• Please read this post on the rules on BigFooty regarding posting copyright material, including fair dealing rules. Repeat infringements could see your account limited or closed.

D4 D4 2008

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
spy1 said:
All I know is it has been a super effort on his part to be tagged and double teamed every week yet still play every game this year on a knee that needed surgery back in March.
Click to expand...


Penny may be a good player but him not getting surgery when he needs it shouldn't make him more worthy of a spot in the team of a year
 
smith_ said:
Penny may be a good player but him not getting surgery when he needs it shouldn't make him more worthy of a spot in the team of a year
Click to expand...

You will probably find most blokes running around at this time of year with injuries, some in the T.O.T.Y. some not, probably shouldnt start to say "he should be in becuase of this and that" just pick it on who deserves to be in it.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Dishon destroyed RC six weeks ago on the ball ... And hasn't rated much of a mention here. McIndoe is the best ruck in the league IMO.
 
Coach of the year;
My 3,not in any order
Witchell,Kew;Quietly going about the job.
Hickey,Centrals;Team building for future.
DeBono,Syndal;struggle street with injuries and not able to get best on the paddock but still kept em coming.

For mine there are other factors than winning games.
 
MATT DILLON said:
Coach of the year;
My 3,not in any order
Witchell,Kew;Quietly going about the job.
Hickey,Centrals;Team building for future.
DeBono,Syndal;struggle street with injuries and not able to get best on the paddock but still kept em coming.

For mine there are other factors than winning games.
Click to expand...
whoever is coaching albert park should win coach of the year.
 
FB: G. Ortlip (Kew) - C. Liston (BHN) - L. Hickey (MtL)
CHB: Hansen (AP) - S. Pietsch (WB) - D. Pizzari (NB)
C: B. Cookson (BC) - S. Bennett (AP) - Scott (Kew)
CHF: B. Spencer (SFX) - J. Sudholz (WB) - C. Horne (Kew)
FF: D. Penny (BHN) - D. Viola (EP) - S. Dishon (WB)

Ruck: G. Bell (Kew)
Rovers: M. Rhodes (MtL) B. Irving (WB)

Bench: G. Pearson (SFX) A. Gall (WB)
Thompson (WB) N. Nuske (RC)

Coach: N. Dallas (AP)
 
Allright 'oc37' I will give it a crack-

B- A.Sykes..L.Hickey..L.Nally
HB- S.Nicholls..G.Fink..M.Pulka
C- H.Moyes..A.Rodwell..D.Cerra
HF- A.Leaumont..D.Leaumont..C.Gibson
F- P.Carolan..J.Roberts..F.Varga
R- M.Rhodes..T.Wall..K.Maniscalchi
Bench-J.Paull..S.Garland..N.Hooke..R.Strony..M.Alderman..R.Mckenzie..R.Rantall..M.Bywater

Now I'm sure I've left a couple out, but I can HONESTLY:D say there is no bias in any of my selections.....HONESTLY:D..PROBABLY..MAYBE..I THINK
 
Sneako said:
Allright 'oc37' I will give it a crack-

B- A.Sykes..L.Hickey..L.Nally
HB- S.Nicholls..G.Fink..M.Pulka
C- H.Moyes..A.Rodwell..D.Cerra
HF- A.Leaumont..D.Leaumont..C.Gibson
F- P.Carolan..J.Roberts..F.Varga
R- M.Rhodes..T.Wall..K.Maniscalchi
Bench-J.Paull..S.Garland..N.Hooke..R.Strony..M.Alderman..R.Mckenzie..R.Rantall..M.Bywater

Now I'm sure I've left a couple out, but I can HONESTLY:D say there is no bias in any of my selections.....HONESTLY:D..PROBABLY..MAYBE..I THINK
Click to expand...


Will they line up like that on Saturday?
 
