You had more frees, more frees in your forward 50 and more goals from frees. We can get into the what frees weren't paid but we'd be here all day.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Carlton - The End is Near.
- Thread starter indieswan96
- Start date
- Tagged users None
You had more frees, more frees in your forward 50 and more goals from frees. We can get into the what frees weren't paid but we'd be here all day.
But this is a Carltank whinge session, let them roam free thats all they're able to do now until March 
Ummm, we beat you, actually. And you should now stop sooking and try and take it like a grown-up. All this ump whinging is really quite pathetic. You had you chances and choked, even your coach and captain said so. You choked and we didn't. Hence we are the victors, that's how it works.
Pie eyed
Premium Platinum
- Jun 26, 2007
- 43,014
- 24,133
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Magpies
LMAO at YOU.
Shouldn't you be on your own board checking out what's been cooking or getting the kids back from DOCS now that footies over for you?
- Banned
- #330
Football is a game of four quarters. Judd only put in one.
27 years old this year, 28 next year. I wish we only aged on our birthdays too, but it's not so. Not in this realm.
Judd deal looks even worse when it was Armfield who gave the ball up for the matchwinner in the final term.
Carlton can't take a trick at the moment.
He's whinging to the wrong team to whinge too.
Once again we win with more FA the FF and the other team still whingers about it.
Once again we win with more FA the FF and the other team still whingers about it.
Umm ... no. He put in one of the best quarters of finals football you'll see this year and 3 quarters of ordinary mortal football. All of which were better than Hodge.
Hahahahaha ... Armfield was three times the player Hodge was on the w'end. Made a bad move in bouncing the ball, but shit, take a look at the rest of game lmao ... it's like you're a softball fan.
Yeah ... I'm not playing add up frees here. I wouldn't care if Sydney had twice as many frees as the Blues; as long as they were kosher. That first quarter was the worst display of finals umpiring I've ever seen.
Of course not. It doesn't help your argument when you were clear beneficiaries of the free count. White spent most of the day getting shoved in the back when he took front position. Hannebery was done for HTB when he'd handpassed out to McVeigh at the top of the Swans forward 50. It's swings and roundabouts.
Carltank feel robbed, this whinge will continue until March. Until then we can tease them about things like being crap. Having Judd troll there monies and going backwards from 2009
- Banned
- #336
Yes, if ordinary mortal football meant choking in front of goal and chipscabbing in defence, then yes he played ordinary mortal football.
Unfortunately he just went missing in another crucial last quarter. Shades of the 2009 EF when he was MIA as Brisbane overtook your mob.
Armfield actually played worse than a bloke hobbling around Subiaco. I didn't think it was possible, but there it was.
Gave up the ball for the matchwinner. I guess that's success at Carlton, right?
Thread should be renamed...
Carlton - And the story of choking in finals.
or
Carlton - What do Brisbane and Swans have in common?
Carlton - And the story of choking in finals.
or
Carlton - What do Brisbane and Swans have in common?
As we're discussing umpiring, Monkey King, I direct your attention to the following screenshot.
To the right you can see a Carlton player passing the yellow area before the other spud is off the field. By my reckoning that's a free from the centre and a 50. It was even called by the emergency but Sydney didn't get the free. Are you as outraged as I over this blatant attempt to let Carlton into the game?
To the right you can see a Carlton player passing the yellow area before the other spud is off the field. By my reckoning that's a free from the centre and a 50. It was even called by the emergency but Sydney didn't get the free. Are you as outraged as I over this blatant attempt to let Carlton into the game?
Yep. We had our chances all right, should really have won it. If the umps did the first half like they did the second, we would have too.
Of course the coach and captain wouldn't say anything about the umps ... just look at what happened to James Hird. Even the commentators are scared to say anything these days ... look at Grant Thomas.
You'll have to forgive me for loving the game of football. If what happened on Sunday took place on Grand Final day, our game might as well just be dead.
We had players from both teams running head first into opponents on Sunday trying to get a free; pathetic in itself, but even more so when the umps react.
LMAO at YOU.
Shouldn't you be on your own board checking out what's been cooking or getting the kids back from DOCS now that footies over for you?
LYAO if the same happened to you guys in a Grannie would you? You're a bottom feeder Pie-eyed, who struggles at the best of times with football sense.
Playing add up free-kick totals is just about the dumbest way to evaluate the impact of umpiring. As if free kick totals are ever meant to be even or a lop-sided count indicate disparity in any way. Bizarre.
Best is to view them on their merits. Even opposition fans were hanging their heads yesterday at the pathetic interference by the umps. Being grown up and all I might have expected you just accept that this was part of the game and it was part of the reason you won. No point burying your head in the sand about it.
Yes, if ordinary mortal football meant choking in front of goal and chipscabbing in defence, then yes he played ordinary mortal football.
Fail narrative is fail
Judd >>> Hodge
Pie eyed
Premium Platinum
- Jun 26, 2007
- 43,014
- 24,133
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Magpies
Coming from a poster like you MK that's a compliment.
I would hate to feature in your top 10.
Fail narrative is fail.
Judd hasnt owned Hodge since he left WCE.
No player can be better then another player whilst wearing that Navy blue jumper.
Besides Greg Williams your last Brownlow winner was 1964.
And we all know Greg was a great player for many clubs and won the medal as it was one of his first years not getting suspended... It shows that Carlscum dont have the best players going around
As I said earlier, I have no doubt if it had been in your favour you would have been all over it.
Ah yes, speaking of viewing on merit, I note you haven't addressed the blatant free which was actively noted and ignored by the umpires that I just posted up.
Sure you would ... it might mean you actually know something. Far better for you remain with the shit stirring bottom feeders; trust me, you're right at home.
Well I wouldn't. You will find posts of mine on BF stating that adding up free-kick totals to evaluate umpires performance is daft. Scores aren't required to be even, why the hell would free-kicks be?
Why jump on an anomaly when the pattern is so obvious. I couldn't believe the amount of Carlton haters that were outraged by the umps. Speaks volumes!
- Banned
- #348
Outraged by the umps doesn't mean they thought the umps were favouring Carlton.
I'm a Carlton hater and I thought the umpiring was balanced.
Get over it.
I never said they should but when youre claiming to have been done over in the umpiring stakes it's a bit strange that you'd be on the positive side of the ledger by some of the biggest discrepancies this year. Stranger still when the umpires aknowledged and ignored a free kick that almost certainly would have resulted in a goal.
Why don't you then? Certainly I'm not going to start suddenly pretending the umps didn't impact the game with a volley of incorrect 1Q decisions.
The only balance in the umpiring was that the first half was beyond pathetic and entirely unacceptable and the second half was pretty much a master class in how games should be officiated.
Sorry mate ... just too many opposition fans outraged for it not to have happened yeah.
