MVP BigFooty West Coast Eagles Player of the Year 2023 - Results Thread

[Bender_]

INTEGRITY

 

[Carbine Chaos]

I want a royal commission into how many other posters 'loved' their sponsored players in this.

Why always me?

 

[squashface]

I want a royal commission into how many other posters 'loved' their sponsored players in this.

Why always me?

This is a stat I am willing to dig up for you

 

[ArdentEagle]

Maybe a rule should be made so people can't vote for their sponsored player.

It would help stop skewed voting stats

 

[ArdentEagle]

I want a royal commission into how many other posters 'loved' their sponsored players in this.

Why always me?

Every year you get certain crushes. It's pretty funny truth be told

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Maybe a rule should be made so people can't vote for their sponsored player.

It would help stop skewed voting stats

On the contrary, friend.

My votes ensured Petch's finishing position here was nearly identical to where he finished in the real BnF.

I merely ensured justice was done.

 

[Bender_]

Maybe a rule should be made so people can't vote for their sponsored player.

It would help stop skewed voting stats

Yeah but then we couldn't get all judgey and shit.

 

[ArdentEagle]

On the contrary, friend.

My votes ensured Petch's finishing position here was nearly identical to where he finished in the real BnF.

I merely ensured justice was done.

That's one way to look at it I suppose.

What about your other crushes, you filthy tart!

 

[squashface]

Mulldogg you missed Round 22 v Fremantle

Tim Kelly 54 votes
Jayden Hunt 27 votes
Oscar Allen 27 votes
Jamaine Jones 25 votes
Bailey Williams 23 votes
Brady Hough 20 votes
Liam Duggan 18 votes
Rueben Ginbey 15 votes
Luke Shuey 14 votes
Dom Sheed 11 votes
Alex Witherden 10 votes
Jeremy McGovern 8 votes
Andrew Gaff 8 votes
Jake Waterman 8 votes
Jamie Cripps 7 votes
Elliot Yeo 7 votes
Tom Cole 6 votes
Ryan Maric 5 votes
Jack Darling 5 votes
Tom Barrass 5 votes
Jack Petruccelle 5 votes
Liam Ryan 5 votes
Campbell Chesser 3 votes
Elijah Hewett 3 votes
Shannon Hurn 3 votes
Jai Culley 3 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 3 votes
Connor West 1 vote
Xavier O'Neill 1 vote

Player you loved: Brady Hough (6 votes more than average)
Player you hated: Elijah Hewett & Elliot Yeo (7 votes less than average)

 

[squashface]

peeky you missed Round 22 v Fremantle

Tim Kelly 50 votes
Jamaine Jones 25 votes
Jayden Hunt 24 votes
Bailey Williams 21 votes
Brady Hough 18 votes
Rueben Ginbey 17 votes
Luke Shuey 16 votes
Elliot Yeo 15 votes
Oscar Allen 14 votes
Liam Duggan 14 votes
Jack Petruccelle 13 votes
Alex Witherden 12 votes
Elijah Hewett 11 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 11 votes
Jake Waterman 9 votes
Ryan Maric 8 votes
Jack Darling 8 votes
Tom Cole 7 votes
Dom Sheed 6 votes
Tom Barrass 5 votes
Shannon Hurn 5 votes
Jeremy McGovern 5 votes
Andrew Gaff 4 votes
Jamie Cripps 3 votes
Campbell Chesser 3 votes
Jai Culley 3 votes
Liam Ryan 2 votes
Noah Long 1 vote

Player you loved: Reuben Ginbey (6 votes more than average)
Player you hated: Oscar Allen (11 votes less than average)

 

[squashface]

