Cripps or Oliver.

[danster168]

Dan.. who’s year was better
In 2023 Cripps polled 22 Brownlow votes, was top 20 in the Coaches Votes award and made the AA squad of 40.
Or Oliver this year 2024?

Because you said earlier that Cripps 2023 was the same as Oliver this year.

Cripps was better. but never do I ever look at, care about or factor in brownlow votes. It's a joke of an award.

 

[Hippster]

Cripps was better. but never do I ever look at, care about or factor in brownlow votes. It's a joke of an award.

Wouldn’t be for you if Oliver won one.

 

[danster168]

Wouldn’t be for you if Oliver won one.

I'd forget it by the following morning. I honestly give it no credibility. There's no sound argument for the award anymore. it's the simpletons award but no footy nut gives it much attention.

When AA defenders are getting 0 votes it sums it up right there.

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

Is this still a thing fmd.

poll needs to be shut down...It's Cripps by the length of the Flemington Straight.

 

[danster168]

Is this still a thing fmd.

poll needs to be shut down...It's Cripps by the length of the Flemington Straight.

the hell? This thing has been shut down since Oliver won 2 back to back best player in the league coaches award. Cripps' current season is nothing on Oliver's best.

Don't let recency bias fool you. Cripps has had about 5 seasons as bad as Oliver's current season

 

[Dewyyyyy]

the hell? This thing has been shut down since Oliver won 2 back to back best player in the league coaches award. Cripps' current season is nothing on Oliver's best.

Don't let recency bias fool you. Cripps has had about 5 seasons as bad as Oliver's current season

No he has not

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

the hell? This thing has been shut down since Oliver won 2 back to back best player in the league coaches award. Cripps' current season is nothing on Oliver's best.

Don't let recency bias fool you. Cripps has had about 5 seasons as bad as Oliver's current season

Any evidence for this statement? Olivers 2024 is an all time fall from grace. Would be lucky to be in the top 20 for Melbournes bnf right now,

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Carlton imploding but Cripps gotta be a chance for the 10 to take the lead or go very close in the coaches votes this week

 

[Pistol Night]

Any evidence for this statement? Olivers 2024 is an all time fall from grace. Would be lucky to be in the top 20 for Melbournes bnf right now,

You wait until Mad Monday though and he’ll be setting the standard

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

You wait until Mad Monday though and he’ll be setting the standard

Will Joel Smith be getting an invite?

 

[Pistol Night]

Will Joel Smith be getting an invite?

He’d be catering the event id assume

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

He’d be catering the event id assume

Goodwins request?

 

[rye]

 

[YeoShuey]

Anyone saying that Oliver is better is out of their minds.

 

[Dewyyyyy]

Cripps is a ****ing freak

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Close the thread. Clarry is probably BOG at Revolver as Crippa does his speech

 

[Trav 20]

This smiley dopey looking #$%@ is loved by the umpires, but not a serious football pundit thinks he's a great of the game.

Neale won this joke of an award last year yet didn't make All Australian.

But yes, I'd probably be doing you if I was you. I'd hope not to, but I can be a flog too.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

This smiley dopey looking #$%@ is loved by the umpires, but not a serious football pundit thinks he's a great of the game.

Neale won this joke of an awrd last year yet didn't make All Australian.

But yes, I'd probably be doing you if I was you. I'd hope not to, but I can be a flog too.

Cripps was favourite for a reason. Best player this year and had the coaches votes stolen by Fly McRae gifting his love child votes.

Umps were righting the wrongs of Fraudulent Fly

 

[Trav 20]

Cripps was favourite for a reason. Best player this year and had the coaches votes stolen by Fly McRae gifting his love child votes.

Umps were righting the wrongs of Fraudulent Fly

Can you believe Daicos received a Brownlow vote for King's birthday when he was successfully tagged by Neal-Bullen, restricted to 15 disposals and subbed off early in the 4th. Extraordinary. And telling. This bloke is gifted votes.

 

[Dewyyyyy]

This smiley dopey looking #$%@ is loved by the umpires, but not a serious football pundit thinks he's a great of the game.

Neale won this joke of an awrd last year yet didn't make All Australian.

But yes, I'd probably be doing you if I was you. I'd hope not to, but I can be a flog too.

Cripps was great this year, he said it himself it was one of his most consistent seasons. His consistency ontop of dominating games win or loss was the reason for such a high voting count and for how good he was.

29 disposals per game
16 contested possessions
8 clearances
0.7 goals (17 goals)
0.5 goal assists
7 score involvements
5 tackles

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Can you believe Daicos received a Brownlow vote for King's birthday when he was successfully tagged by Neal-Bullen, restricted to 15 disposals and subbed off early in the 4th. Extraordinary. And telling. This bloke is gifted votes.

Was quite laughable

 

[Young Redleg]

Can you believe Daicos received a Brownlow vote for King's birthday when he was successfully tagged by Neal-Bullen, restricted to 15 disposals and subbed off early in the 4th. Extraordinary. And telling. This bloke is gifted votes.

ANB receiving 3 votes would have made more sense than Daicos getting 1 vote

 

[raskolnikov]

At their best I'd still take Oliver. Game changer. Even at his best this year Carlton still limped into finals. Anyway, Oliver has played in a flag which Cripps would gladly trade both Brownlows for.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

At their best I'd still take Oliver. Game changer. Even at his best this year Carlton still limped into finals. Anyway, Oliver has played in a flag which Cripps would gladly trade both Brownlows for.

Cripps not a game changer

 

[p4p1]

At their best I'd still take Oliver. Game changer. Even at his best this year Carlton still limped into finals. Anyway, Oliver has played in a flag which Cripps would gladly trade both Brownlows for.

Cripps played one of the best games I have ever seen against us a few years ago, had 38 and kicked 4.