barry hall replacement thread

[Oscarman]

Thinking about Bernie Vince. Averaging 84 - not too bad, and it means I could trade Nathan Jones for Chris Judd.

 

[Drummond]

I'm keeping Hall.

 

[mollyfud]

I am looking at this a bit different! I am thinking:
1) Rioli off the Bench to starting position
2) Hall traded for REIMERS (ess) him moving to the bench
3) (and this is the killer) Travis Tuck traded for (Drum roll please) G Abblett!

If I trade Hall to Reimers, I have 439200 to get a Mid to replace Tuck (worried that he might be sent back to Box Hill soon).

How does that sound? I just love this move to give me another captain target. Should I consider another mid? I basically could have any except Bartell and Corey!

Molly

 

[BigSudz]

Out Hall - In Mayne (Rioli onto field)

Out - T Tuck (pending injury) In K Cornes

 

[spence]

I am looking at this a bit different! I am thinking:
1) Rioli off the Bench to starting position
2) Hall traded for REIMERS (ess) him moving to the bench
3) (and this is the killer) Travis Tuck traded for (Drum roll please) G Abblett!

If I trade Hall to Reimers, I have 439200 to get a Mid to replace Tuck (worried that he might be sent back to Box Hill soon).

How does that sound? I just love this move to give me another captain target. Should I consider another mid? I basically could have any except Bartell and Corey!

Molly

Yeah looks pretty good, i reckon ud be looking to pick up Kornes, he would be a steal if he gets under 400,000 soon hopefully he keeps decreasing.
How many trades have you used so far?

 

[mollyfud]

Yeah looks pretty good, i reckon ud be looking to pick up Kornes, he would be a steal if he gets under 400,000 soon hopefully he keeps decreasing.
How many trades have you used so far?

Already have him. Worked out if I go for Mayne of Freo, can get Corey! Thinking that might be the best option!
Molly

 

[DiscoBiscuits]

Had ROK all of last year and am a big fan - but BJ in a week's time, just can't look past him.

Same. He is v.consistent and came 10th overall in 2007 out of the forwards.

 

[foxy_dal]

Hmm i think i will trade him for SJ or i could afford O'keefe to the exact dollar.

 

[The Special 1]

Current Forward Line:
Franklin, Fevola, Riewoldt, Hall, J. Brown, J. Hill, Ryoli (Tippet, Jetta)
Desired Forward Line:
Franklin, Fevola, Riewoldt, Pavlich, J. Brown, BJ, Chapman

this week im lookn at starting Tippet with Hall on the bench, i kno tippet will score poorly, but i dont want 2 trade any of my 3 desired forwards at ther current price. 1 week later i will get BJ when his price goes down, and then when Hill and Ryolis prices max i will upgrade 2 Pav and Chap for minimal money from the bank.

 

[blues4flag]

Hmmm...I'll be holding off for a week at least, but if Chappy drops enough, I'd be tempted to go him over Johnson. Should be making the Wood to Cox trade this week (or next week, depending if the price drop is more tempting than the extra points) - if I get Cox this week, I'll have 72k left over to upgrade Hall.