Club Mgmt. Board of Directors as led by President Dave Barham

Remove this Banner Ad

 
Last edited:
So is Weston speaking for himself or on behalf of others?
Do these kinds of things impact the players?
If it doesn't affect the players I'm on Weston's side a bit. I don't want blue-collar I want redneck
 
Spot on, Runk.
Why has he waited until now (where we actually seem to have some sort of vestige of a plan) vs a few years ago when we were absolutely fking rudderless and everyone - bar those at the the club - could see it.

And I also loved Weston the player.
This looks to me like a last gasp attempt by the old boys to hold on to the club. The club has been wrenched from their grasp and they know it. The only concern is that a large proportion of supporter/members might not understand what a massive achievement that is.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

So is Weston speaking for himself or on behalf of others?
Do these kinds of things impact the players?
If it doesn't affect the players I'm on Weston's side a bit. I don't want blue-collar I want redneck

What qualification - in your opinion - does Weston have for sitting on a board of directors for an organisation generating ~ $78.9m in revenue per annum?
 
I don't really see how former premiership player counts as a qualification for being a director on the board.

Think about all the players who have played in premierships in the entire league over the last 20 years and think how many of those you'd actually want making decisions based on something other than split-second highly trained instincts on who to handball to. Yikes.

Maybe 2% of them are actually suitable for it.


Bomber Thompson should put his hand up. Even with his drug problem and run ins with the police he's still a better candidate than Weston/Sheedy/etc.
 
I don't really see how former premiership player counts as a qualification for being a director on the board.

Think about all the players who have played in premierships in the entire league over the last 20 years and think how many of those you'd actually want making decisions based on something other than split-second highly trained instincts on who to handball to. Yikes.

Maybe 2% of them are actually suitable for it.


Bomber Thompson should put his hand up. Even with his drug problem and run ins with the police he's still a better candidate than Weston/Sheedy/etc.
is it similar to the AFL / premiership player = great coach?

Ken for all his short comings is doing a pretty damn reasonable job. Alistair Clarkson play in flags?
 
I voted Weston and Solomon.


Walk Away Harley Quinn GIF by Max
 
is it similar to the AFL / premiership player = great coach?

Ken for all his short comings is doing a pretty damn reasonable job. Alistair Clarkson play in flags?
Alistair Clarkson was in the right place at the right time to coach some flags at state level before he got tanking-for-picks Hawthorn right before the expansion years. I don't think he had even a remotely notable playing career though.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

As a former reigning poster of the year I find this mildly humorous if not srs.
As the boards current reigning poster of the year I 100% did it because I want Hird to come back and either succeed or fail so the noise ends.
 
Bomber Thompson should put his hand up. Even with his drug problem and run ins with the police he's still a better candidate than Weston/Sheedy/etc.
Imagine the end of year Xmas parties if he was in charge!! :cool: :p

But on a serious note I do agree with you in that Bomber understands what footballing success in the modern era looks like.
Weston is a glorified Salesman and is there to only further entrench the problems that have plagued this club for 2 decades.
 
Alistair Clarkson was in the right place at the right time to coach some flags at state level before he got tanking-for-picks Hawthorn right before the expansion years. I don't think he had even a remotely notable playing career though.
Played 1 final for 1 loss.
 
what a bumbling train wreck. that was a hard listen
Listening to it makes me want to be productive at work so I guess that's a plus. Not because he's motivational but because I get about a minute into the actual interview (after the 45 seconds of ads) and the best excuse I can come up with to turn it off is to do work. :\
 
Alistair Clarkson was in the right place at the right time to coach some flags at state level before he got tanking-for-picks Hawthorn right before the expansion years. I don't think he had even a remotely notable playing career though.

His playing career is mostly known for coward punching a dude I reckon.
 
As the boards current reigning poster of the year I 100% did it because I want Hird to come back and either succeed or fail so the noise ends.
finally, a reigning poster of the year I can get behind!
 
As the boards current reigning poster of the year I 100% did it because I want Hird to come back and either succeed or fail so the noise ends.
Agree with the sentiment but I doubt the noise will ever end. If he tries and fails again more excuses will be made and there'll be another attempt later.

The best way to end the noise is probably for coterie types to lose respect for Sheedy, which unfortunately would probably require significant health issues for the old fella.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Club Mgmt. Board of Directors as led by President Dave Barham

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top