-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
chris judd ?
- Thread starter mightymax
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Feb 19, 2001
- 1,822
- 50
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Melbourne Wanderers CC...
- Thread starter
- #4
theres a lot of speculation that its going to be pretty hard to keep byron pickett at the club when his contract expires, because he wants to return home.
so why not make a play for chris judd now and west coast's first round pick
we can then on-trade that first round pick and our own, for another top 5 pick
final outcome:
north get chris judd (for b.pickett)
richmond's 4 pick (for w.carey)
another top 5 pick (for b.pickett)
adelaides first pick (w.carey)
chris judd and two picks in the top five, plus adelaides first pick is a great way to start rebuilding the club. I would rather keep pickett, but lets face it. will we be able to match a big offer from freo or west coast if pickett wants to go back to his family in a couple of year's time ?
so why not make a play for chris judd now and west coast's first round pick
we can then on-trade that first round pick and our own, for another top 5 pick
final outcome:
north get chris judd (for b.pickett)
richmond's 4 pick (for w.carey)
another top 5 pick (for b.pickett)
adelaides first pick (w.carey)
chris judd and two picks in the top five, plus adelaides first pick is a great way to start rebuilding the club. I would rather keep pickett, but lets face it. will we be able to match a big offer from freo or west coast if pickett wants to go back to his family in a couple of year's time ?
- Feb 19, 2001
- 1,822
- 50
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Melbourne Wanderers CC...
Not a chance that WCE would swap Judd & first Round pick for Byron...
- Thread starter
- #6
pickett is a matchwinner.
young and can play a number of positions
he can be a match winner.
chris judd wants out and wants to come back to vic
and i dont think they can expect much more than a premiership player and a norwich rising star. and only 25 !
so i think they would be very interested.
i think we would be silly to accept anything less than their first choice, which is about pick 12 anyway
young and can play a number of positions
he can be a match winner.
chris judd wants out and wants to come back to vic
and i dont think they can expect much more than a premiership player and a norwich rising star. and only 25 !
so i think they would be very interested.
i think we would be silly to accept anything less than their first choice, which is about pick 12 anyway
First of all, Judd cannot be traded in his first year since he was drafted from interstate. Has to stay on the list a minimum of 2yrs.
Secondly, by all reports Judd is very happy in WA and has never said anything about wanting to return home. He is sharing a house with Humm (a victorian) and they are apparently best mates.
Thirdly, 1st rd pick + Judd for Pickett? Hahaha. Most people wouldn't swap Judd for Pickett straight, let alone with pick #10.
Secondly, by all reports Judd is very happy in WA and has never said anything about wanting to return home. He is sharing a house with Humm (a victorian) and they are apparently best mates.
Thirdly, 1st rd pick + Judd for Pickett? Hahaha. Most people wouldn't swap Judd for Pickett straight, let alone with pick #10.
hamstringinjury
Debutant
We will need to give up something in the B. Harvey league to get Judd IMO. He is going to be a super star
- Feb 19, 2001
- 1,822
- 50
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Melbourne Wanderers CC...
Where did you hear this - I don't think that it is right!!!
Groucho
Premium Platinum
A Star Wars Fan
North Melbourne - 2024 Hugh Greenwood Player Sponsor
Veteran
North Melbourne - 2023 Aaron Hall and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
10k Posts
North Melbourne - 2022 Aaron Hall and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2021 Taylor Garner and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2020 Taylor Garner and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
I've been trying to have this proven one way or the other but it seems to be some sort of footy urban myth. Some have said that it's in the bargaining agreement but I can't find it. It should be noted that Brisbane have delisted a kid called Clarke after one year.
- Jul 12, 2002
- 1,999
- 1,640
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
I think all draftees sign a standard 2 year (avoids the FIGJAM scenario) agreement with some variation being allowed in the money (between a minimum and maximum).
I presume that an AFL club can delist a draftee, but would have to pay out the contract.
I presume that an AFL club can delist a draftee, but would have to pay out the contract.
if judd did decide he wanted to go home to victoria at the end of the 2003 season there would be 10 clubs tripping over each other to get him.
the kid clarke from brisbane has actually been on their list for 3 years......he was delisted after the first 2 year contract but then picked up again in the draft this year on a 1 year contract i guess which is why he was able to be delisted...
- Banned
- #15
I would actually take Judd over Pickett IF Judd wants to return and maybe if Pickett also feels homsick or just cannot play. We are dreaming to think we can get him for 2003. For 2004 maybe, but it would take the mother of all efforts to get him to come to Arden Street instead of 9 other vic clubs...
Similar threads