Sneako said:
Allright 'oc37' I will give it a crack-

B- A.Sykes..L.Hickey..L.Nally
HB- S.Nicholls..G.Fink..M.Pulka
C- H.Moyes..A.Rodwell..D.Cerra
HF- A.Leaumont..D.Leaumont..C.Gibson
F- P.Carolan..J.Roberts..F.Varga
R- M.Rhodes..T.Wall..K.Maniscalchi
Bench-J.Paull..S.Garland..N.Hooke..R.Strony..M.Alderman..R.Mckenzie..R.Rantall..M.Bywater

Now I'm sure I've left a couple out, but I can HONESTLY:D say there is no bias in any of my selections.....HONESTLY:D..PROBABLY..MAYBE..I THINK
Click to expand...
That's more like it!!!
 
smith_ said:
Penny may be a good player but him not getting surgery when he needs it shouldn't make him more worthy of a spot in the team of a year
Click to expand...

I was not putting him forward at all. I was saying, in effect, that he was below his best this year. But there were good reasons. We at BHN still admire his effort.

If I were to put people fwd from BHN I'd probably bunk up Irvine at CHB.
Though Machine was again pretty impassable at Full Back he has struggled with injury for the last 6 games.
 
B: Lenders (SFX) Hickey (MTL) Camillieri (RC)

HB: S. Nicholls (MTL) Piestch (WB) Hansen (AP)

C: Scott (Kew) Wall (MTL) Bennett (AP)

HF: O'Connell (Kew) Sudholz (WB) T. Pearson (SFX)

F: Nuske (RC) D. Viola (EP) Horne (Kew)

R: Bell (Kew) Irving (WB) Dishon (WB)

Int: B. Spencer (SFX) D. Penny (BHN) D. Cerra (MTL) Whiting (RC)

Captain: Hickey (MTL) V/C: O'Connell (Kew)
Coach: Dallas (AP) Ass Coach: Pearce (MTL)

Umpire: BigWaz
Trainers: Girls from MTL = 9/10
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ruck Machine said:
FB: G. Ortlip (Kew) - C. Liston (BHN) - L. Hickey (MtL)
CHB: Hansen (AP) - S. Pietsch (WB) - D. Pizzari (NB)
C: B. Cookson (BC) - S. Bennett (AP) - Scott (Kew)
CHF: B. Spencer (SFX) - J. Sudholz (WB) - C. Horne (Kew)
FF: D. Penny (BHN) - D. Viola (EP) - S. Dishon (WB)

Ruck: G. Bell (Kew)
Rovers: M. Rhodes (MtL) B. Irving (WB)

Bench: G. Pearson (SFX) A. Gall (WB)
Thompson (WB) N. Nuske (RC)

Coach: N. Dallas (AP)
Click to expand...

surely McINdoe is the premier ruckman in the comp (from Albert Park)
 
Tunnelball said:
B: Lenders (SFX) Hickey (MTL) Camillieri (RC)

HB: S. Nicholls (MTL) Piestch (WB) Hansen (AP)

C: Scott (Kew) Wall (MTL) Bennett (AP)

HF: O'Connell (Kew) Sudholz (WB) T. Pearson (SFX)

F: Nuske (RC) D. Viola (EP) Horne (Kew)

R: Bell (Kew) Irving (WB) Dishon (WB)

Int: B. Spencer (SFX) D. Penny (BHN) D. Cerra (MTL) Whiting (RC)

Captain: Hickey (MTL) V/C: O'Connell (Kew)
Coach: Dallas (AP) Ass Coach: Pearce (MTL)

Umpire: BigWaz
Trainers: Girls from MTL = 9/10
Click to expand...


I have sighted some comments on this forum regarding the rating's of clubs trainers and I can say with my hand on my heart (yes i said heart) that the Mountain Men have that premiership wrapped up. !!
 
bigwaz said:
YEs they were alright.... Those ML trainers... must be said.
Click to expand...