Shifty1 you missed Round 22 v Fremantle

Tim Kelly 50 votes
Bailey Williams 34 votes
Jayden Hunt 33 votes
Liam Duggan 23 votes
Oscar Allen 21 votes
Jamaine Jones 21 votes
Luke Shuey 17 votes
Elliot Yeo 16 votes
Brady Hough 16 votes
Jamie Cripps 14 votes
Dom Sheed 12 votes
Jake Waterman 12 votes
Rueben Ginbey 8 votes
Jeremy McGovern 8 votes
Andrew Gaff 6 votes
Alex Witherden 6 votes
Elijah Hewett 5 votes
Liam Ryan 5 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 4 votes
Tom Cole 4 votes
Tom Barrass 4 votes
Jack Darling 3 votes
Noah Long 2 votes
Jai Culley 2 votes
Jack Petruccelle 2 votes
Shannon Hurn 1 vote
Xavier O'Neill 1 vote

Player you loved: Bailey Williams (8 votes more than average)
Player you hated: Jack Petruccelle (6 votes less than average)

 

[Shifty1]

Shifty1 you missed Round 22 v Fremantle

Tim Kelly 50 votes
Bailey Williams 34 votes
Jayden Hunt 33 votes
Liam Duggan 23 votes
Oscar Allen 21 votes
Jamaine Jones 21 votes
Luke Shuey 17 votes
Elliot Yeo 16 votes
Brady Hough 16 votes
Jamie Cripps 14 votes
Dom Sheed 12 votes
Jake Waterman 12 votes
Rueben Ginbey 8 votes
Jeremy McGovern 8 votes
Andrew Gaff 6 votes
Alex Witherden 6 votes
Elijah Hewett 5 votes
Liam Ryan 5 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 4 votes
Tom Cole 4 votes
Tom Barrass 4 votes
Jack Darling 3 votes
Noah Long 2 votes
Jai Culley 2 votes
Jack Petruccelle 2 votes
Shannon Hurn 1 vote
Xavier O'Neill 1 vote

Player you loved: Bailey Williams (8 votes more than average)
Player you hated: Jack Petruccelle (6 votes less than average)

Thanks for the effort squashface

Not surprised with my hated player. Not a fan of Petch.

 

[ArdentEagle]

Thanks for the effort squashface

Not surprised with my hated player. Not a fan of Petch.

Carbine Chaos

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Everyone is entitled to their incorrect opinions.

 

[Mulldogg]

Mulldogg you missed Round 22 v Fremantle

Tim Kelly 54 votes
Jayden Hunt 27 votes
Oscar Allen 27 votes
Jamaine Jones 25 votes
Bailey Williams 23 votes
Brady Hough 20 votes
Liam Duggan 18 votes
Rueben Ginbey 15 votes
Luke Shuey 14 votes
Dom Sheed 11 votes
Alex Witherden 10 votes
Jeremy McGovern 8 votes
Andrew Gaff 8 votes
Jake Waterman 8 votes
Jamie Cripps 7 votes
Elliot Yeo 7 votes
Tom Cole 6 votes
Ryan Maric 5 votes
Jack Darling 5 votes
Tom Barrass 5 votes
Jack Petruccelle 5 votes
Liam Ryan 5 votes
Campbell Chesser 3 votes
Elijah Hewett 3 votes
Shannon Hurn 3 votes
Jai Culley 3 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 3 votes
Connor West 1 vote
Xavier O'Neill 1 vote

Player you loved: Brady Hough (6 votes more than average)
Player you hated: Elijah Hewett & Elliot Yeo (7 votes less than average)

Cheers Squashface.

Surprised about the Hewett one, I’m a massive fan but was obviously a bit harsh in allocating votes.

Reckon he grabs the competition by the thruff of the scrote next year though

 

[squashface]

Kapowie1 you missed Round 17 v Brisbane

Tim Kelly 54 votes
Oscar Allen 39 votes
Bailey Williams 26 votes
Jayden Hunt 20 votes
Jamaine Jones 16 votes
Luke Shuey 14 votes
Rueben Ginbey 13 votes
Elliot Yeo 13 votes
Liam Duggan 13 votes
Shannon Hurn 12 votes
Andrew Gaff 11 votes
Brady Hough 11 votes
Noah Long 10 votes
Alex Witherden 10 votes
Jake Waterman 8 votes
Jamie Cripps 8 votes
Dom Sheed 7 votes
Elijah Hewett 7 votes
Tom Barrass 6 votes
Ryan Maric 5 votes
Liam Ryan 5 votes
Josh Rotham 5 votes
Jack Darling 4 votes
Jai Culley 3 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 3 votes
Tom Cole 2 votes
Greg Clark 2 votes
Jeremy McGovern 2 votes
Jack Petruccelle 1 vote

