Mod. Notice Competitions: READ BEFORE POSTING A COMPETITION
- Thread starter TheDoctor11
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Just leave it at the logo. The guernsey one (to me) didnt work very well. People were just using texture and effects without trying to focus much on the company or they fo
i guess the Guernsey one would work better if you were doing a logo alongside it too, that way it was completely yours rather than just chucking a logo on a jumper.
maybe if it was made so that instead of changing the company logo, or as well as, the logo was made into a football logo?
that way it's like the company is actually a football club?
maybe if it was made so that instead of changing the company logo, or as well as, the logo was made into a football logo?
that way it's like the company is actually a football club?
But that is COTF. Non-sports logo was created as a way of developing skills in making logos that aren't necessarily on shields or roundels. They were a good way to see how a person understood what a company logo should look like.
HaroLad
HaroChad
COTF has logos too thanks mate.
You're not understanding what I'm saying. COTF focused on the guernseys or a "team" overall. LogoOTW (in both iterations) focuses on the logo on its own.
Not to mention I just went through every COTF thread that's been done and there is a total of three logos made up. All of which came from lmach. You can't say there are logos in the comp if there arent
Last edited:
HaroLad
HaroChad
Craegus
One and Only
Yes there are logos in COTW, but that is not the sole point of the competition, the guernsey designs took precident. LogoOTW was purely logos.
I just had a look, there's none.
Correction, there is one. You added half a football to a QANTAS logo. That hardly counts
HaroLad
HaroChad
Bacon Warrior
D10
You STILL haven't put up the poll for the last one yet. Y'know, the LEGO one?
I'm making this request public. Please stop saying "m9". It's irritating and makes no sense at all
HaroLad
HaroChad
You can do it if you want.
Bacon Warrior
D10
lol I'm not running another one of your comps. You put it up.
Klim
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 17, 2013
- 12,532
- 10,364
- AFL Club
- Sydney
I have an idea similar to this one. Instead of jumpers why don't we have a logo comp as well. Just logos. That way we have a logo comp working around.Proposal:
FJ&GD World Heavyweight Championship
My idea is for a competition in the spirit of competitions like the NAFL and IFA but a little more fast paced. People have been complaining about a lack of weekly designing, well for this competition you could design every week or once in a blue moon and not lose your place.
Every member on this board is permitted to have one live entry design, consisting of a playing strip and logo for a fictional football club from a location anywhere they like in the world. I don't care whether you enter the New York Isotopes or the Salisbury East Fieldmice. All I want is a real world location and a football club.
Each week there will be several divisions of roughly 5. Each division will have a match involving all 5 participants in an open vote for the best design.
After each match, the top two (or so) teams in the division will be promoted and the bottom two teams will be relegated. I'd imagine each voting period would be about 5 days with the idea to have one round each week.
The winner of the top division will be the World Heavyweight Champion and that champion will defend his title each week for as long as he or she has it.
Entry rules:
- One entry per person. One playing strip with a logo if you choose. Also I want your username attached somewhere in-image for quick reference of who is who.
- You will maintain your position in the rankings provided you stick with the same club name and colours. I will allow design tweaks or changes between rounds provided it's the same club. If you want to make wholesale changes, you have to pull out and re-enter a new club in the bottom division. This hopefully will stop one or two people from dominating for too long.
- If you enter a design and don't change it, and it maintains it's place in a division, it can theoretically stay there forever until you pull it out or enter something new. So if you want to enter a guernsey you can, but if you don't enter for a while you maintain your place in the competition. I'm not sure how this will work longterm and I expect that if this runs for a while and we end up with heaps of divisions, I will remove entries where the owner has lost interest or where the entry has remained in a low division for an extended period of time.
- The idea behind this is that it's quickfire comp that anybody can enter without having to invest too much time or effort. There is no bidding process. If you submit an entry, you are in (unless it gets absolutely ridiculous and we have like 60 teams).
Theoretically we could have 6 divisions, so 30 odd entries, and someone could enter at the bottom and their design if good enough would take 6 weeks to get up to the top division and challenge for the belt.
The thread structure would be a hub thread where discussion and announcements happened and a weekly voting thread. I'm not sure if there is an image limit in posts or a limit as to how many voting options there are. If so I could break the divisions over a couple of threads if required.
I'm hoping that the belt will regularly change hands as people get sick of the incumbent titleholder and vote new designs in.
Also, once this competition got the go ahead, i'd start the hub thread immediately and as soon as I had 5 designs, the first week would be up. The NAFL benefited greatly from 3 months of time to enter and the quality was outstanding. This competition is all about a fast pace and constantly rotating entries.
What do people think?
could work well.
what if you ran that comp from tuesday or wednesday - saturday and i'll run the other from saturday- wednesday.
that way there's always at least one going
what if you ran that comp from tuesday or wednesday - saturday and i'll run the other from saturday- wednesday.
that way there's always at least one going
Klim
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 17, 2013
- 12,532
- 10,364
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Agreed. Thoughts guys?
Fizzler
TAKE BACK PAFC
- Dec 26, 2013
- 13,508
- 18,152
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- OKC, Coburg, Werribee, Storm, QPR
Yeah I like that. Lets do that.
Dylan8
Bar Up
Could you clarify? Like, logos for a football team or just general logos? The latter wouldn't really make sense, and the former is already a part of the belt competition.
The belt is good because you're basically voting on a free for all match between teams. I don't know how it works with logos.
If you want to work on a logo gradually just make a basic sort of kit with the main focus being your logo in the belt competition. That's what I was doing until I just gradually lost interest in it.
The belt is good because you're basically voting on a free for all match between teams. I don't know how it works with logos.
If you want to work on a logo gradually just make a basic sort of kit with the main focus being your logo in the belt competition. That's what I was doing until I just gradually lost interest in it.
Klim
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 17, 2013
- 12,532
- 10,364
- AFL Club
- Sydney
You can create a logo for a sports team or make up one. It's a test on how good your logos are and you can always fix up your entry.
Dylan8
Bar Up
Yeah but do you see how that's the equivalent of having the heavyweight belt being a comp with kits from any sport. It's too broad.
- Aug 21, 2007
- 33,357
- 110,712
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Aston Villa, San Antonio Spurs
I'm not sure if it would work well with logos because of the enormous scope.
I'd be super keen for logootw to return if someone wants to run it.
I'd be super keen for logootw to return if someone wants to run it.
Klim
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 17, 2013
- 12,532
- 10,364
- AFL Club
- Sydney
I'll give it a shot.
Dylan8
Bar Up
Yeah like I said a while back, I'll happily run it when the league comps have started as to not bottleneck the board, esp. since a solid part of this board is just back at school now so a bit busier.
Similar threads
