- Banned
- #1
Are the Beach Boys musically superior to the likes of Mozart, Hendrix, and the Beatles?
Beach Boys musically the best ever?
- Thread starter bunsen burner
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Oct 17, 2003
- 10,792
- 4
- Other Teams
- Banned
- #2
one day we'll be swabbing 500 year old piano's in attempts to clone mozart
nobody will ever clone the beach boys
nobody will ever clone the beach boys
Hungry29
Debutant
bunsen burner said:
Yes. Yes they are.
And nobody comes close to Brian Wilson.
Muunky Tuunk Man
Cancelled
I don't believe there is an answer to this because everyone has different tastes in music and everyone will say something entirely different.
- Oct 17, 2003
- 10,792
- 4
- Other Teams
- Banned
- #5
dude, there's an answer. and it's not the becah boysMuunky Tuunk Man said:
Muunky Tuunk Man
Cancelled
Karbassiyoon said:
Who are they? Are they a metal version of the Beach Boys?
- Oct 17, 2003
- 10,792
- 4
- Other Teams
- Banned
- #7
yep, it's not the becah boys, and its not the becah boys eitherMuunky Tuunk Man said:
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #8
Then your answer must be no. If you're not sure then they can't be head and shoulders above the rest. This isn't about personal preferences, it's about whether you think they without a doubt clearly superior than the rest.Muunky Tuunk Man said:
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #9
Question for Unit: what's your reasoning?
Because it is absolutely impossible to be definitive on anything regarding Music or any other such creative, individually judged thing, you simply can't answer this question with a yes.
- Oct 17, 2003
- 10,792
- 4
- Other Teams
- Banned
- #11
unless of course you truly believed they were the very best.NorthBhoy said:
it'd be like asking a religious fanatic which was the best religion - all logic and sense would go out the window and none of the values of the other religions would be taken into account - the fanatic would go with his own
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #12
Bingo.NorthBhoy said:
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #13
Let me clarify the agenda of this thread for the people who don't already know:Karbassiyoon said:
This is not about personal opinion. Fire Storm is trying to pass this off as fact as you will see from a few of his quotes below.
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=153598
fire storm said:
fire storm said:
fire storm said:
The best bit is where he says no one covers the Beach Boys because they are musically too hard to cover. It still makes me laugh.fire storm said:
- Oct 17, 2003
- 10,792
- 4
- Other Teams
- Banned
- #14
hold on, didn't david lee roth or whoever he was cover them in like the 80's?
I didn't say it, Sir George Martin said it regarding perhaps the greatest rock song of all - Good Vibrations.
You might be right if it was ONE person saying it. But not well respected people IN the music industry the WORLD over.
But your not.
You might be right if it was ONE person saying it. But not well respected people IN the music industry the WORLD over.
But your not.
David Lee Roths version was average at best. And had a Beach Boys member or two singing some backround harmonys.
Musically and vocally, the original is so much more superiour its not funny.
Musically and vocally, the original is so much more superiour its not funny.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #17
Champ, you're trying to pass BB/BW off as the Don Bradman of musicians. The sooner you get your head out of your ass, the sooner you will stop embarassing yourself.Fire Storm said:
Your wrong and you have no where else to go. Your such a clown, Bunsen. I see you havn't checked the other thread. I wonder why........
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #19
I thought you said on the other thread that everyone would agree with you and you would all be laughing at me? <points at the poll results>Fire Storm said:
- Oct 17, 2003
- 10,792
- 4
- Other Teams
- Banned
- #20
i never said the cover was any goodFire Storm said:
I said the 'music world' - The produces, arrangers, composers, song writers, engineers, session players, and singers
Not bigfooty members.
Only good thing about Roth's version is the bikini girls. Hey, I'm a shallow guy....
Not bigfooty members.
Only good thing about Roth's version is the bikini girls. Hey, I'm a shallow guy....
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #22
Take your medicine (i.e. read the poll) and have a lie down.Fire Storm said:
So you'd rather believe Bigfooty members rather then all those people I mentioned who have MILES more crediblity then everyone here put together? Hell, even ONE of those guys surpasses everyone here(including me).
You just get deeper and deeper into the ridicules, Bunsen.
You just get deeper and deeper into the ridicules, Bunsen.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #24
Considering many of the people you mention would have made similar compliments about other musicians, absolutely.Fire Storm said:
So how come few on here agree with you?
Fire Storm said:
Yes, but surely the point is that one could find a more respected person (or group of people) who could be quoted as saying another group or artist are "the best", which is obviously their own opinion.
IMO, you have yourself too deep in this one and don't want to back out. Bunsen won't stop until you concede. Walk away dude.
