Bluemour Melting Pot XX - Snark Free Zone

[KnobHead]

We're interested in Bonar but probably won't have the currency to get it done. Casboult has been tabled as a potential swap.

Nice work Reg


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Navara79]

We're interested in Bonar but probably won't have the currency to get it done. Casboult has been tabled as a potential swap.

Casboult told people at the b&f that he isn't going anywhere

 

[DrTrain]

We're interested in Bonar but probably won't have the currency to get it done. Casboult has been tabled as a potential swap.

Has he done a medical?

 

[Blue Rising]

Casboult told people at the b&f that he isn't going anywhere

So did Dayne Beams

On CPH1831 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[BlueBoyBrett]

We're interested in Bonar but probably won't have the currency to get it done. Casboult has been tabled as a potential swap.

Thanks for the info Reg...I'm guessing there would be something else coming back to us? A very unproven midfielder that would be a project/depth for us vs a very versatile good senior footballer doesn't seem equivalent.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

We're interested in Bonar but probably won't have the currency to get it done. Casboult has been tabled as a potential swap.

Geez I hope we keep Casboult, but he just may be our best chance to get both Papley & Martin across the line.

Would hate to think Casboult just nets us Bonar alone.

 

[Blue Rising]

Thanks for the info Reg...I'm guessing there would be something else coming back to us? A very unproven midfielder that would be a project/depth for us vs a very versatile good senior footballer doesn't seem equivalent.

You're joking right

On CPH1831 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Coops93]

Thanks for the info Reg...I'm guessing there would be something else coming back to us? A very unproven midfielder that would be a project/depth for us vs a very versatile good senior footballer doesn't seem equivalent.

lol

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Has he done a medical?

It’s spelt medial....

 

[mochacinolatte]

Casboult told people at the b&f that he isn't going anywhere

Dayne Beam's said the same thing. 1 week can change people's mind.

 

[JoeyPBLUES]

We're interested in Bonar but probably won't have the currency to get it done. Casboult has been tabled as a potential swap.

Cheers Reg - can't we give them Setanta or T-Bird back instead??

 

[ajs071]

Casboult told people at the b&f that he isn't going anywhere

Means nothing. Betts told me at B AND F a few yrs ago he loved club and was going nowhere. 2 weeks later, gone


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Dadda Dave]

That was a week ago..

Casboult told people at the b&f that he isn't going anywhere

A week is a long time at trade time..

 

[Matty411]

Not sure Bonar is right for us but if SOS and Agresta (and Teague) believe he could be a good fit for us, then I'll back them in.

Much rather use a future or current 3rd rounder and keep Casboult.

 

[Brezsa]

Papley trade to go down within 90 min

please note: I don’t know this, but if it turns out I’m right, I’ll make some other bits up we can all talk about

 

[ferrisb]

Note to Suns.

Ed Langdon just got traded for equivalent of a pick in the mid 20s*.

Langdon runs harder and gets the ball 50% more than Martin, but doesn't use it as well.

Top 5 in Freo B&F last two years. Out of contract. A year younger than Martin.

NOT. WORTH. FIRST. ROUNDER.


* Works out at ~Pick 23, but blows out to ~30 as Melb could rise and/or with next year's picks being more compromised.

 

[Gavstar]

Any rumours about us taking Archi Manton as F/S?

 

[BringBackSimmo]

Any rumours about us taking Archi Manton as F/S?

Still a raw prospect, Manton is most likely to feature late draft or as a rookie if picked.

AFL Draft Wrap: Carlton set to prosper from another talented father-son

Former Melbourne Tigers prodigy Archi Manton recently turned to football and could be set to excite Carlton fans if he lands at the Blues through the father-son rule.

www.espn.com.au

I guess that doesn't really answer whether we are or not, though.

 

[BlueBoyBrett]

You're joking right

On CPH1831 using BigFooty.com mobile app

At the stage we are at, I value what Casboult brings to the table more than Bonar. I know big Cas has his deficiencies, hence why I said good footballer, not great...but he has shown the ability to perform well at senior level (especially this year). My biggest concern with our best 22 for next year is who will play back-up ruck to Kreuzer, a role that Casboult has shown he can do. I definitely do not want it to be McKay. In saying that, I don't see how we play McKay, C Curnow, McGovern, Jones, Weitering, Marchbank and Casboult all in the same team either...

Of our current midfield group, who would you play Bonar ahead of on exposed form (not potential)? I haven't seen anything from him yet to say he would play ahead of Cripps, Murphy, E. Curnow, Setterfield, Cuningham, SPS, Fisher etc. Happy to be proven wrong on this, but just my gut feel looking at that trade.

 

[myblueroan]

It’s spelt medial....

that would be a very chewy bread!

 

[cfc4life]

Thanks for the info Reg...I'm guessing there would be something else coming back to us? A very unproven midfielder that would be a project/depth for us vs a very versatile good senior footballer doesn't seem equivalent.

Back to steal some more content hey?

 

[JuddgementDay]

Note to Suns.

Ed Langdon just got traded for equivalent of a pick in the mid 20s*.

Langdon runs harder and gets the ball 50% more than Martin, but doesn't use it as well.

Top 5 in Freo B&F last two years. Out of contract. A year younger than Martin.

NOT. WORTH. FIRST. ROUNDER.


* Works out at ~Pick 23, but blows out to ~30 as Melb could rise and/or with next year's picks being more compromised.

This is inflated by product of the WCE generosity for the Kelly's trade

 

[KnobHead]

Note to Suns.

Ed Langdon just got traded for equivalent of a pick in the mid 20s*.

Langdon runs harder and gets the ball 50% more than Martin, but doesn't use it as well.

Top 5 in Freo B&F last two years. Out of contract. A year younger than Martin.

NOT. WORTH. FIRST. ROUNDER.


* Works out at ~Pick 23, but blows out to ~30 as Melb could rise and/or with next year's picks being more compromised.

... we should’ve gone for Langdon?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Michael Jezz]

Note to Suns.

Ed Langdon just got traded for equivalent of a pick in the mid 20s*.

Langdon runs harder and gets the ball 50% more than Martin, but doesn't use it as well.

Top 5 in Freo B&F last two years. Out of contract. A year younger than Martin.

NOT. WORTH. FIRST. ROUNDER.


* Works out at ~Pick 23, but blows out to ~30 as Melb could rise and/or with next year's picks being more compromised.

Correct Carlton are over paying this year for our management's perceptions of our needs and the target's potential

 

[slashin_velvet]