You might get a job at Carlton as recruiting officer I doubt you would any where else though, Jack is 25, Jay is 29, Jack has over 100 goals more in 3 years less football, averaging nearly a goal a game better than Jay and should have a few more years left in him after Jay will have retired.
Jay is a good solid player with a great set shot at goal that finally managed a full season last year for the first time in his career and is now getting the best service of his life, but Jack is still without doubt the better full forward.
It would be great if we could have kept Jay but it's easy to see why we let him go, not many clubs can keep two gun full forwards on their list these days, overall it was a win win situation for Jay, Port and Richmond.
You must be forgetting that in his time at the tigers he was being used as a defender right?