If we are to rate the best, lets not leave out the worst! I know u guys dont see the same trainers we do this year (not missing much), but hands down, ugliest most disgusting firebox/ralph malph looking, eat an apple through a pickett fence trainer head like a half chewed twistie or dropped pie trainer goes to the EX (and i cant figure how she ever made money out of this career) stripper trainer from elsternwick. She really looks like she ate the three billygoats gruff.

condolences to Elsternwick. No wonder their injuries dont heal, none of them want to go near her for strapping or rubs.
 
Picks for this week

X Men by 10 goals
Syndal by 20 points
Kew by 11 points
Albert Park by 37 points
BHN by 25 points
West Brunswick by 16 goals

If these tips are to be correct the following week will see

Qualifying Final

Kew v X Men

Elimination Final

Albert Park v Mount Lilydale

Should be a cracking finals series. Albert Park must kicking themselves after their close loss to the Mountain Men as it has certainly cost them the double chance.
 
TheMalachiCrunch said:
Picks for this week

X Men by 10 goals
Syndal by 20 points
Kew by 11 points
Albert Park by 37 points
BHN by 25 points
West Brunswick by 16 goals

If these tips are to be correct the following week will see

Qualifying Final

Kew v X Men

Elimination Final

Albert Park v Mount Lilydale

Should be a cracking finals series. Albert Park must kicking themselves after their close loss to the Mountain Men as it has certainly cost them the double chance.
Click to expand...


Last round of 2008:

Nth.B v S.T.HO---Nth.B too finish strong by 6 goals
Sth.M v S.F.X---S.F.X by 12 goals to maybe pinch back 3rd spot
Bull.C v B.H.N---Bull.C in a good one by 10 points
West.B v Rich.C---West.B by 15+
Kew v Mt.L--- Gee, It has to be the Mt.L boys over the line by a goal.(Just about match of the year)
E.Park v A.Park---E.Park in an upset by 2 goals

:thumbsu::thumbsdown:
 
Sneako said:
Last round of 2008:

Nth.B v S.T.HO---Nth.B too finish strong by 6 goals
Sth.M v S.F.X---S.F.X by 12 goals to maybe pinch back 3rd spot
Bull.C v B.H.N---Bull.C in a good one by 10 points
West.B v Rich.C---West.B by 15+
Kew v Mt.L--- Gee, It has to be the Mt.L boys over the line by a goal.(Just about match of the year)
E.Park v A.Park---E.Park in an upset by 2 goals

:thumbsu::thumbsdown:
Click to expand...

Spot on! Should be a ripper.
I went with Kew due to their unbeaten record at home.
 
Sneako said:
Last round of 2008:

Nth.B v S.T.HO---Nth.B too finish strong by 6 goals
Sth.M v S.F.X---S.F.X by 12 goals to maybe pinch back 3rd spot
Bull.C v B.H.N---Bull.C in a good one by 10 points
West.B v Rich.C---West.B by 15+
Kew v Mt.L--- Gee, It has to be the Mt.L boys over the line by a goal.(Just about match of the year)
E.Park v A.Park---E.Park in an upset by 2 goals

:thumbsu::thumbsdown:
Click to expand...

Nth.B v S.T.HO---Nth.B by 41 points - strong finish to the year
Sth.M v S.F.X---S.F.X by 92 points to stenghten a even better %
Bull.C v B.H.N---BHN for mine - 7 points in a close one
West.B v Rich.C---West.B by 113pts No 'Fish' No Richmond
Kew v Mt.L--- Mountain Men by 1 pt in a rip snorter
E.Park v A.Park---AP by 20pts

D.Viola to top the Goal Kickers for the year with 85
 
YellowBlue said:
Nth.B v S.T.HO---Nth.B by 41 points - strong finish to the year
Sth.M v S.F.X---S.F.X by 92 points to stenghten a even better %
Bull.C v B.H.N---BHN for mine - 7 points in a close one
West.B v Rich.C---West.B by 113pts No 'Fish' No Richmond
Kew v Mt.L--- Mountain Men by 1 pt in a rip snorter
E.Park v A.Park---AP by 20pts

D.Viola to top the Goal Kickers for the year with 85
Click to expand...

It will be a tie then as I think Horne will kick 6.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top