Trade Requested Bailey Smith

Remove this Banner Ad

Either Dogs accept the deal (it’s not even a bad deal, this draft is deep)

If the deal you’re referring to is Cats first + f2 for Smith, no doubt Dogs knock that back and send him to the draft. It’s impossible to swallow such a terrible deal for our club sending one of our key assets to a premiership competitor. Also his manager is the same as JUH’s so if we accept peanuts it sets a precedent.

No doubt a deal will be done and we won’t get his full value, but Cats f+f1 have to be involved or the more likely scenario of Cats trading up to satisfy Power.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

He wants to come play for the team he’s old man played for

So those two are lying?

He lives in Tourqay with his siblings and loves to surf, not to mention most of his mates play for the Cats
Why would he give that up to move to Carlton?

Carlton fans tried pushing it the other day and both Edmund and Twomey answered it on SEN this week.
Edmund said it’s rubbish and Twomey flat out said no.

The reason he’s not playing has nothing to do with form, he’s best 22 when fit and healthy.
 
So those two are lying?

He lives in Tourqay with his siblings and loves to surf, not to mention most of his mates play for the Cats
Why would he give that up to move to Carlton?

Carlton fans tried pushing it the other day and both Edmund and Twomey answered it on SEN this week.
Edmund said it’s rubbish and Twomey flat out said no.

The reason he’s not playing has nothing to do with form, he’s best 22 when fit and healthy.
Believe it or not having to drive an hour to work is pretty common practice. Blake Acres lives down in Geelong but plays for Carlton without issue, SDK could still head off for a surf after work whether he lives in Geelong or Melbourne.

SDK for Baz would be about right in terms of trade value pre knee. Think the Dogs would have to chuck in a sweetener to get a deal over the line involving those two though.
 
Believe it or not having to drive an hour to work is pretty common practice. Blake Acres lives down in Geelong but plays for Carlton without issue, SDK could still head off for a surf after work whether he lives in Geelong or Melbourne.

SDK for Baz would be about right in terms of trade value pre knee. Think the Dogs would have to chuck in a sweetener to get a deal over the line involving those two though.

Did you read what I said, Twomey and Edmund said it’s not happening.
That’s a pretty good sign that it’s not happening.

This thread is about Baz. Let’s not sidetrack it.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Trade Requested Bailey Smith

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top