'm surprised at only 6. Thought he'd get at least 7 in this current climate.

 

[strayadmbcnt]

Can the Cats offer $780,000 a year for 6 years? That was Dangerfields deal when he joined the cats at the end of 2015.

I am a bit nervous. Dockers dont make finals in 2025, I can see him leaving.

Then Again, I dreaded Sean Darcy leaving to join the cats as a free agent.

Maybe they should go after Darcy again, get him on the same deal as Brayshaw; free shipping that way, I'm pretty sure.

 

[King Huskii]

What's he worth on the open market?

 

[247Tigers]

What's he worth on the open market?

Champion Data has him as a top 40 player in comp. Top 30 midfielder. Cerong is rated Top 5 player, Top 4 midfielder.

Chad warner is rated top 15 player. Top 12 Midfielder. If you couldn't afford all three. Purely from Statistic (not always right). You prioritise Chad and Cerong. Which means if you had to lose Andy you would take that risk if you have a guarantee warner will sign. Preference is somehow you can afford all three.

 

[stallon]

Champion Data has him as a top 40 player in comp. Top 30 midfielder. Cerong is rated Top 5 player, Top 4 midfielder.

Chad warner is rated top 15 player. Top 12 Midfielder. If you couldn't afford all three. Purely from Statistic (not always right). You prioritise Chad and Cerong. Which means if you had to lose Andy you would take that risk if you have a guarantee warner will sign. Preference is somehow you can afford all three.

You cant look at it as simply as that, it looks pretty bad if they refuse to pay one of their best players and let him walk just to get a different guy in.

Remember it wouldnt be just Andy for Warner, itd probably be Andy + their 1st rounder + a f1 + potentially more depending on ladder position for Warner.
Thats just not worth it at all.

 

[RonnieRaven]

You cant look at it as simply as that, it looks pretty bad if they refuse to pay one of their best players and let him walk just to get a different guy in.

Remember it wouldnt be just Andy for Warner, itd probably be Andy + their 1st rounder + a f1 + potentially more depending on ladder position for Warner.
Thats just not worth it at all.

Sounds like eagles are going to pay up if you think Warner is worth
AB(BNF,MVP,AA) + 1st rd + F1st + more.
Here’s a table for score inv averages in 2024

Id prefer to Keep AB then package him up with a couple 1sts and more for a chance at warner.
Everyone on that table is jizzed about except AB who just keeps getting it done without th fan fare.

 

[stallon]

Sounds like eagles are going to pay up if you think Warner is worth
AB(BNF,MVP,AA) + 1st rd + F1st + more.
Here’s a table for score inv averages in 2024
View attachment 2211624
Id prefer to Keep AB then package him up with a couple 1sts and more for a chance at warner.
Everyone on that table is jizzed about except AB who just keeps getting it done without th fan fare.

What pick do you expect to get for Andy? Hes a free agent, and if he wanted to go to the Saints or something you wouldnt be able to comfortably match it

Freo are expected to at least make finals, lets say they end up 6th.
Pick 14+15+f1 is definitely not more than I expect the Eagles to pay if he wants to come, something like wce 2025+2026 1st rounders for Warner+swans 1st