Best Player in the APS

[SouthSwans]

Who do you think?

 

[Candy]

I'll go Sandilands

 

[SouthSwans]

Apologies to any Melbourne Grammar people I've offended, I should of put one of your player's in there.

Carey and Wesley, well....

 

[nostril]

Brasd GUilder finished last year didnt he?

And Shaw from MGS and Laisle from Carey should be in there

 

[bohemoth]

Some interesting choices there. Kennedy been on that list is quite controversial especially looking at some of the xavier players u have put ahead of him. Sam Lees, Buckley, Thomas are just a few very highly rated players at xavier. How about Weddel from Geelong College. Played awesome against us

 

[SouthSwans]

Some interesting choices there. Kennedy been on that list is quite controversial especially looking at some of the xavier players u have put ahead of him. Sam Lees, Buckley, Thomas are just a few very highly rated players at xavier. How about Weddel from Geelong College. Played awesome against us

Just doing my best from my knowledge.

 

[mainboardboycotter]

Yeah Vickery ahead of Nicolopolous. I vote Cyril Rioli just ahead of Henderson, Sanflippo and Sandilands. He has that X factor, super player. Sundberg is up there, James Strauss is jsut about best.

 

[Danzig]

what about sam lees and the big ulbasaurus - the best ruckman in the aps

 

[underthepack]

sam hall.. how could u go any1 else.. top 10 draft pick 08

 

[specialedition]

the big ulbasaurus - the best ruckman in the aps

yeh the thing about that. no.

 

[no buffer]

Hugh Sandilands is better than Lynch
Tom Sundberg is better than Sanfillipo
Cam Penburthy is better than Scott Newman
but from what ive heard cyril rioli looks like being top 10 draft pick so it would definately be him

 

[Onballer]

okeefe

 

[pup12]

um just wandering where is Vickery and Ashely smith in that list cause they are to all aus players so i think they would dominate most peoople on that list

 

[ggb07]

how bout zach senstock from cgs?? hes a fair gun ive heard, played footy with him back in under 9-14s and he was always a gun, also played with penberthy in the same team,, very talented players both of them

 

[footy09]

Cyril "Junior" Rioli. First round draft pick. ENOUGH SAID

 

[TheFinalSay]

Apologies to any Melbourne Grammar people I've offended, I should of put one of your player's in there.

so u should be-charles shaw is in the best 15 after dominating APS in yr 10.
Cyril Rioli is my no. 1

 

[kangaroo pill]

Yeah South Swans, probably not a good post from you.
Doesnt sound like you know enough depth in football.. who are you?
Vickey
Parisi
Shaw
-all are freaks and would be in the top 10 in the aps.

 

[SouthSwans]

Yeah South Swans, probably not a good post from you.
Doesnt sound like you know enough depth in football.. who are you?
Vickey
Parisi
Shaw
-all are freaks and would be in the top 10 in the aps.

Parisi? Top 10?

I missed Vickery and Shaw and apologised for that earlier.

 

[highflyer123]

Parisi definitely not top 10 would struggle to make the top 20 IMO

 

[over the top]

wheres pat macarthy?

 

[SouthSwans]

Newman, Hall, Kennedy/McCarthy.

Kennedy's better IMO.

 

[Alan Smith]

Apologies to any Melbourne Grammar people I've offended, I should of put one of your player's in there.

Carey and Wesley, well....

George Beatty?
Rioli 4 me anyway

 

[Footy1]

i dont know what you guys are playing at. rioli should be one and sandilands is a good player but sanfillippo is shocking!!! all he is a straight line running full forward, that doesnt make him a good player he needs to be able to play other positions.

 

[pup12]

Parisi? Top 10?

I missed Vickery and Shaw and apologised for that earlier.

you also missed ashley smith who is easily one of the best players if not the best player in the aps

 

[jimbojones90]

risol ziebal tilly nash?