Player you loved: Oscar Allen (14 votes more than average)
Player you hated: Jack Petrucelle (7 votes less than average)

 

[squashface]

Bender_ you missed Round 15 v Sydney and Round 22 v Fremantle

Tim Kelly 43 votes
Bailey Williams 29 votes
Jayden Hunt 27 votes
Jamaine Jones 26 votes
Oscar Allen 25 votes
Liam Duggan 21 votes
Brady Hough 18 votes
Rueben Ginbey 12 votes
Elliot Yeo 12 votes
Alex Witherden 11 votes
Ryan Maric 9 votes
Liam Ryan 9 votes
Luke Shuey 9 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 8 votes
Andrew Gaff 7 votes
Jamie Cripps 7 votes
Jake Waterman 7 votes
Tom Barrass 6 votes
Dom Sheed 6 votes
Jack Petruccelle 6 votes
Elijah Hewett 4 votes
Jai Culley 4 votes
Jeremy McGovern 3 votes
Campbell Chesser 2 votes
Tom Cole 2 votes
Jack Darling 1 vote
Xavier O'Neill 1 vote

Player you loved: Ryan Maric & Jamaine Jones (7 votes more than average)
Player you hated: You gave Tim Kelly 12 votes less than average but given he still won your count I can't really say you hated him. So we will go with Luke Shuey (6 votes less than average)

 

[Bender_]

Bender_ you missed Round 15 v Sydney and Round 22 v Fremantle

Tim Kelly 43 votes
Bailey Williams 29 votes
Jayden Hunt 27 votes
Jamaine Jones 26 votes
Oscar Allen 25 votes
Liam Duggan 21 votes
Brady Hough 18 votes
Rueben Ginbey 12 votes
Elliot Yeo 12 votes
Alex Witherden 11 votes
Ryan Maric 9 votes
Liam Ryan 9 votes
Luke Shuey 9 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 8 votes
Andrew Gaff 7 votes
Jamie Cripps 7 votes
Jake Waterman 7 votes
Tom Barrass 6 votes
Dom Sheed 6 votes
Jack Petruccelle 6 votes
Elijah Hewett 4 votes
Jai Culley 4 votes
Jeremy McGovern 3 votes
Campbell Chesser 2 votes
Tom Cole 2 votes
Jack Darling 1 vote
Xavier O'Neill 1 vote

Player you loved: Ryan Maric & Jamaine Jones (7 votes more than average)
Player you hated: You gave Tim Kelly 12 votes less than average but given he still won your count I can't really say you hated him. So we will go with Luke Shuey (6 votes less than average)

Pretty accurate. I found even in Kelly's best games his disposal was a bit poor and put me off giving him votes. Cheers Squashy.

 

[squashface]

As requested by Carbine Chaos

These are the only player sponsors for 2023 to vote for the sponsored players - to the surprise of no one, CC almost lapped the field twice.

Player Sponsor Leaderboard
Carbine Chaos - Jack Petruccelle 37 votes
omgfridge - Tom Cole 13 votes
Hook461123 - Tim Kelly 8 votes
Schtinker - Jamaine Jones 8 votes
SloppyJoe - Connor West 7 votes
eaglespremiers - Jack Darling 7 votes
Keys - Sam Petrevski-Seton 4 votes
KBLT - Xavier O'Neill 3 votes
AsterixTheGaul - Jamie Cripps 2 votes
Doashuey - Jayden Hunt 1 vote
dinnaz - Andrew Gaff 1 vote

 

[ArdentEagle]

Pretty accurate. I found even in Kelly's best games his disposal was a bit poor and put me off giving him votes. Cheers Squashy.

