Best Player in the APS

[Candy]

Apologies to any Melbourne Grammar people I've offended, I should of put one of your player's in there.

Carey and Wesley, well....

Funny you say that, cause Harry Croft got selected in the Vic Metro squad. (for wesley).

 

[carrazzo_44]

Tom Newton hands down... played the best game i have ever seen him play on sat against brighton... #4 for carey absolute gun... silky skills of ben holland/mark bolton , the courage of josh hunt, speed of sandilands, football brain of kepler bradley, set shot ability of matthew richardson and racks it up like simon prestigicomo.. absolute gun

 

[Let's Fly Jetstar!]

SouthSWans your commentary is so ****en shit

 

[jimbojones90]

yamen would have to be in there

 

[SouthSwans]

Tilly was next in from CGS, but mate theres more players than just our boys...

 

[Gary_Ablett_5]

George Beatty very talented footballer from wesley....but i think we can all agree the battle for the best in the aps is a two horse race between Hall and Rioli

 

[nostril]

How is it that Henderson has only 1 vote? he is easlily the best centre hafl/full forward in the APS. Kicked 8 goals in the APS game last year and some say a 1st round pick this year.

Definately between Rioli and Henderson

 

[love_the_punt]

why isnt smith and vickery in that polll??

 

[bigraj]

BEcause Smith and Hickey Like the **** seriously they arent good enough thats why

 

[SouthSwans]

why isnt smith and vickery in that polll??

Seriously, there is the 'other' option....

It's difficult to make a poll like that, someone's bound to be left out. Vickery and Charlie Shaw should be in it. There the only ones legitimately good enough to be in that list who aren't. Beatty possibly aswell.

 

[Billy Costigan]

Beatty is shithouse! most unfit player in the aps!

Juniour Rioli easily the best dissappointing he is injured but will return is becoming very very fit!

 

[mad dawg 1]

BEcause Smith and Hickey Like the **** seriously they arent good enough thats why

there obviously not good enough so thats why they were in AIS and played against south africa. surely there not good enough...

 

[notorious_big]

Criso Sanfillipo 3 votes. Probs good player, fair nut and will king hit people if they hit number 12 vice versa. Better bloke then the entire list.

 

[the off white]

What about mccarthy(stkevs) and croft(wes) both vic metro squad and curnow(GC) vic country squad.

Also Gilder finished at haileybury last year

 

[scrumrugby1]

big bad sammy hall is the best in the APS 1st round draft pick for sure

 

[the boundary]

well running the boundary this year iv seen many fine players but scott newman #5 from skc would hav to be one of the best as well as #2 luke andrews both very talented......tom mcdermott #4 is also a gun and a dangerous full forward

andrew swan from ggs is also a great player and would be one of the best for them pretty hard to be a good player in a shit team though

tom lynch from HC had a disappointing game against SKC just got taken out of the game by J.Cachia a much better and younger player

 

[samwell27]

nial collins?
should be in the poll, i uderstand there is always going to be people that miss out but seriously, he should be in there
next great NFL Quaterback, sets the team up from the halfback line superbly

 

[bombersman_moon]

Definitly Kennedy great overall player