Central Murray FL Discussion 2024

[ROOTA#6]

Maybe you and John brookshaw could do a few games together, I'd pay to see that

Bloody hell!!

 

[stopblowingyourwhistle]

Max Carroll
Damien Hirst
James Downing
John Threadgold
Daylight

These 4 have been great when I've watched.

Brayden Wren, Narelle and young Liam Edwards are also great.

 

[HDFLFan]

Massive news for the league with cohuna, can't see the Heathcote league knocking them back again

Yes they will, again. ALL are against.

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

Yes they will, again. ALL are against.

I'd find that hard to fathom, they let in leitchy 10 minutes down the road, I'm not sure if a club needs to move and 85% of their members agree, why other clubs should have a say, you're driving 10 minutes further for 1 game a year

 

[Old bomber]

I'd find that hard to fathom, they let in leitchy 10 minutes down the road, I'm not sure if a club needs to move and 85% of their members agree, why other clubs should have a say, you're driving 10 minutes further for 1 game a year

Would be interesting if Leitchy are for or against it.

 

[HairyMaclary]

If I was to pick 4 to do a grand final tomorrow it would be.

Brent Howden
Danny Fraser
Brayden Wren
Damien Hirst (only seen him once or twice, but I thought he was very very good)



On SM-S918B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Id go with
Brent Howden
Johnny Threadgold
James Downing
Brayden Wren

I feel personally Frazer tries to take control of the game and have it on his terms to often then not instead of letting the game go. Stamps his authority to much on the game that’s just my opinion.

 

[kidgorgeous]

It's not ideal having 3 Kerang people officiating a game... you can read into that as much as you want. They shouldn't be umpiring their sons. They should have been allocated another game. It creates controversy and a bit of Nepotism.

FMD who are the sons of the umpires officiating Kerang games?
Hall has 5 daughters.
Howden has twin boys underage.
Nitschke yes but only one son.
I agree that umpires are not immune to criticism but to accuse them of outright cheating, a step too far.
I recall Kerang being dudded in 2006 with very questionable decisions, no one said the umpires cheated for the result.

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

FMD who are the sons of the umpires officiating Kerang games?
Hall has 5 daughters.
Howden has twin boys underage.
Nitschke yes but only one son.
I agree that umpires are not immune to criticism but to accuse them of outright cheating, a step too far.
I recall Kerang being dudded in 2006 with very questionable decisions, no one said the umpires cheated for the result.

You should umpire kid, once your playing days are over of course

 

[Old bomber]

FMD who are the sons of the umpires officiating Kerang games?
Hall has 5 daughters.
Howden has twin boys underage.
Nitschke yes but only one son.
I agree that umpires are not immune to criticism but to accuse them of outright cheating, a step too far.
I recall Kerang being dudded in 2006 with very questionable decisions, no one said the umpires cheated for the result.

2 Nitschke’s played on Saturday

 

[Crippa09]

FMD who are the sons of the umpires officiating Kerang games?
Hall has 5 daughters.
Howden has twin boys underage.
Nitschke yes but only one son.
I agree that umpires are not immune to criticism but to accuse them of outright cheating, a step too far.
I recall Kerang being dudded in 2006 with very questionable decisions, no one said the umpires cheated for the result.

#1 - Nitschke had 2 sons play
#2 - No one has mentioned outright cheating
#3 - 2006 is 18 years ago, who cares
#4 - Jog on

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

#1 - Nitschke had 2 sons play
#2 - No one has mentioned outright cheating
#3 - 2006 is 18 years ago, who cares
#4 - Jog on

Sounds like a woora whinge to me, did you mind getting the rub of the green in the lalbert grand finals?
26 scoring shots to 16 on the weekend
Yep nitscjkes dad shouldn't umpire kerang, kerang don't choose the umpires either. Sounds like he's umpired kerangs game before this weekend, as I say I can't have that happening in senior footy, but the other 2 are fine

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

#1 - Nitschke had 2 sons play
#2 - No one has mentioned outright cheating
#3 - 2006 is 18 years ago, who cares
#4 - Jog on

Were you born in 2006?

 

[Crippa09]

Sounds like a woora whinge to me, did you mind getting the rub of the green in the lalbert grand finals?
26 scoring shots to 16 on the weekend
Yep nitscjkes dad shouldn't umpire kerang, kerang don't choose the umpires either. Sounds like he's umpired kerangs game before this weekend, as I say I can't have that happening in senior footy, but the other 2 are fine

Not a whinge at all, nothing to do with me. Just not liking all the negativity around it that’s all..

 

[ROOTA#6]

You should umpire kid, once your playing days are over of course

He will play forever

 

[Crippa09]

Were you born in 2006?

Haha, you are a complete and utter flog Trent. This comment just confirms it. I wish I seen u play footy, I bet u were the skinny kid in the back pocket with with his socks pulled up that got ragdolled ever week

 

[ROOTA#6]

#1 - Nitschke had 2 sons play
#2 - No one has mentioned outright cheating
#3 - 2006 is 18 years ago, who cares
#4 - Jog on

Not sure you need to post with disrespect mate…kid has and continues to be an great contributor to the league

 

[Glock]

Not sure you need to post with disrespect mate…kid has and continues to be an great contributor to the league

Im not affiliated with any team and haven't played in this league for 40 years, but you cant have relatives umpiring games as it creates the feeling of cheating, whether they do or not. There needs to be independent umpires covering games, especially come finals time. This needs to be addressed ASAP as it is a farce with what is being allowed to occur. I don't give a flying F$%# whether you agree with me or not, That is my 2 cents worth.

 

[ROOTA#6]

Im not affiliated with any team and haven't played in this league for 40 years, but you cant have relatives umpiring games as it creates the feeling of cheating, whether they do or not. There needs to be independent umpires covering games, especially come finals time. This needs to be addressed ASAP as it is a farce with what is being allowed to occur. I don't give a flying F$%# whether you agree with me or not, That is my 2 cents worth.

Whoa man no need for the anger towards me… I have said that having people umpire their sons is problematic

 

[thegranger]

Sounds like a woora whinge to me, did you mind getting the rub of the green in the lalbert grand finals?
26 scoring shots to 16 on the weekend
Yep nitscjkes dad shouldn't umpire kerang, kerang don't choose the umpires either. Sounds like he's umpired kerangs game before this weekend, as I say I can't have that happening in senior footy, but the other 2 are fine

I think they need to get them from Bendigo what are your thoughts? Is the cmfl overtaking Bendigo in terms of strength TTFS?

 

[ROOTA#6]

I think they need to get them from Bendigo what are your thoughts? Is the cmfl overtaking Bendigo in terms of strength TTFS?

Get who from Bendigo?? Umpires?

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

I think they need to get them from Bendigo what are your thoughts? Is the cmfl overtaking Bendigo in terms of strength TTFS?

Well I think they should for finals yes and if you took out sandhurst and gisborne it would be close between the cmfl and bfl at present

 

[thegranger]

Get who from Bendigo?? Umpires?

Yeah mate, saves all this commotion…

 

[Trent the flight Steward]

The Wimmera league get umpires from Ballarat

 

[finalsiren25]

Who are the best umpires in the league these days?

Id go with
Brent Howden
Johnny Threadgold
James Downing
Brayden Wren

I feel personally Frazer tries to take control of the game and have it on his terms to often then not instead of letting the game go. Stamps his authority to much on the game that’s just my opinion.

Fraser is a joke aswell

 

[Donhimup]

I think they need to get them from Bendigo what are your thoughts? Is the cmfl overtaking Bendigo in terms of strength TTFS?

Not very feasible