I really thought I was the same. I was very surprised to see I gave him as many votes as I did. Disposal shat me off most weeks

 

[squashface]

Leaderboard at the bye

1 Tim Kelly 28.39 votes
2 Jamaine Jones 19.65 votes
3 Oscar Allen 18.85 votes
4 Jayden Hunt 17.20 votes
5 Bailey Williams 16.33 votes
6 Liam Duggan 12.03 votes
7 Elliot Yeo 10.55 votes
8 Rueben Ginbey 9.95 votes
9 Dom Sheed 9.39 votes
10 Jake Waterman 8.54 votes
11 Alex Witherden 5.98 votes
12 Liam Ryan 5.26 votes
13 Sam Petrevski-Seton 4.65 votes
14 Luke Shuey 4.41 votes
15 Tom Barrass 3.72 votes
16 Jeremy McGovern 2.98 votes
17 Shannon Hurn 2.68 votes
18 Andrew Gaff 2.53 votes
19 Jai Culley 2.40 votes
20 Xavier O'Neill 2.03 votes
21 Jack Petruccelle 1.83 votes
22 Brady Hough 1.31 votes
23 Noah Long 1.17 votes
24 Jamie Cripps 0.68 votes
25 Connor West 0.65 votes
26 Ryan Maric 0.63 votes
27 Luke Edwards 0.46 votes
28 Josh Rotham 0.26 votes
29 Rhett Bazzo 0.18 votes
30 Jack Darling 0.15 votes
31 Callum Jamieson 0.06 votes
32 Greg Clark 0.06 votes
33 Luke Foley 0.03 votes

Few takeaways:
Kelly already near uncatchable by this point
Hough finished strong to go from 22nd to 8th after the bye
Ryan was sat just outside the top 10 here despite not playing since Round 3

 

[squashface]

That's all the requests I have for individual votes or stats. If you want your votes or want to see any sort of stat from the data let me know.

If not then I ride off into the sunset after 5 years and can finally rest.



It's Bender_ 's ship now

 

[Keys]

Thanks squashface for your work on this over the years

Much appreciated

 

[Schtinker]

As requested by Carbine Chaos

These are the only player sponsors for 2023 to vote for the sponsored players - to the surprise of no one, CC almost lapped the field twice.

Player Sponsor Leaderboard
Carbine Chaos - Jack Petruccelle 37 votes
omgfridge - Tom Cole 13 votes
Hook461123 - Tim Kelly 8 votes
Schtinker - Jamaine Jones 8 votes
SloppyJoe - Connor West 7 votes
eaglespremiers - Jack Darling 7 votes
Keys - Sam Petrevski-Seton 4 votes
KBLT - Xavier O'Neill 3 votes
AsterixTheGaul - Jamie Cripps 2 votes
Doashuey - Jayden Hunt 1 vote
dinnaz - Andrew Gaff 1 vote

I woz robbed!!!!

 

[BeornJ]

Bender_ you missed Round 15 v Sydney and Round 22 v Fremantle

Tim Kelly 43 votes
Bailey Williams 29 votes
Jayden Hunt 27 votes
Jamaine Jones 26 votes
Oscar Allen 25 votes
Liam Duggan 21 votes
Brady Hough 18 votes
Rueben Ginbey 12 votes
Elliot Yeo 12 votes
Alex Witherden 11 votes
Ryan Maric 9 votes
Liam Ryan 9 votes
Luke Shuey 9 votes
Sam Petrevski-Seton 8 votes
Andrew Gaff 7 votes
Jamie Cripps 7 votes
Jake Waterman 7 votes
Tom Barrass 6 votes
Dom Sheed 6 votes
Jack Petruccelle 6 votes
Elijah Hewett 4 votes
Jai Culley 4 votes
Jeremy McGovern 3 votes
Campbell Chesser 2 votes
Tom Cole 2 votes
Jack Darling 1 vote
Xavier O'Neill 1 vote

Player you loved: Ryan Maric & Jamaine Jones (7 votes more than average)
Player you hated: You gave Tim Kelly 12 votes less than average but given he still won your count I can't really say you hated him. So we will go with Luke Shuey (6 votes less than average)

Bender_ Only 11 votes for the greatest one on one defender in the comp?!