Cricket Thread: Indian Summer

Remove this Banner Ad

I would have looked at Labuschange to open against India rather than push McSweeney there .
Absolutely, Labuschagne played like an opener anyway, not looking to score but blunt the new ball instead. McSweeney should have never been used as the sacrificial lamb and I personally thought it was horrible leadership from everyone.
 
The issue is Lyon & Murphy are both similar.

We need a different type of spinner imo.

Possibly so, and its a good point but I still dont see the point in bringing in a sub par specialist spinner just because.

The gap between the output of Connolly, Head or McSweeney over any replacement spinner would be far outweighed by their superior batting they bring to the table.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Is Ashton Agar's batting against spin sound?

I'm not sure I'd want him selected as a bowler alone. I could see him being useful to extend the batting line up and as a third option while Murphy/Lyon do the bulk of the work.
 
Smith out would be a big loss.


Head to captain his 1st test.

What would our batting line-up look like?

Reckon I would go...

1 Head
2 Konstas
3 Khawaja
4 Labuschagne
5 McSweeney
6 Webster
7 Carey
8 Starc
9 Lyon
10 Kuhnemann
11 Boland

Hopefully Kuhnemann is ok to play... if not then reckon we need Connolly.
 
Smith out would be a big loss.


Head to captain his 1st test.

What would our batting line-up look like?

Reckon I would go...

1 Head
2 Konstas
3 Khawaja
4 Labuschagne
5 McSweeney
6 Webster
7 Carey
8 Starc
9 Lyon
10 Kuhnemann
11 Boland

Hopefully Kuhnemann is ok to play... if not then reckon we need Connolly.

Considering everything, I think they might keep it simple ...

1 Khawaja
2 Konstas
3 Labuschagne
4 McSweeney
5 Head
6 Webster
7 Connolly
8 Carey
9 Starc
10 Lyon
11 Boland

Is that good enough spin, though?
 
Smith out would be a big loss.


Head to captain his 1st test.

What would our batting line-up look like?

Reckon I would go...

1 Head
2 Konstas
3 Khawaja
4 Labuschagne
5 McSweeney
6 Webster
7 Carey
8 Starc
9 Lyon
10 Kuhnemann
11 Boland

Hopefully Kuhnemann is ok to play... if not then reckon we need Connolly.
Openers too vanilla
 
depending on the pitch, I reckon you guys are a seamer to much in the line ups.

I'd probably go with Webster and Starc as the seamers
Agree the seamers. Webster becomes the second and I'm thinking Boland instead of Starc. Perhaps as potent but much better able to lock up an end if required.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Remove this Banner Ad

Cricket Thread: Indian Summer

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top