-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Best Point Guard Since Magic
- Thread starter bluesSAfan
- Start date
- Tagged users None
knowledgeable fan
Senior List
steve nash is the best PG since Magic! Jason Kidd im beginning to think is overrated and has been his whole career..thoughts?
he was thinking...
"gosh, Steve and Dirk had six opportunities to win a title, and didn't even get close"
- Banned
- #156
I dont rate Nash that high.
Payton, Stockden and another few white boys have been better.
Payton, Stockden and another few white boys have been better.
Marcus Banks and DJ Strawberry to become the powerhouse PG's over the next 2 years... ohhhh yeah and Rondo a close 3rd
You know, I don't really reckon an pivotal PG is that important to a championship winning side anymore (look at the Bulls/Lakers/Spurs dynasties in the last 10 - 20 years) none of them had what you would call an 'elite' HOF PG did they ???
Also how many titles have Nash and Kidd etc won in their careers ???
Also how many titles have Nash and Kidd etc won in their careers ???
Look2Me4Guidance
Destination Club Supporter
How many has John Stockton won?
Bomberz_pacers07
Team Captain
Jamaal 'the abuser' Tinsley
- Banned
- #161
well I'm glad you waited until the end of his career before deciding that.
I guess once you saw Gary Payton in Miami you finally realised he had been overrated his entire career too? hmm?
- Banned
- #162
- Banned
- #163
Nash and Kidd, as good as they were, aren't all-time greats at their position. Jordan, Shaq and Duncan are.
I'm not sure if the Hornets are ready this year, but if Chris Paul can continue to improve (especially his 3pt shot), they'll be perennial contenders. His current season is already better than any season by Kidd or Nash, and by the time he's done I feel he'll definitely be in the discussion for greatest all-time PG (health permitting).
- Banned
- #164
Tony Parker?
Haha, only white guys play PG...bet you love those white boys...
Did you forget to mention he has a top 5 PF of all time playing with him. I think that has something to do with it.
- Banned
- #166
You mean no.1?
Really, Duncan's been a C ever since Robinson left, but if he's viewed as a PF he's the clear-cut best ever.
- Banned
- #167
Nah, Horace Grant.
Nah, seriously, Parker is good. I hate his guts, but you've got to give it to him.
- Banned
- #168
it's not that clear cut, but he's a certain contender as the best.
- Sep 9, 2003
- 27,578
- 28,760
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- FGR
Kidd is. A ring isn't the be all and end all.
- Banned
- #170
I shoot better than Jason Kidd.
He is second to Magic all-time at running the fast break, and he was an incredible defender for a lot of years, but he couldn't run the pick-and-roll and wasn't terribly effective in the half-court due to his rubbish shooting.
Give me Magic, Isiah, Stockton or Payton any day. Kidd is definitely top 10, but when I said all-time great, I meant best 2-3 I guess.
Based on what?.. What he has on his fingers?On talent there are many better PF's than Duncan.. Not disrespectful to him because he is a superstar and probably top 10 ever PF's but too say he is clear-cut the best over is a joke
- Banned
- #172
You need to watch more Tim Duncan. On talent alone he is miles in front of any other PF.
Barkley is the only guy who comes close, and he sucked defensively. Malone = overrated.
Currently listed players Garnett>Duncan
In hiistory Barkley, McHale possibly even Kemp > Duncan
- Banned
- #174
LARRY BIRD!>Duncan.
