Game Day Collingwood v GWS Giants - Preliminary Finals — Sat 21 Sep, 4:35PM AEST, MCG

[Red Black and Blue]

So GWS without five of their top ten players are at least the second best team in the competition. I’ve got an idea, let’s give them priority access to a top 3 talent in the draft.

 

[The Meerkat]

Mayne is 30, and has played the best footy of his career over the past two years, and in particular over the past 6-8 weeks.

He's very emotional for better or worse, win or lose. A heart-and-soul type, quality clubman, just means so much to him, particularly after a number of near misses over his career.

Mayne has been very good in the last two years, plays with more heart than some of the more higher profile pies players.

 

[Bazzar]

Brave Collingwood - ripped off -

Bwaaaahahaha.

 

[Dez!]

I mean I was pretty clearly saying Collingwood got a dodgy goal that was touched... I want Richmond to win the flag. Gws winning was good for them

So you’re saying that when Grundy was backing into the contest he was actually not backing into it?

It’s okay mate. You’re new to modern footy. You’re one of those old bloke Melbourne fans who still thinks that grinter is running around. You’ll be dead before the next flag buddy, I understand why you’ve jumped on the giants.

So you keep harping on about apparently "I'm still whinging about a goal from 90 minutes ago" and yet you continuously keep whinging, interesting.

Then you tell me I'm jumping on the Giants despite not giving two shits about who won today, yet you've jumped on the Tigers.

You poor child, you're clearly not okay.

 

[Demontim275]

They know the Melbourne teams back to front, others not so much. Never knew how good Taylor was but Haynes has been a freak for years now. Most underrated player in the comp.

Haynes is an absolute gun. I’ve rated him over Davis this year.

Yet the commentators think a fill in ex Collingwood player is the one to lead the defence.

 

[beema limapep]

Nathan norm Smith, brownlow medallist.
You, blogger, flogger and north supporter

#noflags

 

[Sterge]

Adam Treloar:

I want to leave gws and I choose Collingwood over Richmond so I can win a flag

Nek minut could be a two time premiership player at Richmond or at worst a premiership player for gws while pies have nothing. Good choice brah

We would not have won a flag if treloar picked us

 

[Cool Kangas]

Nathan norm Smith, brownlow medallist.
You, blogger, flogger and north supporter

Nath left brissy for flags....dear oh dear
Anyway, peace out

 

[WCfan22]

It is interesting how many big name players move clubs to play in premierships and it never get one.

Yeah imagine leaving the bears and then have to sit through a triple premiership crowning

 

[Chinacats]

They do not want to stuff up the score review next week. If the side on the wrong end gets beaten by under 6 points then you can guarantee it will go to court.

Yes the ARC stuffed up!

 

[Demontim275]

So you keep harping on about apparently "I'm still whinging about a goal from 90 minutes ago" and yet you continuously keep whinging, interesting.

Then you tell me I'm jumping on the Giants despite not giving two s**ts about who won today, yet you've jumped on the Tigers.

You poor child, you're clearly not okay.

This seems like a non sequitur. Do you happen to hold a members seat on level two? There was an old bloke accusing every player of being on steroids all year.

Was it you? He had a tenuous grasp on reality too.

We get it mate, you either don’t understand footy, or live in some no physics reality.

 

[Les Malone]

Floreat Pica ran second today at Morphettville in race 1, it was either this week or next week - Collingwood was not going to win.

But the Giants without half of their midfield had a gutsy win, club defining really.

Questions must be asked of Buckley, big questions.

 

[The Dog]

teams winning their first grand final?

adelaide, port, brisbane? essendon?

probably a few

May as well add the Dogs as their other was 60 years ago


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[demondavey]

Zac Williams was big

 

[NSWCROW]

Maggots did their best to get the pies over the line

 

[Cool Kangas]

We would not have won a flag if treloar chose us

Really?

 

[demondavey]

Floreat Pica ran second today at Morphettville in race 1, it was either this week or next week - Collingwood was not going to win.

But the Giants without half of their midfield had a gutsy win, club defining really.

Questions must be asked of Buckley, big questions.

Questions of Buckley? Why?

 

[The Filth]

Oh boy Wowee

Unbackable favourites, week off, playing interstate team, Giants 4 best players out, no way a few free kicks should influence that result.you are looking in the wrong direction.

How did the Pies mess this up??? Looking forward to fleshing this out over the next year.

True, don't get me wrong GWS played well. Pies had all the advantages leading into the game.
Personally I have been playing down the runaway win that others expected the Pies to have - I still gave GWS a chance - you can read my posts yesterday to Richmond supporters prematurely talking about a Tigers v Pies GF.
Conditions suited GWS and they played well, tougher in the contest.
Shame that their 5 goal run in the 3rd that won them the game was helped by the 3 goals they scored from poor umpiring.
That's the problem - 3 goals from non calls is huge in a low scoring game when GWS had momentum.
Match should have been closer at 3/4 time.

 

[Dez!]

This seems like a non sequitur. Do you happen to hold a members seat on level two? There was an old bloke accusing every player of being on steroids all year.

Was it you? He had a tenuous grasp on reality too.

We get it mate, you either don’t understand footy, or live in some no physics reality.

It's okay buddy, one day you'll come back to reality.

 

[MadMundy]

For all the shit GWS get, they ****ing earnt this flag if they win it this year. So much adversity and they come back and shove it up all the ****s who doubted them.

 

[Chinacats]

No thanks, no bandwagon for me.

Fair enough it was a great comeback by the woods today, just missed.

 

[Neale4brownlow]

Coniglio seems pretty buouyant. I reckon he plays. Or atleast he thinks he's a chance anyway.

Massive difference to shots of gaff last year when he knew he'd miss out.

 

[biggiemediums]

Are you mentally challenged? How can you say if the Pies had won by a goal or less that the incorrect touched decision has no bearing on it's own. FMD.

I didn't say it has no bearing, you seem to be the one who lacks any comprehension. Nuffies like you acting like the ENTIRE game hangs on ONE incorrect decision because it was more obvious is genuinely ******ed...

There are many incorrect decisions that throughout the game literally have huge impacts and ramifications within seconds, minutes that wouldn't have happened if not for the incorrect decision affecting it. They are every bit as much impactful as the big obvious ones that the lesser thinking seem to stay glued to.

 

[Demontim275]

So you keep harping on about apparently "I'm still whinging about a goal from 90 minutes ago" and yet you continuously keep whinging, interesting.

Then you tell me I'm jumping on the Giants despite not giving two s**ts about who won today, yet you've jumped on the Tigers.

You poor child, you're clearly not okay.

You’ll notice I’m actually discussing the game, and how good gws were too

Your only posts are whinging about a free kick discussion from 2 hours ago. Did you watch the rest of the game? Or spend tome freeze framing Grundy to try and find something to whinge about?

The games over bandwagoner.

 

[Black white]

Nath left brissy for flags....dear oh dear
Anyway, peace out

You left your brain back in the primary school.
Peace out